6 ms·
A lot of these experiences focus on the driver's experience using the center console while the car is in motion. But, when the car is in motion, the driver real
by vel0city 4y ago
A lot of these experiences focus on the driver's experience using the center console while the car is in motion. But, when the car is in motion, the driver really shouldn't be messing with the stereo or most anything else in the center console. Any controls the driver should need should be available on or immediately around the wheel, where the driver's hands and focus already are.
What about the experience when the car is not in motion, or by the passenger? Personally I like having a large touch screen when going through the media I'd like to play rather than a tiny screen far away. Same for going through the settings of the car. Same when planning out a route or even just entering a destination.
I have a car with a big touchscreen. I have a car with a ton of buttons and a small screen. I prefer the car with the big touchscreen, hands down. When stopped it's a much better experience as I'm almost exclusively using the screen. When driving, I'm practically never pressing any of the buttons on the dashboard. Meanwhile, the screen being much smaller makes the map and directions harder to see, just about the only thing I do bother to to care about on the center console while the car is in motion.
My car with a bunch of buttons has lots of buttons that practically never get pressed. That's such an immense waste of space on that dashboard.
https://arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-tbt.s3.amazonaws.com/public/NKG4ELGGJEI6TCHRIBWI6S7HAY.jpg https://arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-tbt.s3.amazonaws.com/public...
You're telling me having a SETUP button is useful for driving? INFO? BLUELINK? Should I be using the PHONE button to scroll through my address book while driving? No! All of this is essentially a waste of space. I shouldn't be pressing most of these buttons while driving, so the argument of safety of a physical button is moot.
- ARandumGuy 4y agoTouchscreens work well for functionality that the driver shouldn't be touching while in motion. Stuff like adjusting settings or configuring bluetooth. And some car manufacturers do use their touchscreen primarily for these sort of tasks. The issue is when car manufacturers put stuff you need modify while driving in their touchscreen. Stuff like climate controls, pausing music, or switching driving modes. Sometimes these controls have associated buttons on the steering wheel, but not always. This causes issues because it's harder to navigate touch interfaces by feel, which forces the driver to look down at the screen to make necessary changes.
- vel0city 4y ago> Stuff like climate controls, pausing music, or switching driving modes. None of these things are things you need to be doing while actively driving.
- Ichthypresbyter 4y agoClimate controls are the exception there. You may need to switch on the defroster to stop your windshield fogging up.
- vel0city 4y agoThere's little reason why that couldn't be completely automated. The car knows the outside temperature. The car knows the inside temperature and can easily know the humidity. Its pretty basic math to figure out if the window is going to fog up or not. You shouldn't need to engage your defogger, your windows should just never fog in the first place. I do agree though, most cars sold today don't bother automating this and that critical safety controls should be controllable by the driver. I think defrost controls should be controllable on the same stalk that lets you control the windshield wipers, its a pretty similar concept of controlling outside visibility, even if there automatic systems in place to prevent fogging. I don't think it should necessarily be at home on the center console seeing as how its an important safety control a driver should be in charge of and should take precedence over any climate setting.
- devmor 4y agoI view my car as a tool for driving. You seem to view yours as an entertainment center. I think consumer preference sides with you, and thus manufacturers cater more to people with your line of thought, but I don't think your line of thought lines up with safety on the road. When my car is not in motion, I don't care what's on the screen because I'm probably about to get out of it.
- vel0city 4y ago> When my car is not in motion, I don't care what's on the screen because I'm probably about to get out of it. So do you just not stop at stop lights? When you enter your car, do you somehow manage to get it to engage into reverse without you being in it and you jump in it while its moving? No? I guess when you get to a stop light you shift into park and step out of the car then? No? Huh. I guess you probably do spend some amount of time with your car not actively in motion then. > I view my car as a tool for driving. You seem to view yours as an entertainment center. If anything my comment is arguing the opposite. I'm arguing when you're in the driver's seat, and the car is in motion, the only thing you should be doing is driving. You shouldn't be fine tuning to a radio station or changing some other stereo setting. You shouldn't be adjusting the AC. You shouldn't be pressing that PHONE button or BLUELINK or INFO button or NAV button while you're driving the car. You shouldn't really be doing anything on the center console, at all. Both your hands should be on the wheel, and all your attention should be focused on the road ahead, the environment around outside the car, and how your car is currently moving. So with that, it shouldn't matter what the center console is like, because the driver shouldn't be messing with the center console at all while driving. It might as well not even exist to the driver. That's my argument. I'm far more leaning towards your car being a tool for driving when you're in the driver's seat and the car is in motion than you probably are, as I imagine you'll probably say the driver should be adjusting the fine tuning of the radio, the driver should be changing how the AC is blowing, etc. When I'm driving my car, if I can't do it from the steering wheel or the toggles immediately around the steering wheel or is manageable from the voice commands, I don't mess with it when my car is in motion. When I'm at the wheel and the car is in motion, my focus is on driving not playing around with dozens of buttons and knobs and wheels on the center console.
- squaresmile 4y agoI agree. I think touch screen is a balance that should be designed thoughtfully rather than an all or nothing thing. My car isn't the best but I think it struck a good balance. It has a 10" infotainment screen with physical climate control. I much prefer looking at google maps on a bigger compared to using a phone mount. It's easier to glance and get the direction, where I am, next turns with a bigger screen. The steering wheel has change tracks, change mode, volume which is all I ever need while driving and can be navigated by feel without looking at them. A bigger screen also allows for a bigger backup camera view and 360 view. The climate control has knobs to change the temperature which is perfect. > What about the experience when the car is not in motion, or by the passenger? Yep, on the right seat, navigating the map with drag, pinch to zoom is intuitive. Using Android Auto/Carplay without a touchscreen or with a poor one is a miserable experience. My friends have always commented on the intuitive infotainment and thought about replacing the ones on their cars or looking at cars with the same infotainment.
- vel0city 4y agoThere's only one button I press for my climate control, AUTO. Everything else is just a waste of space to me. Auto climate controls with some decent low-emissive tint on my cars have been fine for over 20 years, and I live in a place that gets snow and >100F temperatures over the course of the year, at somewhat low latitude for the US so I get lots of long sunny days. I do agree with the idea that not everything should be behind a screen. There's one button I miss on my car with mostly just a touchscreen. My many-buttoned car has a button to engage the 360 cameras while at a low speed even in drive. That's so useful for parking rather than waiting until I get close to something for the car to automatically show it. But even then, theoretically that could easily be achieved without me needing to press a button. I'd love for there to just be a toggle to say "if I'm creeping and the radar senses I'm probably in a parking lot or garage, engage the cameras". It wouldn't be that hard for the car to tell that I'm going slow in a narrow space with lots of probably-car-like-things on the sensors and cameras.
- squaresmile 4y agoOh my, I also have the same complaint regarding the 360 camera. The 360 camera can be selected in the infotainment but navigating to it takes 2-3 steps which isn't great. However, I have figured out that I can turn on the turn signal and the 360 cam will turn on and stay on after the turn signal is off.
- alexb_ 4y ago> But, when the car is in motion, the driver really shouldn't be messing with the stereo or most anything else in the center console. In a fantasy world where everyone follows every single rule, correct. In the real, actual world, I'm driving 70mph down the highway and want to skip this song without risking my life to do so.
- vel0city 4y agoIn every car I've owned for over 20 years skipping a song is something that can be done from the steering wheel. It would be a less safe choice for me to use the center console to change the track than just using the control on the wheel.
- lazide 4y agoIt is when you’re sitting at a light, or crawling at 2mph on the freeway and can keep an eye on traffic. Do you really think it’s ridiculous to change the radio in those scenarios? Most folks in California would literally never be able to do anything at all to their car otherwise.
- vel0city 4y agoWhen I'm sitting at a light I'd prefer a large and easy to navigate interface to change what playlist I'm in or maybe change to the podcast app or something along those lines instead of a clickwheel. There's a reason why I don't have the MacBook Wheel. When I'm sitting at a stop light and want to change the music, I prefer a big touchscreen versus a single-row seven segment display, several knobs, and a bunch of dials. When I'm wanting to quickly type an address I prefer a QUERTY keyboard on a touchscreen than a list of letters alphabetically and a wheel to scroll and select them.
- lazide 4y agoSure, but that wasn’t the statements I was replying to? I’ve always thought touchscreens were a huge hassle and terrible for anything you needed to do regularly without looking. I bought my current vehicle avoiding touchscreens. But the assertion was it shouldn’t be a thing using any non-driving essential controls at all while driving, correct?
- vel0city 4y ago> It is when you’re sitting at a light, or crawling at 2mph on the freeway and can keep an eye on traffic. Do you really think it’s ridiculous to change the radio in those scenarios? When you're sitting at a light, sure, adjust the stereo, adjust the AC, change your seat position, change your driving mode, do whatever with the center console. You're stopped. Just make sure to start going when the light turns green and the intersection is safe. When you're creeping in stop and go traffic, no, I don't think you should be making lots of stereo adjustments or fiddling with the AC or doing anything else with the center console. Your car is in motion! You should be paying attention to the road! Maybe if we didn't have people fiddling with the center console and actually focusing on just driving we wouldn't have so many rear-end collisions of people crawling in traffic. Why do you think its OK to be distracted when the car is in motion, even if only at low speeds? Why is it OK to be distracted by buttons and knobs but not a screen? In my opinion, doing anything other than driving when the car is moving is less safe than just focusing on driving. But for some reason lots of people here think buttons and knobs are perfectly safe to play with while driving but screens, those are the devil! If the car is in motion, you shouldn't be messing with the center console, at all. And when I drive my cars, when my car is in motion and I'm in the driver's seat, I do not mess with the center console. At all.