3 ms·
They are not proxies because they don't well... proxy your request as in make a second connection on your behalf which is what proxy means. Those VPN services a
by _8j50 4y ago
They are not proxies because they don't well... proxy your request as in make a second connection on your behalf which is what proxy means. Those VPN services are the equivalent of moving your ISP gateway to someone's datacenter somewhere . They are internet gateway VPNs.
I see no deception or nothing misleading about the service they provide. The fact that you need to trust them more than your ISP and country's network is not unclear to anyone, they even advertise "no log" because obviously they can log if they choose to.
It is preposterous that you call them snake oil when there are so many discoveries about ISPs doing mitm on their own behalf or governments and even in the US/west it is a default that they will sale your location and address along other things as a service. You have no choice in the matter because they are monopolies. It is a simple risk calculation that if I trusr some rando vpn provider over my last-mile or country/locality network I can pay to use them to move my trust boundary to their servers. Now marketers and other hostile parties can buy my metadata from a myriad of VPN providers who all risk to lose their whole business if that deal was ever exposed (unlike ISPs).
- jrm4 4y agoI fully understand everything you're saying and you have very good technical points, but (and I would draw this out to a LOT of things in IT) these aren't taken away by MOST USERS. Most users, who are novices in tech, read the "label" of the VPN and presume that they are covered, when we know they are not. SOMEONE should be punished for this because it's effectively a lie. This is the only way we will actually improve the bad situation you're talking about.