4 ms·
> Not housing per-se, but concentrating too many jobs in few locations. Jobs weren't "concentrated" per se by any form of planning or centralized action, emplo
by mschuster91 4y ago
> Not housing per-se, but concentrating too many jobs in few locations.
Jobs weren't "concentrated" per se by any form of planning or centralized action, employers simply shifted to urban centers because the amount of skilled workers and other necessities (such as high speed Internet, universities, road and rail infrastructure) was vastly higher there than in dilapidated flyover-state villages. Additionally, rural areas got devastated by mechanization of agriculture following WW2 and later-on the closure of manufacturing plants and the mining industries [1], which led to a massive rural flight movement as everyone who could fled to the only place where employment was available - urban areas.
The fix to the housing crisis would be to invest in rural areas again - there is no limitation in the nature of the work at all that stuff like a callcenter or a bunch of programmers can't work from some rural town, but as long as there is no actual high speed Internet or no amenities (healthcare, education institutions for children, entertainment) worth their name employers won't establish shop there and employees won't move there. Would you, even for free rent, move to some small town where your children have no perspective?
[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/01/where-did-all-the-workers-go-60-years-of-economic-change-in-1-graph/252018/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/01/where-d...
- seper8 4y agoI read this kind of thinking a lot lately, people trying very hard to come up with solutions that don't address the main issue. Just guessing, you already own a house? The fix is to enable builders to build enough housing, and not just single family detached housing, by removing regulations which allow NIMBY-ism. At the same time, prevent investors from hoarding houses and jacking up the prices. I find it similar to scalping GPU's and reselling them for more money, which was a common practice in the past few years during the chip shortage and crypto mining boom. This kind of investment provides very little value to consumers, and in my view only serves to extract money from the poor to the rich.
- zhdc1 4y ago> The fix is to enable builders to build enough housing, and not just single family detached housing, by removing regulations which allow NIMBY-ism. This is the short term fix, and I completely agree with you. The long term fix is, aside from letting local governments make minor regulatory changes to facilitate denser urban construction, to simply do nothing. Cities are expensive. People will (and are) moving away from HCOL areas because of this. Businesses are adapting (e.g., with remote work) to hire people living in MCOL and LCOL areas. At the same time, new economic agglomerations are springing up in these areas to support growing populations. Given enough time, two things will happen. Many of these MCOL and LCOL areas will become more expensive. Some will urbanize. Some wont. Second, eventually, people living in the areas that don't urbanize will realize that they actually would enjoy living in a HCOL area. And the cycle will continue.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Just guessing, you already own a house? LOL, I wish. Renting in Munich for enough money that I'll never be able to save enough for a downpayment. If I ever want to own my home, I'll have to move to the German equivalent of Alabama, with all the issues that come with that. > The fix is to enable builders to build enough housing, and not just single family detached housing, by removing regulations which allow NIMBY-ism. Where? Seriously, where?! Urban areas literally don't have enough space left any more to build any kind of building at affordable prices (plot values have sometimes doubled over four years here [1]), not to mention the associated followup costs of high-density populations (you need expensive subways as public transport at some point, denser / more anonymous populations leading to lower societal cohesion and rising crime as a result) or the fact that most urban areas simply are unsustainable regarding climate change in the long term (no trees to provide shade = lots of heat). [1] https://www.sueddeutsche.de/muenchen/muenchen-grundstueckspreis-immobilien-bodenrichtwert-1.4580410 https://www.sueddeutsche.de/muenchen/muenchen-grundstueckspr...
- prawn 4y agoIf zoning/regulations were relaxed, the density would almost instantly start to increase. Land value is high where I live, but there would be new, denser building projects in the suburbs and CBDs alike. I'm not arguing that it would be ideal in all cases, but it answers the "where" question.
- seper8 4y agoPlot values have doubled BECAUSE OF regulations! Agricultural land here in the Netherlands sells at 6 euro per m2. With a single stroke of a pen that ground can become 300 euro per m2, when the municipality decides you can build a house there. Same process in Germany. There is more than enough space. Problem is the price of plots is kept artificially high by municipalities, because they rely on the easy money it provides to finance their projects.
- Ekaros 4y agoOn other hand if municipality is struggling to attract people in Finland, they will give those plots of lands for essentially free. Or that is nominal cost of 1€ . Actually transaction happens when construction begins. Then again those prices are in dying areas with little going on.
- TuringNYC 4y ago>> The fix is to enable builders to build enough housing, and not just single family detached housing, by removing regulations which allow NIMBY-ism. I remember when Mayor DeBlasio (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_de_Blasio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_de_Blasio) was running for Mayor in NYC. He was hugely against high-rise high-density condos in Brooklyn adjacent (4th Ave) to expensive $2M+ brownstones (incidentally where he lived, in Park Slope!) He was the "left" candidate and didnt seem to understand the concept of supply and demand. Nor the concept that no every city dweller can afford a $2M brownstone. The problem is that Left and Right alike wants to perpetuate the system because they are all so fully bought into the system. I'm sure Mayor DeBlasio fully understood the economics here, but supported NIMBYism because he and his money base wants to keep their wealth. That also means this isnt a left or right issue, its more of a hopeless issue. The only way out is to buy into the system and join them.
- noahtallen 4y ago> The fix to the housing crisis would be to invest in rural areas again There’s actually a really big, fundamental problem with this approach. Cities hugely subsidize rural infrastructure already. Tax income generated by rural (and even suburban) developments can’t repay the construction and maintenance cost required for upkeep. Partly because it’s not dense, and partly because typical rural/suburban economic development looks like a stroad with chain restaurants and huge parking lots. (Where most of the land isn’t being economically productive, and the land that is isn’t really boosting the local economy that much.) https://youtu.be/7Nw6qyyrTeI https://youtu.be/7Nw6qyyrTeI