3 ms·
The binding energy of the carbon dioxide taken from the Martian atmosphere is much less than the binding energy of the metal oxides from the Martian rocks. So
by adrian_b 4y ago
The binding energy of the carbon dioxide taken from the Martian atmosphere is much less than the binding energy of the metal oxides from the Martian rocks.
So the thermal decomposition of the rocks will require much more energy.
As you say, the thermal decomposition could be done directly with solar light, bypassing the conversion efficiency of the photovoltaic cells.
That brings the energy requirements to similar values. Which would be the more efficient process would depend on details, e.g. the type of photovoltaic cells, the exact composition of the rocks whose decomposition is attempted, the usefulness of the byproducts, e.g. reduced carbon or reduced metals, and so on.
When taking into account the byproducts, it is likely that both processes will be needed anyway.