3 ms·
To be more exact: If the goal is to remove fossil CO2 that is already in the air, then this process is doing more than it needs to and so won't compete with ju
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
To be more exact:
If the goal is to remove fossil CO2 that is already in the air, then this process is doing more than it needs to and so won't compete with just running their system and using the output from the first step as a chemical feedstock instead of using extra energy to turn it into a classic fuel.
But, the key missing option is 3) use the electricity you were going to use to make the fuel to do the end task directly and much more efficiently, and without fossil or recycled carbon being involved.
Their pitch is a bit like: “Someone else has invented the replicator machine that makes any food you want in Star Trek and our business will use that basically free, essentially limitless food as an input to our bioreactors to make Quorn meat substitutes."
Quorn is a good thing now, when meat involves expensive, cruelty, waste, carbon and disease. Once you have near limitless food on tap though, it becomes a very niche product.
- ncmncm 4y agoQuorn, by the way, turns my stomach. I could not finish a meal of Quorn without losing it and needing to start over. Fortunately there are now better alternatives, and Quorn can go quietly out of business.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThe only thing stopping everything from being solar powered is you may not have a solar panel and sunlight when and where you want to use the energy. Batteries solve this somewhat, but are big, heavy, and expensive. Fuels are small, light, cheap to store, and inefficient. You're not going to want to store energy for 6 months with batteries even if they hit the $30-60/kWh range. You're not going to want to store energy as fuel for a few days unless you really need to pick it up and move it. Solar derived fuels are nearly competitive with nuclear ($130/MWh with maybe $10-20/MWh to burn it according to this claim https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2021-08/12-proton-ceramics-using-ammonia.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2021-08/12-proton... vs $100 for nuclear). Other safer fuels are not far behind for applications closer to people. The energy component of that cost is going to halve or better on a fairly predictable schedule around 2035, so if the cost of the manufacture can be brought down to half or better there's not really any reason to continue with fossil fuels. So the correct metaphor is a replicator that only makes perishable non refrigeratable foods on public holidays. To be able to eat the rest of the time you'll need to make a lot of soup even though you don't really like soup. Also worth noting is this particular project is just buzzword soup that absolutely reeks of a pump and dump scam, and is closely tied to y combinator. Please don't dismiss real e fuel projects when they run off with a few billion dollars of investor money in two years. Edit: found their news article where they break down costs a bit, might not he a scam -- the slicm marketing still reeks of solar roadways though.