4 ms·
i don't think it is these laws that reduce the birthrate. as far as i can see the birthrate correlates with living standards and education levels. higher educat
by em-bee 4y ago
i don't think it is these laws that reduce the birthrate. as far as i can see the birthrate correlates with living standards and education levels. higher education, access to and knowledge about contraception, more opportunity for alternative entertainment, not needing kids to take care of you in old age, are all factors that lower the birthrate. cost may be a factor too, but i believe that the cost of raising kids in 3rd word countries is still takes a greater part of their income than it is in 1st world countries.
france has the highest birthrate in europe, followed by ireland and sweden. i don't know what ireland and sweden are doing, but i understand that france offers infant daycare, allowing more parents to work.
as for this article, it specifically talks about families getting a third child when they already have two in car-seat age. it looks to me that the problem is not cost, but possibly the fact that many cars can't fit three car seats in the back.
this comment from the original discussion, and the study authors response also seem to support that idea:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24648548 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24648548
- somenameforme 4y agoBut correlation is not the same as causation. In the past those of means and education continued to raise large families, and in the present exceptions abound. Israel: 3rd most educated country in the world, strong economy, fertility rate of 3. Thailand: about 50% do not even complete high school, relatively poor country, fertility rate of 1.5 - even lower than the US (1.8). European numbers are largely controlled by Islamic populations. Pew carried out an interesting study [1] on the numbers. The Islamic fertility rate in France is 2.9, the non-Islamic fertility rate is 1.9. In Sweden it's 2.8 vs 1.8. There is no European country with a non-Islamic fertility rate over 2. Ireland is the highest at exactly 2.0. The fact that these extreme trends exist even within Western countries, emphasize that it's primarily a cultural issue. I am not implying the West should adopt Islamic social views, but the irony is that we will end doing exactly that if nothing changes simply because they are reproducing in healthy numbers while non-Islamic groups are not. [1] - https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/11/29/europes-growing-muslim-population/ https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/11/29/europes-grow...
- em-bee 4y agothose are good points, but they don't contradict livingstandards as a cause. what caused the culture in europe to change? the islamic population in europe is very young. first and second generation mostly. if living standards and education are the cause it's going to take a few more generations before the effect of that set in.
- somenameforme 4y agoPerhaps so, it'll be interesting to see. As for my opinion of what caused culture to change, I think there's a nice way to reshape the question in an identical way. There's the interesting issue of how a middle class individual may state that they can't have kids right now because of the cost. Yet a lower class individual will happily do so and make things work, one way or the other. Obviously the middle class individuals could afford to have children and make it work if they genuinely wanted to do so, but it might be uncomfortable and require some sacrifice. So it all comes down to priorities. So the question isn't why people stopped having children, but why priorities shifted so radically away from what is ultimately the most fundamentally important responsibility of humanity? In the US from 1960-1980 many things happened. And one of these was a precipitous decline in fertility rates, plummeting by about 50% to where it would roughly stay to present day. It's quite unfortunate so many things happened in such a short time frame, because it enables one to create a reasonably compelling case for nearly any argument, including the common economic and educational (though those have many issues outside of this time frame). One thing that also happened during that period was a dramatic decline in religiosity. And IMO that left a vacuum for meaning in society. And that vacuum seems to have been filled, for most, by indulgent hedonism that would gradually transition into consumerism. Drugs, the "sexual revolution", and various other issues skyrocketed during this period. This would further transition into the endless pursuit of the ever more expensive next shiny thing, be those Jordans, iThing, or exotic/expensive selfies for social media image crafting. And what could be more antithetical to this shift in values and priorities than doing something that "might be uncomfortable and require some sacrifice"? There's certainly nothing more rewarding or fulfilling than raising a family, but that reward comes at immense cost and time. --- Ok, I wanted to hit more on how this hypothesis can also work as a casual explanation for the commonly observed correlations (education, income, etc) related to lower birth rates, but this post is already getting far longer than intended.