10 ms·
FWIW Ford was hiring around this area (southern Ontario) for software engineers to work on their in-car systems like this. Not sure if this specific one. From w
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
FWIW Ford was hiring around this area (southern Ontario) for software engineers to work on their in-car systems like this. Not sure if this specific one. From what I've heard they were woefully underpaying. A friend of mine talked to them -- very qualified; like me he worked on similar touchscreen, interactive display type systems at Google/Nest, and had a general background on similar systems, and on QNX, etc. They tried to lowball him badly. Like 1/2 the rate he asked for (contract) and probably 1/3rd or 1/4 what we made at Google. I saw a posting from them recently, again, and they were crowing about how they wanted to see candidate's GPA's etc. etc. I don't have a degree, so even if I hadn't heard about their low pay, I wouldn't even consider applying despite being probably very qualified for what they were doing. We had a whole team at Google that worked on getting rid of "jank" and improving FPS and performance on a really low-spec SoC. I wasn't any kind of expert on that team, but I learned a little. But they clearly weren't willing to pay reasonable for talent (like most local Canadian employers, frankly)
All of this to say: You get what you pay for.
- Dig1t 4y agoI completely agree with your conclusion, this is why I feel that European tech companies can't compete with US ones at all. They just refuse to pay enough to attract the best engineers.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoWell here's a North American company clearly not willing to pay competitive software engineering rates even within the continent, and trying to take advantage of sub-regional low rates. Like, they're not in Toronto, but just west of it, and companies there are paying less, so, hey, they should pay less, too, right? You get what you pay for. This is what happens when HR drones are allowed to do naive "compensation range surveys" for regions. They do not understand the subtleties of the market and try to lump people with specialized skills, lots of experience, etc. in with people fresh off the boat from overseas, pumping out bug fixes for boring internal legacy J2EE systems at ancient insurance companies. Companies like this will be in real trouble if remote work continues to be a thing. They better hope it doesn't.
- denkmoon 4y ago>Companies like this will be in real trouble if remote work continues to be a thing. They better hope it doesn't. Would be much healthier for humanity overall if these poorly managed companies, you know, just died from their poor management.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoOr at least outsourced the software engineering to companies that would do a proper job of it.
- usefulcat 4y agoWhich would probably still cost more than what they’re willing to pay, assuming that (cost) is indeed the problem.
- flir 4y agoI've found that paying companies a big pile of cash to do a thing is much more acceptable than paying an individual a big pile of cash to do the same thing. I don't know why. Risk management maybe.
- irrational 4y agoIf the person is a full time employee you have to pay benefits and you can’t just fire them when the project is done. Easier to just contract it out.
- ismailegilmez 4y agoYeah, I totally agree with that. It might be better to just contract the job out.
- vanilla_nut 4y agoIf recent US policy is any indication, it's far more likely that we'll give them billions of dollars of direct subsidy in a misguided attempt "protect American interests."
- megablast 4y agoWhat a strange comment. Ford is a us tech company. Most people in Europe don’t want to leave.
- jonnybgood 4y agoFord is not a tech company. > Most people in Europe don’t want to leave. I believe they're saying if European tech companies want to compete in business with US tech companies they need to pay their engineers more money.
- jbay808 4y ago> Ford is not a tech company. By what standard?
- jonathankoren 4y agoSoftware is not their primary business.
- chrisseaton 4y agoIf you mean ‘software company’ then say that - software isn’t the only form of technology - drive trains are also technology.
- jbay808 4y agoIs SpaceX a tech company?
- speed_spread 4y ago> Ford is not a tech company. By their CEO's own admission, Ford sees itself as a "data company": https://www.autoblog.com/2016/01/06/ceo-mark-fields-ford-data-company/ https://www.autoblog.com/2016/01/06/ceo-mark-fields-ford-dat... Their software chops are certainly dubious, but there is no questioning their intent when it comes to entering the surveillance economy.
- sleepydog 4y agoAre there any professions in European countries that are paid as well as US tech workers, for similar levels of skill and/or education? Moreover, if EU tech companies are not willing to pay the best software/hardware engineers what they're worth, where do they all go? Not everyone wants to live in the US or work remotely.
- boc 4y agoDespite the general online sentiment, it's important to realize that the average American makes an absurd amount of money compared to their global peers. Even adjusting for PPP and other factors, average disposable household income for the US - a nation of 340M people - blows the doors off Luxembourg, Switzerland, Norway, etc. [1]. What's more though, median disposable income per capita ALSO places the US at the very top in the world, which is super impressive. All of this is to say that the US is actually a very wealthy place for the white collar worker demographic, so companies need to pay high salaries to attract employees. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_household_and_per_capita_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_household_and_per_c...
- greesil 4y agoAnd yet, I can't afford a house. I guess I'll go buy another Tesla.
- brigade 4y agoAs much as you can't afford a home in the US, you wouldn't be able to afford to buy a home in Europe even harder.
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y agoA flat in a nice part of Barcelona can be had for €300k.
- suction 4y ago
- bergenty 4y agoHow does Europe make it work? Lower salaries, higher cost of living. Is it just that so many essentials are handled by the government? Or are they still coasting on the colonial wealth (this doesn’t seem likely)
- Strom 4y agoCost of living is way lower in Europe, especially if you also account for health care and higher education.
- rasz 4y agoEuropeans use weird tricks like charging two digit margin on medication, socialized education, and taxing fuel to pay for road maintenance.
- ceeplusplus 4y agoThey also use weird tricks like underpaying health staff (doctors and nurses make 40% of what they do in the US, look at NHS salary tables), relying on US defense subsidies, and taxing everyone making over 100k at insane rates. We already have "socialized education" in public schools in most blue states if you make under 120k. The financial aid is generous enough that you aren't paying any tuition. The 70k sticker price is only paid by wealthy students, as a means of price discrimination.
- m000 4y ago> doctors and nurses make 40% of what they do in the US Oh, those US nurses living the high life. > relying on US defense subsidies It's more like "keeping the US defense industry afloat by buying expensive gadgets we don't need".
- ceeplusplus 4y ago> Oh, those US nurses living the high life. More like oh, those UK nurses in the poorhouse. They deserve to make what their US counterparts are making. > It's more like "keeping the US defense industry afloat by buying expensive gadgets we don't need" Yes, because that's what's defending Europe against Russian invasion, right? Expensive gadgets you don't need? Or is Germany's broken down, dysfunctional army [1] going to do that? [1] https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-biggest-enemy-threadbare-army-bundeswehr/amp/ https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-biggest-enemy-thread...
- woevdbz 4y agoHaving worked in both US and Europe I think this is very much less about average engineer and much more about engineering management and product management. There are many excellent software engineers in Europe already, and they are generally OK being paid much less than in the US. But the strategy, ambition, and execution discipline imparted by management are not there, so folks end up being underutilized there. The average engineer - even at a FAANG - often gets lionized but really isn't that amazing IMO.
- nemo44x 4y agoYes, in the industry Euro engineers are considered to be generally high quality and underpaid. A good value. The danger being there are awful ones too that are hard to fire. In my experience Euro devs are really good though if you interview well. Individual contributors from Europe are generally a great value. Euro managers however are generally thought to be of extremely low quality and unreliable as well as 20-30 years dated in terms of running an org. Except at the top, never rely on senior or middle management in Euro to be much more than followers. Never let them run an org unless you really know them as their management techniques do not apply to modern software companies. Managers from Europe are generally of poor quality.
- spaniard89277 4y agoSad to hear. What differences did you notice?
- nemo44x 4y agoYou see it everywhere but in general I see a lot of superficiality in Euro managers. They love to have direct reports, but because they need them but because it makes them feel more official. This is more frequent in Euro in my experience. You don't see outside the box thinking as much. Very vanilla approaches to things that are generally dated approaches. A culture that lacks innovation. You see a bit of gaming the system to meet KPI goals. Things that are probably not useful to the company but help them hit a defined goal. Just not very aggressive in their approach to the business. A very conservative business culture that doesn't really understand scale and is obsessed with throwing lots of bodies at a problem rather than finding novel and innovative approaches. Insistence that "this won't work here" when that's just not generally true. It's that they don't understand why the approach works and are stuck in older approaches to things that are not relevant to todays business world. Secretive and inward looking.
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoIt's not just the pay, it's the attitude of both middle and upper management that is woefully inadequate as well.
- jfim 4y agoDo they have the margins that allows them to pay equivalent salaries? From what I recall, Meta and Google have gross revenues on the order of one million in revenue per employee, while SAP AG has revenue per employee around 200k.
- grog454 4y agoWhat is their profit per employee ignoring employee compensation? That tells you more about how much they can pay employees.
- assttoasstmgr 4y agoThis. The OP wrote: > They tried to lowball him badly. Like 1/2 the rate he asked for (contract) and probably 1/3rd or 1/4 what we made at Google FAANG arrogance never ceases to amaze me. It's like these guys live in a different universe blissfully unaware of the world around them. Did it ever occur to him maybe Ford is paying normal average human salaries and not grossly inflated Google wages? Remember Ford (and this analogy extends to most companies in traditional industries) still has to be able to sell cars to the average blue collar Joe at a price point he can afford, and still turn a profit. Outside SV most people don't drive $80k Teslas. Somebody's still gotta write software for the $16k econoboxes. I'm sorry but nobody deserves to get paid more than e.g. a specialist doctor to hack JavaScript code I don't care how smart you think you are, when there's a guy in India probably just or nearly as good at it who'll do the job for $40k/year. FAANG is swimming in money and can afford to piss away $$ in talent wars, artificially driving up salaries and the prices of everything else, which is why no average person can afford a house in SF anymore. Those that won the FAANG lottery and managed to cash in? God bless them. But don't let the reality distortion field make you think that's how the rest of the world works.
- WatchDog 4y agoI agree mostly with your points, other than when you get into how much the cars cost. The unit price of the cars isn't really relevant to the cost of developing it's software. A low cost model that moves sells a lot of units, can likely afford to spend more on software compared to a high cost model that moves only a few units.
- pronlover723 4y agoI honestly think having an underpowered low-spec SoC is a huge problem. Sure, if you have top programmers who have experience writing low-level code and best in practice algorithms and data structures for speed you can get that low-spec SoC to have a good experience. But, I think the odds of you getting/retaining, and finding more of those types of programmers is low. So soon you have some programmers trying to cram python or javascript or lua in the underpowered SoC and using Qt or some other wholly inappropriate high-level API and then you end up with those gas station gas pump computers that take 3-9 seconds to respond to single clicks. Of course having high-powered SoCs won't guarantee you'll get performant displays either but I think have low-powered ones generally guarantees failure except for maybe some initial small team of experts.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoIt's super easy to blow your budget on a higher-spec'd SoC, too. We made responsive applications on 1980s era 16-bit and 8-bit computers. We did it by being conscious of what we were doing in each cycle. There's a huge budget to burn on even an older super cheap SoC. Often what is making the screen lag is accidental stupid pointless idle states (blocking on I/O etc.) inside tight animation loops. Lag and jank aren't usually a throughput problem, but a latency problem. Diagnosing and fixing this requires concern and effort and recognition that it's actually super important to the consumer experience. You get what you pay for.
- jcadam 4y agoThe software in my 2021 F-150 ecoboost is... flakey. It seems like every OTA update fixes one bug and introduces another.... At least I can now get my iPhone to connect semi-reliably without restarting the truck :/ If I don't keep the various sensors clean (I live on a dirt road in Alaska) the collision mitigation system can get a bit... touchy.
- bluedino 4y agoMy 2015 F150 had a TERRIBLE interface for navigation https://youtu.be/Py92XdJwgqo?t=62 https://youtu.be/Py92XdJwgqo?t=62
- devwastaken 4y agoUniversity types infect the private market. They think they can turn programmers into standard office workers to lower their pay. And, unfortunately, they're right. Consumers will buy, so no need to produce quality. They can slave away graduates that have to pay back loans and have 0 guidance on the market or how to negotiate. All apart of the plan.
- kensai 4y agoExcuse me guys, but I think your comments although interesting for their story are out of place here. The Verge articles talks about a slow computer. The F150 issues can literally be fixed if Ford decides to install a quicker one on MY23. What does this thing have to do with software engineers payment and the rant that followed?
- nemothekid 4y ago>The F150 issues can literally be fixed if Ford decides to install a quicker one on MY23. I’m unconvinced the problem can be fixed by “installing a quicker computer”. The functionality here isn’t materially different from what Tesla offered almost 10 years ago at this point. If nearly 10 years of hardware advancements couldn’t close the gap, a marginally faster computer next year won’t do it either.
- adrianN 4y agoYou're assuming that the processor they're using today is ten years more advanced than what Tesla was shipping ten years ago. Automotive is very conservative. I wouldn't be surprised if the processor used here were very old indeed.
- kensai 4y agoThe unavoidable Tesla comparison sorry, I am not convinced. What functionality is better? Not everybody is interested in fart apps or Steam games or other questionable "extra" functionality. OK, let's just say that Tesla has better software. It lacks however in other departments, such a build quality. But fact of the matter is here the following: if one reads The Verge article, his complains are mainly about the slow software and some unlabeled functionality here and there. Which can easily be fixed in a future iteration (ie MY23). He does not complain about the software being "that bad" or needing to offer fart apps or anything. Just slow. Hardware problem, not software. And yes, the same applies for many car companies, even ones that sell premium products (BMW, etc). They need to offer faster processors.
- fastball 4y ago
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoAs a candidate who turned down an offer, I can confirm they were not even hitting the margins.
- deepGem 4y agoI see this sentiment everywhere outside the tech first ecosystem. In the generalization of 'workers'/'engineers' v/s 'supervisors'/'managers', programmers are often seen as just workers. For whatever reason, an MBA or even a BBA is seen as an officer/supervisor. Even product teams at tech first companies tend to represent this dogma. There are exceptions but the programmers are workers dogma is prevalent in this world. This is the main reason for suppressed pay for programmers and software engineers in all other industries except tech. Because of this, these other industries will never be able to catch up on the areas of hardware/software interfaces, let alone pure software craftsmanship. On the contrary, the software craftsmen are now learning the tropes of the non-software world and turning craftsmen in those areas as well. So yeah, Ford might make a fast car, they will almost never be able to build a software driven car, which is the car of the future.
- KronisLV 4y ago> ... they will almost never be able to build a software driven car, which is the car of the future. Software can make a lot of things better, but for whatever reason most cars end up with closed software solutions with a limited amount of updates, problems with how responsive/inefficient they are and a plethora of other complications. At that point, slapping an Android tablet on the dash for navigation might be a better idea, since at least that can be changed out or customized with relatively few issues, versus being stuck with a flawed built in system that's a black box as far as you're concerned. Alas, why even pay for that? Why not have a car with a simple dash, less electronics and simply mounts for you to bring your own. Of course, that's not the direction in which the industry seems to be headed. Now, this might be a silly comparison, but I can't help but to think of comparing a simple soviet tractor (say, a T-25 https://de-m-wikipedia-org.translate.goog/wiki/T-25?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en&_x_tr_pto=wapp https://de-m-wikipedia-org.translate.goog/wiki/T-25?_x_tr_sl... ) which is simple to use and repair, to something like a modern John Deere. Perhaps that's one of the better examples, where the more complex design ends up rather expensive, even if you don't need all of the features. But the former, simpler design? Well, somehow ones like that aren't manufactured much nowadays. Surely in regards to cars it should also be possible to pick the essentials (e.g. in regards to safety and security) and then offer plenty of different models, with varying different levels of technology embedded. Then again, it's easier to pump up the price if you cram more features in even in the basic models. Of course, it's not like that would be okay if those closed systems were to be replaced with open source either - since that might be a serious safety liability.
- afandian 4y agoMeanwhile people in Myanmar are desperate enough to pump poisonous chemicals into mountainsides to make magnets for motors. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32489998 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32489998