3 ms·
> I never quite understood how competitive bidding processes usually end up with similar outcomes. Its not competitive bidding processes; government contractin
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> I never quite understood how competitive bidding processes usually end up with similar outcomes.
Its not competitive bidding processes; government contracting before competitive bidding became the norm with exceptions requiring justification was much more prone to this kind of failure (to the point where it wasn't even a newsworthy failure.)
> If the government needs a Dell server
IF the government needs a Dell server, there are generally exceptions to bidding requirements that would allow a sole-source purchase, direct from Dell. While this might have has much bureaucratic overhead as bidding arrangements, its completely different bureaucratic overhead.
OTOH, Dell mostly sells commodity servers; and the government rarely just wants to buy a server, it wants to but a server with specified forms of support. So, what actually happens even if the government official for whom the purchasing is being done expects that a Dell server with first party support from Dell would be the best option is that there is competitive bidding processes where vendors able to provide a commodity server with the necessary functionality and support bid.
Actually, that’s not really true either, because basically no government is doing competitive bids for a server. What they actually do for many things, and commodity servers and associated support would usually fall into it, is a have master contracts that are either sole-source or competitive bid with set prices and schedules for a high level part of government (GSA does this at the federal level, and some of them can be used by tribal, state, and local government as well, either generally or for specific uses; most states also do it at the state level, and individual state agencies and local governments also do it), and individual programs that need something just buy off the master contracts made above them. At the scale of a single server, if it wasn't off a master contract, they wouldn't have a high-formality post and bid, though if they didn't have a sole source justification they'd probably need to solicit quotes from multiple vendors.
> Quite why there isn’t competition I don’t know. Maybe writing bids really is that expensive?
It’s expensive for a genuine competitive bidding process, which tends to be long, drawnn out, and have a hard requirement for at least three bidders, at least two of whom will fail. Maybe not considered over the long term, with multiple opportunities, some of which succeed, put you have a lot at risk, and a long time between putting resource in and getting sales out, so not every business can do it.