9 ms·
I worked at a company where this was an issue at one point (granted this was one situation among a lot of employees). A manager was pretty much dismissive of e
by duxup 4y ago
I worked at a company where this was an issue at one point (granted this was one situation among a lot of employees). A manager was pretty much dismissive of everything anyone of a lower caste did / wouldn't communicate with them effectively.
HR absolutely struggled with the issue. The HR folks tasked with dealing with discrimination issues largely had spent their time constructing company wide emails and classes that revolved around white folks discriminating against others / concepts of privilege, absolutely froze when faced with a discrimination issue outside that stereotype.
Long story short legal eventually was the brave one and decided that yes it was discrimination and the manager in question was asked to move on. The folks he refused to work with were compensated and their status in the company (pay scale, etc) was corrected.
As one of my Indian college's observed about the manager in question "If he was white this would have been dealt with sooner."
Credit to my Indian coworkers who really pushed this issue with HR and made legal act in the end. They wanted nothing to do with this kind of behavior.
- BurningFrog 4y ago
- azinman2 4y agoOr the fact that people discriminate against others, everywhere in the world! Often way worse than in the contemporary US!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tartakovsky 4y ago@BurningFrog, your comment itself smacks of bigotry, ironically. It seems to denigrate rather than enlighten and provide a solution. Also nowhere in the parent comment does it state that the HR employee themselves was not a POC (person of color).
- negamax 4y ago100x this. I told a white SJW colleague that I never felt discriminated by whites, I am a PoC. I was told "You are naive" People take a really small sample set and paint the whole world with a very wide brush
- colpabar 4y agoAs a white person, I'm so sorry to hear about your internalized racism. /s In all seriousness though, this is an aspect I really detest about anything related to "diversity". It doesn't really seem like it's actually about helping anyone, but more an opportunity for white people to pat themselves on the back without really doing anything other than policing language. All the people I know who "care" about diversity only started caring when it became part of their job.
- akomtu 4y agoIt's corporate priesthood. Their job is to defend dogmas, and their greatest enemy is reason. The moniker "dei" isn't an accident.
- krainboltgreene 4y agoThe parent of your comment wasn't talking about non-white people feeling discriminated by whites.
- bottled_poe 4y agoThere seems to be a sad irony of discrimination in this.
- tartakovsky 4y agoI agree, it is sad and HN has a tradition of not condoning this kind of comment, :shrug:. I tried to call it out, too.
- outworlder 4y ago> A lot of the contemporary left (...) You lost me here. Please stop slotting everything into 'left' or 'right'. If you said "a lot of people" I would agree.
- HideousKojima 4y agoI've only ever seen the claims "non-whites can't be racist" and "racism is prejudice plus power" from the left, so I'm not sure what issue you're taking with him here. Sure, not every single leftist believes that tripe, but that belief is essentially exclusive to leftists. Not all mammals are dogs, but all dogs are mammals.
- colpabar 4y ago> HR absolutely struggled with the issue. The HR folks tasked with dealing with discrimination issues largely had spent their time constructing company wide emails and classes that revolved around white folks discriminating against others / concepts of privilege, absolutely froze when faced with a discrimination issue outside that stereotype. Cue the pro DEI (i honestly don’t know what it’s called anymore) people claiming this wasn’t “real DEI”.
- gedy 4y agoMaybe "no true Scotsmxn" etc
- colpabar 4y agoLol. I think it'd have to be "Scotsperson" or "Scotshuman" or "Scotsfolk" - the X is usually reserved for a vowel that indicates masculine or feminine, like the super popular "latinx" that's totally used by more than just rich white liberals.
- arethuza 4y agoFortunately you can just use "Scot" :-)
- naniwaduni 4y ago"Scotsmxn" just reads to me as "Scots-mexican".
- rayrey 4y agoHaggis tacos!
- sirmarksalot 4y agoNot sure what point you're trying to make here. Are you arguing that companies shouldn't have DEI initiatives because they didn't help sufficiently in this case? Do you interpret this as evidence that DEI is somehow bad?
- pm90 4y agoI don’t think this is some sort of malicious conspiracy or evidence of anti whiteness or whatever. Processes are created for the common case and when there is an uncommon scenario, it is new territory for everyone involved and someone has to be responsible. In most corporate environments, nobody wants to be that person so inaction is generally the norm unless the course of action is straightforward or has precedent.
- teakettle42 4y agoIt’s a blind spot in DEI and intersectionality; the idea that an oppressed class can also be an oppressor class, and that it’s not an attribute of the perpetrator’s class at all, but in fact, situational and individual.
- pm90 4y agoAgreed. In tech especially, certain minority groups (East and South Asians) are over represented so our processes must evolve to deal with the situations that result from them.
- colpabar 4y agoI'd rather the processes evolve to treat all discrimination on factors such as race or caste as bad, regardless of the race or caste of the people doing the discriminating.
- pnathan 4y ago> It’s a blind spot in DEI and intersectionality; the idea that an oppressed class can also be an oppressor class, and that it’s not an attribute of the perpetrator’s class at all, but in fact, situational and individual. what's really bleakly funny is that you're right - that's how it's taken, but that's actually a major _point_ of intersectionality.
- morelisp 4y agoWell, "DEI" in the end is the neoliberalization of (the capitalist-corporate-compatible parts of) intersectionality, so it's not really surprising that something of significant value was lost in the appropriation.
- draw_down 4y ago
- fritztastic 4y agoMost likely they struggled because the legal language in policies was ambiguous on how to handle the situation, therefore opening the room for the manager to pursue action against the company for consequences for their behavior. It would have been dealt with sooner if the employee was white because (assuming they meant white as in western white skinned person) culturally there isn't an equivalent of caste that would make sense for a white person to act on, and they could have acted based on the other groups listed in the anti-discrimination language. I think it's good they found a way to go forward with dealing with the manager and compensated the employees. In a visit to India a few years ago I saw a shopkeeper make someone leave the store because of caste, not sure if there are actual laws/regulations about this in place there to simplify the process of handling discrimination. The issue of discrimination is very easy to find anywhere, though, and most often presents in a subtle form of prejudice because many people feel a certain way toward others in another group. Anywhere there aren't enforced laws with legal language that protects a group there will be difficulty dealing with discriminatory practices against said group, because laws have to be specific in the way they are written to allow for their enforcement being simple/easy.
- adamsmith143 4y ago> Most likely they struggled because the legal language in policies was ambiguous on how to handle the situation, therefore opening the room for the manager to pursue action against the company for consequences for their behavior. How? Do you really think their language specified that discrimination could only happen from white people to minorities?
- richiebful1 4y agoMy understanding of the situation is that Western countries/companies don't usually have protected class status on basis of caste. Those protections exist for race, gender, age etc.
- adamsmith143 4y agoOk are there also specific legal protections for Eye color, Hair Color, presence of Freckles, etc? Does every possible way to discriminate need to be clearly spelled out for it to be illegal?
- shreyshnaccount 4y agoironic how discrimination classes kinda discriminated against other minorities by focusing mainly on white people. this has to be a The Office plot line
- hintymad 4y agoCurious, why did HR "struggled with the issue", and why it was a brave thing to decide that it was discrimination? I hope it's not the so-called multiculturalism.
- hintymad 4y agoNot sure why the question, an honest one, got down voted. My assumption was that discrimination is bad, no matter which culture it comes from. So, the HR should investigate or intervene per my assumption. And then per my experience with the western movement, people hesitate to judge other cultures because of the multiculturalism, hence my hope it's not that.
- jl6 4y agoIn the UK, class and ethnicity and accent intersect to create some similarly “invisible to HR” discrimination situations between people who would otherwise be lumped together as white.
- registeredcorn 4y agoCould you explain what you mean, a bit more?
- jl6 4y agoClass discrimination is a big thing, and it’s related to accent discrimination and somewhat to ethnicity too. There is no shortage of stereotypes associated with regional accents (apologies, but to illustrate: cockney = untrustworthy; West Country = unsophisticated; Yorkshire = blunt, miserly; RP = haughty). Accent is judged alongside class (which I won’t attempt to define here). Ethnicity comes into the picture with groups such as travellers (who have only recently been recognized as an ethnic group) and showmen (who disclaim being one), and Jewish ethnicity is also often ignored as “just another kind of white” (see David Baddiel’s book Jews Don’t Count). Then there are Scottish and Welsh people and maybe even sub-national groupings like Cornish, where ethnicity and accent and class interact in complex ways. These groupings have fuzzy edges and can be hard to disentangle as identity markers (and thus hard to make anti-discrimination rules against), which is fertile ground for under-the-radar discrimination. The UK has multi-dimensional racism!
- effingwewt 4y agoWe have this in the US as well. People with a southern drawl may be thought of as country bumpkins and whatnot. Some (most?) of humanity's constant behaviors over our lifetime as a species is pretty sad.
- barrysteve 4y agoThe UK has racism/tribalism built in. It started there and worked upwards. The founding Anglo-Saxons are the Angles and the Saxons, two competing and merged races. The word England means land of the Angles. The class system overrides any racism, you are judged on much more than your race. Where you were born, your education (what school and university you went to), your friends, where you live now (by area name and distance to better spots), your family connections, your accent and word choice, your dress and behaviour (manners and mannerisms), your job history, the clubs you belong to, and much more. If you work with some people or someone really cares about you, they'll do homework on you to find out all this stuff. The UK has mapped out discrimination far deeper than american style racism. There are many more ways to slice up your image than just tribalism and ethnicity.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI don't understand how you can be so dismissive of HR talking about discrimination while at the same time praising legal for firing someone for discrimination, and compensating people for being discriminated against. What would you like HR to do about caste-based discrimination? Apparently not send emails, or mention it in classes? You just want them to go straight to firing?
- registeredcorn 4y agoThe commenter was saying that the classes and emails were geared towards evil whites, not caste issues. That is, they had no idea of how to approach the topic because they (probably?) had no idea about what caste is.
- ScoobleDoodle 4y agoFrom parents comment I understand: the emails and classes were apparently only addressing white people who discriminate and did not address cast-based discrimination. HR did nothing about the cast-based discrimination. And so parent is dismissive of HR. Only legal took any action there.
- SaltyBackendGuy 4y agoMaybe deal with it the same way you would with any other discrimination situation?
- colpabar 4y agoA lot of people are frustrated because if you ask anyone who works in HR at a company with DEI policies, they would say that they are "committed to diversity and inclusion and helping the oppressed" and whatever else they were trained to say. But given what seems like a textbook example of oppressive discrimination, they throw their hands up and say "well, we don't know what to do because the law says we don't have to do anything." Are we really still supposed to believe they're "committed" to anything other than getting paid?
- ummonk 4y ago"You just want them to go straight to firing?" Assuming it is clear cut discrimination, yes. Especially when it's a manager doing it.
- kazinator 4y ago> If he was white this would have been dealt with sooner. I think that if we more or less accurately map the situation into an analogous one involving the class system among whites in North America, then the "lower caste" white person would not even be working there.
- conductr 4y agoI thought this too. “White” has a lot of gradients in the US
- coward123 4y agoI'm a white dude, and had an incident a number of years ago in which a group of Indian contractors basically didn't want to work with me because I was a white dude. Used a number of slang racist terms in my direction. I didn't make a stink about it because I was a consultant just there on a short-term project, but it was memorable. As another commenter suggested, even the whole "white people" branding that happens in social media is comical, given centuries of one white group looking down on another white group. I'm glad to see this kind of social dialog about racism / classism in all of its forms and think it is very worthwhile to realize that it isn't just about the stereotype of white (males) hating on everyone else as is generally portrayed.