3 ms·
In my mind, I would be happy with 75% of the risk of human driving. That is enough to be clearly better and clearly safer. It is a big enough margin to preven
by londons_explore 4y ago
In my mind, I would be happy with 75% of the risk of human driving.
That is enough to be clearly better and clearly safer. It is a big enough margin to prevent lying with statistics ('oh, we only count highway miles', or 'yeah we were including with that statistic the young drink drivers').
It also isn't too unrealistic. If (to simplify things) you imagine that every accident has two cars involved and is the fault of just one of them, then a perfect self driving car that makes no mistakes will still be involved in half as many crashes (ie. 50% of the risk). I therefore don't believe it to be possible to exceed that while most cars are still driven by humans.
I would be completely happy with my government telling car companies they can do whatever they like as long as their accident rate per passenger mile remains under 75% of the nationwide average. I'd be happy with that instead of car standards too - if your manufacturer has a safety record exceeding that, they no longer need to do crash tests, brake performance tests, meet headlight regulations, whatever.
- josephcsible 4y agoHow is it lying with statistics to take into consideration the prevalence of drunk driving?
- londons_explore 4y agoWhen you get in a self driving car you want to be confident you are safer in that car than in one you drive yourself. If you are an honest citizen and don't drink drive, then you want to be comparing crash rates of other honest non-drink-driving citizens.
- josephcsible 4y agoAlice says "I never drive drunk, so the accident bar for self-driving cars to clear shouldn't take accidents caused by drunk driving into account." Bob says "I never use my phone while I'm driving, so the accident bar for self-driving cars to clear shouldn't take accidents caused by phone use into account." Carol says "I never drive exhausted, so the accident bar for self-driving cars to clear shouldn't take accidents caused by exhausted driving into account." And so on, since for every bad driving behavior, there's probably at least one person who's never done it. If they all get what they want, then self-driving cars will have to be perfect before they're allowed, even though they could save a lot of lives by going into service long before they're perfect.