3 ms·
It doesn't support his case. "Data collected in Europe shall be processed generally in accordance with the legal provisions of the country in which the data w
by lozenge 4y ago
It doesn't support his case.
"Data collected in Europe shall be processed generally in accordance with the legal provisions of the
country in which the data was collected, regardless of where the data is processed, but at the very least
in accordance with the requirements of these Binding Corporate Rules Privacy."
His data wasn't collected in Europe.
" For Deutsche Telekom AG from
July 01, 2014 in accordance with
approval by the Board of
Management on June 10, 2014.
In the domestic Group companies,
as per board approval or decision
of the responsible board member."
Where's the board approval of the US board?
How about the GDPR?
" The whole point of the GDPR is to protect data belonging to EU citizens and residents. The law, therefore, applies to organizations that handle such data whether they are EU-based organizations or not, known as “extra-territorial effect.”" (gdpr.eu)
Is he an EU citizen?
- jeroenhd 4y ago> Is he an EU citizen? Based on his biography (hasbrouck.org/bio/whoami.html) I believe he is an American citizen. I see records about him being born in the USA and nothing about any moves to a European country (other than his world travels for activism and other short-term purposes). If he were a European citizen, I'd expect his complaints to be directed at his local DPA rather than at DT/T-Mobile directly. I'm no lawyer so I'm not sure how legally binding his communication with T-Mobile/DT about the exact use of his data really is.
- ehasbrouck 4y agoI'm a citizen and resident of the USA. But I have travelled often in Germany, roaming on Deutshce Telekom cell towers using a cellphone with a T-Mobile USA SIM and a US phone number. DT has collected data about my roaming in Germany, and has transferred that data to T-Mobile USA for billing and other purposes. So some of the data about me held by T-Mobile USA, which T-Mobile USA has refused to allow me to see, was collected in Germany by Deutsche Telekom.
- cj 4y ago(I could be wrong but) GDPR does not grant rights to American tourists visiting Europe unless they are residing there (e.g. established residency, not just traveling through)
- joecool1029 4y agoProbably also a distinction to make but T-Mobile USA's international roaming isn't meant for long-term usage and they'll terminate the account if more than half a year or so is outside the US. I always thought of the cost implication for T-Mobile before this thread, not that they are probably more concerned with legal exposure of people changing residency and trying to remain as customers.