2 ms·
What doubts are those? What atmospheric changes? And can you share with us which particular cultural differences and lingustic drifts you mean? It sounds like
by Cthulhu_ 4y ago
What doubts are those? What atmospheric changes? And can you share with us which particular cultural differences and lingustic drifts you mean?
It sounds like you have doubts - which is fine - but you don't actually have the necessary knowledge to make these into solid counterpoints, peer review arguments, or competing scientific paper. As others point out, this is a common issue on HN and comment sections in general.
- tomrod 4y agoI share the doubts with the OP. Your comments are ad hominem. It doesn't matter whether OP has the "necessary knowledge" (read: pedigree and institutional background) to bring up clear confounders. The mere naming of them is sufficient to make the link. The names of colors have evolved -- no word for Orange for a long time! Perhaps "Yellow" was used instead. Further, without public access, there is no great way for the OP to respond directly. Thus, the onus is on the paper's distribution. But you don't call that out. Why?
- beowulfey 4y agoIt is freely available on ArXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.04702 https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.04702
- tomrod 4y agoCan you confirm this is the post-publication print, not a pre-publication? Not that the content is changed substantially -- but it could have.
- beowulfey 4y agoWell, the paper was released on July 29th, and the last revision (v2) of the ArXiv document was July 27th, so without going through the whole thing twice I would strongly suspect they are the same.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThe atmospheric changes I had in mind were the expansion of human population and burning of wood. I wrote about cultural factors in a sibling comment. I am not expert in these areas, but the main reason my comment was so brief was that I was working on something else at the time and glanced at HN while waiting for computations to render.