5 ms·

Source for 10-rep sets being particularly injurious please. And 10 lbs x 50 is much less stimulative than 50 lbs x 10, bordering on being not particularly effec

Source for 10-rep sets being particularly injurious please. And 10 lbs x 50 is much less stimulative than 50 lbs x 10, bordering on being not particularly effective.

ungamedplayer 4y ago
Any weight you can do 10reps of is unlikely to be near your 1rm max. From my limited experience it's a out 15 percent off.
- jstx1 4y ago
  > Any weight you can do 10reps of is unlikely to be near your 1rm max. Most people can't do 10 reps at 85% intensity, it's closer to 70-75%.
tomp 4y ago
It’s not that 10rep set is injurious. It’s that 50lbs is injurious, even just lifting it overhead.
- FartyMcFarter 4y ago
  It's only injurious if you can't do it. If you can lift 50 lbs up above your head a few times in a row, there's nothing wrong with doing that. Most males can probably do that with a tiny bit of practice.
  - tomp 4y ago
    Holding a heavy weight overhead is an inherently unstable position. Even if you can lift it overhead (using momentum), doesn’t mean you can hold it overhead. Even if you can do a few overhead presses, you need to be very careful not to do it to failure, as you need enough strength to safely bring it back to the ground. If you lose balance and the weight swings back, your shoulder is fucked, especially at that weight.
    - throwaway22032 4y ago
      Yes, but essentially no-one tries to do a high weight overhead press without training. If anything, most people are less likely to even touch a barbell because it looks like "serious work". For most adult men lifting the bar (44lbs, so almost 50) above their head after studying the form is not "injurious".
    - balfirevic 4y ago
      > Even if you can lift it overhead (using momentum You don't do shoulder presses using momentum (unless you're doing something specialised, in which case you know what you're doing). > as you need enough strength to safely bring it back to the ground You don't, you can do them in properly configured squat rack and just drop them.
    - andreareina 4y ago
      The overhead press is usually done off of hooks or pins, you don't have to start or end on the ground. The front rack position is very stable, I've never felt it to be the least bit sketchy lowering the bar even after a failed lift, either strict or with leg drive. If you do start off the ground, it's going to be a weight you can clean up into a front rack position; if you can clean the weight you can certainly lower it back down.
      - tomp 4y ago
        Ah, right, I always did overhead dumbbell press so I first thought of that. Yeah 50lbs barbell press is trivial, and using pins or even Smith machine it’s completely safe.
        andreareina 4y ago
        Mmm, yeah I don't like going too heavy on dumbbell presses, but heavy is really relative to your max, and sets of 10 is about where they start feeling good to me.
- gigaflop 4y ago
  I occasionally use 50-lb dumbbells for one-hand overhead presses. It takes some mindfulness of form, but otherwise is perfectly safe for me. I like it for when I don't have a lot of time, since I can only do a few reps with each arm. Part of lifting weights is raw strength, another is proper form. If I can't perform a lift 'the right way', I take off weight until I can. It took a fair bit of practice to
Ensorceled 4y ago
> Source for 10-rep sets being particularly injurious please. That's absolutely not what they said.
curiousllama 4y ago
99% of people have bad form, because nobody showed them good form. 1 set of 50lb dumbbells on shoulder press with no warm up & bad form, by a middle aged dad with no gym experience, can def mess up a rotator cuff.
- drakonka 4y ago
  I don't think that means the solution is to recommend they do 10lb sets with bad form though; it's more like they should learn proper technique instead, regardless of what their target weight is.
AlwaysRock 4y ago
25 pounds for 6-10 reps, always stopping before any pain, is a good middle ground. Dont do curls with 2-5 pound weights. Find something that is actually a bit difficult, but most people shouldnt pile on weight or even continue to increase it unless their current weight feels like it isnt very difficult.

Source for 10-rep sets being particularly injurious please. And 10 lbs x 50 is much less stimulative than 50 lbs x 10, bordering on being not particularly effective.

ungamedplayer 4y ago

Any weight you can do 10reps of is unlikely to be near your 1rm max. From my limited experience it's a out 15 percent off.

jstx1 4y ago
> Any weight you can do 10reps of is unlikely to be near your 1rm max. Most people can't do 10 reps at 85% intensity, it's closer to 70-75%.

tomp 4y ago

It’s not that 10rep set is injurious. It’s that 50lbs is injurious, even just lifting it overhead.

FartyMcFarter 4y ago
It's only injurious if you can't do it. If you can lift 50 lbs up above your head a few times in a row, there's nothing wrong with doing that. Most males can probably do that with a tiny bit of practice.
- tomp 4y ago
  Holding a heavy weight overhead is an inherently unstable position. Even if you can lift it overhead (using momentum), doesn’t mean you can hold it overhead. Even if you can do a few overhead presses, you need to be very careful not to do it to failure, as you need enough strength to safely bring it back to the ground. If you lose balance and the weight swings back, your shoulder is fucked, especially at that weight.
  - throwaway22032 4y ago
    Yes, but essentially no-one tries to do a high weight overhead press without training. If anything, most people are less likely to even touch a barbell because it looks like "serious work". For most adult men lifting the bar (44lbs, so almost 50) above their head after studying the form is not "injurious".
  - balfirevic 4y ago
    > Even if you can lift it overhead (using momentum You don't do shoulder presses using momentum (unless you're doing something specialised, in which case you know what you're doing). > as you need enough strength to safely bring it back to the ground You don't, you can do them in properly configured squat rack and just drop them.
  - andreareina 4y ago
    The overhead press is usually done off of hooks or pins, you don't have to start or end on the ground. The front rack position is very stable, I've never felt it to be the least bit sketchy lowering the bar even after a failed lift, either strict or with leg drive. If you do start off the ground, it's going to be a weight you can clean up into a front rack position; if you can clean the weight you can certainly lower it back down.
    - tomp 4y ago
      Ah, right, I always did overhead dumbbell press so I first thought of that. Yeah 50lbs barbell press is trivial, and using pins or even Smith machine it’s completely safe.
      - andreareina 4y ago
        Mmm, yeah I don't like going too heavy on dumbbell presses, but heavy is really relative to your max, and sets of 10 is about where they start feeling good to me.
gigaflop 4y ago
I occasionally use 50-lb dumbbells for one-hand overhead presses. It takes some mindfulness of form, but otherwise is perfectly safe for me. I like it for when I don't have a lot of time, since I can only do a few reps with each arm. Part of lifting weights is raw strength, another is proper form. If I can't perform a lift 'the right way', I take off weight until I can. It took a fair bit of practice to

Ensorceled 4y ago

> Source for 10-rep sets being particularly injurious please. That's absolutely not what they said.

curiousllama 4y ago

99% of people have bad form, because nobody showed them good form. 1 set of 50lb dumbbells on shoulder press with no warm up & bad form, by a middle aged dad with no gym experience, can def mess up a rotator cuff.

drakonka 4y ago
I don't think that means the solution is to recommend they do 10lb sets with bad form though; it's more like they should learn proper technique instead, regardless of what their target weight is.

AlwaysRock 4y ago

25 pounds for 6-10 reps, always stopping before any pain, is a good middle ground. Dont do curls with 2-5 pound weights. Find something that is actually a bit difficult, but most people shouldnt pile on weight or even continue to increase it unless their current weight feels like it isnt very difficult.