16 ms·
Happy Birthday GNOME! 25 years today
- dtx1 4y ago25 years, still no preview images in file picker
- david_draco 4y agoI see two previews, one next to the file name, and a large one on the right when clicking on a image file name. So: 25 years, now with preview images in file picker :)
- airtonix 4y ago1. select thing 2. press space 3. get preview of thing 4. come to hackernews 5. make a post complaining about lack of thing previews 6. ????
- PetitPrince 4y agoNot a Linux user, but I heard about the problem OP describe with this usecase: identify a picture of your children in a camera dump with dozen of pictures where the filename are all dsc_1346.jpg. Don't use a dedicated software because it's only for quick sharing.
- Smithalicious 4y agoIt beggars belief that gnome devs seem somehow totally incapable of understanding why one would want a proper thumbnail view in the file picker. Have they never had to find a specific image in a directory of many images? If you told me their response to the file picker issue is some kind of elaborate troll or gaslighting operation I would believe you.
- gnomethumbnails 4y ago[dead]
- WesolyKubeczek 4y agoNo, it's not what is being talked about. It's about thumbnails where you can see multiple of them at once.
- jeroenhd 4y agoInteresting, I get that preview in Firefox but not in any other standard file picker on my system. Any idea why that could be? That said, the preview is absolutely tiny and takes up a lot of horizontal space so it still feels very suboptimal. I much prefer the way Windows does this (https://ibb.co/jvQ50MG); https://ibb.co/jvQ50MG); you can play around with the old Windows file picker over at [1] and I must say that I would happily use this file picker for picking images in GNOME if I had the option. [1]: https://bellard.org/jslinux/vm.html?url=win2k.cfg&mem=192&graphic=1&w=1024&h=768 https://bellard.org/jslinux/vm.html?url=win2k.cfg&mem=192&gr...
- input_sh 4y ago> Any idea why that could be? It's not a default thing (I don't know why), apps need to add a couple of lines to use it. Relevant lines in Firefox: https://github.com/mozilla/gecko-dev/blob/master/widget/gtk/nsFilePicker.cpp#L380-L387 https://github.com/mozilla/gecko-dev/blob/master/widget/gtk/...
- gundamdoubleO 4y agoSomething like this https://wiki.installgentoo.com/images/b/b9/Gloriouskdefilepicker.png https://wiki.installgentoo.com/images/b/b9/Gloriouskdefilepi... is what people are requesting
- emptyparadise 4y agohttps://happybirthdaygnome.org/images/gnome2.jpg https://happybirthdaygnome.org/images/gnome2.jpg Nostalgic.
- thesimp 4y agoAnd that was a great user experience: Note the scrollbars that indicate where you are in your document/file list. No guessing on how many pages (if any!) there are to go. Note the edges of the windows that can be clicked on with a mouse with confidence. I don't need to be a 16 year old pro E-sports gamer to hit that 1 pixel edge as in current desktop environments. Note the clear button UI. You know 1: what part of the UI is a button and 2: if a button is active. Note the cohesive windows and colors. No mess of different UI toolkits, each with their own buttons, menubar layout and color space. But then I am not the target audience anymore: The desktop power user is a dying breed. 95% ( * ) of the people in the world view "the internet" via a small screen on their phone and have no interest in running multiple programs at once, managing large amounts of data on file systems, or even running their own PC. (*) random statistic that I made up.
- einpoklum 4y agoThe fact that a large userbase has evolved on smartphones does not mean that the desktop userbase is dying. In fact, it's probably increased in size somewhat. And we need to make UI designers understand that what may work and be appropriate for a smartphone or tablet should not be applied to desktops.
- hericium 4y agoFor me, Gnome died at 12.
- Findecanor 4y agoHappy Birthday, MATE . (<https://mate-desktop.org https://mate-desktop.org>) What is called "GNOME" today is something else.
- n3storm 4y agoThanks GNOME for facilitating me meeting XFCE
- PontifexMinimus 4y agoI moved to XFCE ages ago when Gnome and KDE kept changing things. XFCE mostly stays the same, which is as it should be. Stop reinventing the wheel!
- pjmlp 4y agoSame here, even with my C rants, that is exactly my desktop environment on the surviving netbook that still runs Linux. Kudos to XFCE devs.
- konart 4y ago>What is called "GNOME" today is something else. This is like telling somebody who's been into math for the past ten years and then decided to dive deep into arts they are now a different person. You may not like the change, but Gnome is still Gnome.
- traverseda 4y agoI guess that depends on if you see Gnome as an organization or as a desktop environment. The organization is 25 years old, but I'd argue that the desktop environment is not. Gnome 3 was a big enough change that I think it's reasonable to consider it an entirely new desktop environment.
- konart 4y agoI'm talking about (r)evolution of a software. I find it strange that people agree that windows 10 is still windows just like windows 3.11 but Gnome 42 is somehow 'not Gnome' anymore. Anyway, I don't there is any point to argue about it. Depending on interpretation we can say that every human wakes up as an entirely new entity every day too.
- sph 4y agoLinux has big GUI problems, we all know about it. But the HN discussion on Linux desktop is constantly partisan and very low quality, I am extremely disappointed. This is a celebration, if you have nothing good to say, just move on. This is a free desktop environment for a free operating system. Happy birthday GNOME. You might not have as many fans as years ago, but I appreciate the courage of trying something new. I miss GNOME 2, but yours is still my favourite desktop on the PC bar none. Looking forward to the next 25 years.
- Tainnor 4y agoI missed Gnome 2, too, 10 years ago. Then... 10 years passed, and I've just gotten used to the new UI. It's not like you can't customise it to some extent, and you still have the choice of using any alternative DM that you wish. IMHO, Gnome just works. There are other parts of the Linux ecosystem that still suck (audio...), but GNOME is IMHO not among them.
- thepangolino 4y agoI honestly miss all the 3D effects I had running on Gnome 2. It made my desktop fun to use. Modern replacements for the wobbly windows aren’t getting anywhere close to what I was used to.
- traverseda 4y agoKDE has most of those features, especially with wayfire.
- badsectoracula 4y agoPipewire seems to be the solution for audio... probably. I still have issues with different users that run at the same time not being able to use the same output (i.e. having two Xorg instances in different virtual terminals output to my USB headset at the same time) which is a stupid problem to have, but TBH i'm not sure if it is a PulseAudio issue or a Pipewire issue. It is most likely fixable, but it hasn't bothered me enough to try and figure it out.
- omegabravo 4y agoNormally these pages are filled with people who prefer old gnome. I thought I'd weigh in and say I prefer gnome 3 by a significant margin. * I don't use border click targets to resize, I hold alt + click to resize / move windows. * I use "expose" like functionality to switch windows or alt tab. * Nautalis isn't great, but I don't spend much time in there anyway. * I prefer the gnome 3 launcher (Windows key + start typing), than the menu system I barely see gnome, it lets the applications take centre stage, and I spend all my time in them anyway.
- 72deluxe 4y agoSorry, did you just say you liked gnome 3 yet told us that the file manager isn't great? I use mod + left/right to move my windows on Mate. Alt tab still works fine. Mod + r shows the run box which shows all the same entries as the menu. I used gnome 2 for many many years but also kde 3.5 (Konqueror did everything!) so the modern gnome 3 experience seem dysfunctional to me. I even used gnome 1 - must have been on RedHat 6.2? One thing I can't stand on the modern gnome apps is the hamburger menu and popout menus that are impossible to spawn from the keyboard. Eg. alt-f won't bring up that menu so you have to fumble around with the mouse. But thank goodness gnome exists, whether in gnome2-forever guise or the "modern" (I would say less-useful) 3.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ho_schi 4y agoGNOME is very keyboard centric and it is a joy to use :) Nautilus improved a lot the past years. There was a big backslash due to the removal of find-as-you-type but the new search instantly works as type-ahead-find inside the current directory or recursive. Special thanks to Carlos Soriano! I also thank Red Hat (Debarshi Ray and David King) for the transparency feature of gnome-terminal. I maintain myself a package for Arch with the required patches because I want it.
- politelemon 4y ago> I barely see gnome This is key for me. A good OS (in this case DE) gets out of the way. With none-to-little effort, recent Gnome does this well, and it's not something that Win/Mac are keen on.
- taubek 4y agoI was always more of KDE person, but I've always liked GNOME.
- iopq 4y agoI tried it, hit a few bugs and immediately switched. The right click menu for the language bar was stuck on the desktop forever which annoyed me right away. It happens in Windows too, and I just don't want to use buggy software. Gnome has lots of bugs too, but they are not obvious and in my face like this.
- mjmasn 4y agoIn case the author is reading, the specified font-family 'Cantarell' is not loading and there are no fallbacks specified. Probably needs a 'sans-serif' fallback or a webfont.
- pjmlp 4y agoIn 2001 I got an article published on The C/C++ User's Journal as introduction to GNOME development with Gtkmm. In those days I still believed that GNU/Linux would eventually gather around one main desktop solution. Nowadays I focus on Apple, Google and Microsoft platforms, while GNOME does yet another reboot with Gtk4, leaving behind Glade, extensions and whatever else. That C++ code for the article has nothing to do with "modern" Gtk.
- malermeister 4y agoThere's a new Glade-like for gtk4! https://gitlab.gnome.org/jpu/cambalache https://gitlab.gnome.org/jpu/cambalache I haven't read anything about them leaving behind extensions yet, do you have any more info?
- pjmlp 4y agoYes, it uses Web rendering for what is supposed to be a native toolkit and is years behind to be feature complete, not worth waiting for.
- 72deluxe 4y agoWhat's with the modern obsession of using web rendering for everything? It's actually insane.
- pjmlp 4y agoI really don't get it, when I do native I want native tooling, when I do Web, I expect no more than whatever the user has installed as their main browser. I was never found of MSHTML and Active Desktop, nor of its FOSS clones. See the readme on the repo, they basically use Gtk rendering into browsers.
- malermeister 4y agoFrom what I understand they're basically doing this as an abstraction layer so as to support both Gtk3 and 4? I'm still not sure why it needs to involve a browser though..
- einpoklum 4y agoI appreciate the work GNOME authors have put in over the years - but at the same time am highly critical of many of their choices. My personal favorite desktop environment is Cinnamon: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinnamon_(desktop_environment) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinnamon_(desktop_environment) created by the Linux Mint folks as an alternative to GNOME 3. But even there we are stuck with the horrendous Gtk file-picker. A compile of problematic claims from the post: > GNOME 3.0 was an exciting new desktop designed for today’s users and which is suited to a range of modern computing devices. That's quite debatable. Or rather, it seems that the designers decided what "today's users" need, and neglected to verify that was actually the case. > Flatpak, the next generation application framework for Linux It is not. > Flatpak ... provides cross-distribution applications that are more secure than traditional Linux apps Baseless claim. And it is somewhat "imperialistic" of GNOME to expect people to get binaries directly from them.
- 72deluxe 4y ago"neglected to verify that was actually the case" This seems very true. They decided that "apps" should abandon all of the useful toolbars because they were too "distracting" which is why gedit ended up being a big white space where you had to poke around in a floating popup menu to work out what you could actually do with it. By the same logic, reading a page of text is horrendously distracting and we should only be given access to 1 line at a time. Insanity, it my view, and a terrible regression on decades of UI development.
- pixelbeat__ 4y agoWow so I have been using gnome for 25 years! Here are some screenshots along the way https://www.pixelbeat.org/pics/ss/ https://www.pixelbeat.org/pics/ss/
- gkhartman 4y agoThanks for sharing these. I became aware of Linux in the gnome 2.x days, so I'd never seen the screenshots of gnome 1. I feel quite fortunate to live in a world where software projects like Gnome exists.
- bodge5000 4y agoThis year, I finally made the jump from Windows to Linux (specifically Fedora) and one thing I was anticipating was poorer, perhaps buggier UI. I was blown away by Gnome 41, it felt more like MacOS (not a reliable source for that, haven't used a mac in about a decade but you get the idea) than the slapped together front-end I was expecting. And the majority of the things I wasn't such a fan of (eg lack of taskbar) was easily fixed with gnome-extensions or tweaks. It barely took me even a month to get more used to it than Windows. And on top of all that, its incredibly performant (was running it on an X220). Obviously its not perfect (I don't really like the look of the app-menu for example, looks a bit mobile-y), but I've yet to find anything better, not just on Linux but across any OS.
- 72deluxe 4y agoNot sure about the menu, but using Mate (which is GNOME2+ effectively), by default the menu was a weird menu in the style of Windows 11 where you had to type to find anything. But you could replace the menu with a different menu button from the applets list to get the traditional menu back / other styles. I wonder if it's the same for Gnome 4?
- trin94 4y agoAmazing desktop if primarily used with the keyboard. Congratulations to 25 years!
- samuell 4y agoI'm extremely happy with ............. XFCE!
- davidy123 4y agoI like Gnome well enough. I keep trying to switch to KDE for the additional settings, many of which are useful, and what I understand to be more innovative core features, but its lack of consistency just feels janky. Gnome provides the most essential features, including a good amount of customization around focus and window switching, and Gnome apps are consistent in appearance and features, such as being able to select text in the UI. The 'problem' I have is that all these desktops are trying to recreate a 1990s era desktop. At least the Gnome people are professionals focused on a higher goal than a cool anime background, but I think the contingent of people who want a desktop experience with local media player, file manager, office suite and games is decreasing daily. If they don't want to be subsumed by tablet and ChromeOS options, focusing on goals like being a secure, networked operating system that an ordinary user would appreciate might be a good way forward. I think embracing rather than hiding the technical nature of the OS would be a good way to do this, but nothing like the disaster of forums today. For example, give every widget an ID and version, and create web based conversations around them that are embedded directly in the UI.
- 72deluxe 4y agoIf you believe that the number of people wanting a file manager and office suite is decreasing, what do you think the desktop environment actually will consist of? "focusing on goals like being a secure, networked operating system that an ordinary user would appreciate might be a good way forward" Isn't that precisely what the system is?? "give every widget an ID and version, and create web based conversations around them that are embedded directly in the UI" What does this even mean? What is a "web based conversation" in terms of the user interface??
- davidy123 4y ago«If you believe that the number of people wanting a file manager and office suite is decreasing, what do you think the desktop environment actually will consist of?» Look at ChromeOS and tablets. But, if you want to skip to a decentralized, user innovation and privacy-first future, look at KDE Nepomuk (which was an ambitious decentralized semantic desktop that collapsed), MS Graph (which is a centralized semantic system that probably won't), Plan 9, Nix, Qubes. «Isn't that precisely what the system is??» It's not really networked, in fact it's going backwards. X lets you run distrbibuted application on a fine level, as do other decentralized ideas like WS and HATEOAS, but we're reverting to a thin client model where the user is dependant on the browser and ???. But getting to the fine level requires more isolation, data & identify consciousness. «What does this even mean? What is a "web based conversation" in terms of the user interface??» Think of an inherently local, yet potentially complex control; a volume control. I can simply use it to control volume, but I might also want to mix volume with networked devices, which spirals into complexity, especially as we get into spatial audio. It's all possible on a Linux desktop, but doing it takes you into open ended complexity, compounded by the fact there are so many versions and combinations of software. A post-90s desktop could add a new control to the context menu which opened a live discussion about that version of that control and combination of desktop options.
- jasoneckert 4y agoI've always liked how Linux offers a desktop that is geared towards macOS (GNOME) and Windows (KDE) users. And the feel of each desktop hasn't adhered to a design standard (e.g., the Apple Human Interface Guidelines), but instead has evolved continually over the years to reflect what those who use the software (as with all open source software that is developed by those who use it). As a UNIX/macOS person, I primarily use GNOME. And in recent years I've come to prefer using it for development over macOS and Windows. So to the GNOME project: Congrats on 25, and here's to another 25!
- self_awareness 4y agoI did use GNOME-3 for 2 years in order to learn the "GNOME-3-way" of managing windows, and I kind of managed to get used to it. But then I've installed KDE and its traditional way of management felt like fresh air, after 2 years of trying to "learn the better way". So I've stopped trying to forcefully "evolve" my workflow management patterns and I've stopped looking at GNOME-3 altogether. Nevertheless, I'm sending happy birthday from a distant island where I live a more happy life than before ;)
- hotcoffeebear 4y agoHappy birthday Gnome!
- wooque 4y agoFortunately they are losing market share to KDE, so I say good riddance GNOME. Probably worst DE for Linux.
- pjmlp 4y agoIt was great, about 20 years ago.