2 ms·
Your numbers don't take into the age bands (you include older, wealthier families). However, the comparing CPI to inflation adjusted incomes (as the article do
by hedora 4y ago
Your numbers don't take into the age bands (you include older, wealthier families).
However, the comparing CPI to inflation adjusted incomes (as the article does) doesn't work either. Clearer explanation of the error I think the article made (and that I think you're pointing out):
For the sake of argument, say CPI is always proportional to income (which it would be if purchasing power was constant). To make arithmetic easy, say the CPI and median nominal income were both 1 in 1970, and are now both 8.
The inflation adjusted income in 1970 would be 8. (If we assume CPI moves with inflation, we multiply the 1970 median income by the ratio of 2022 CPI / 1970 CPI.)
So, by the author's calculations, a median family would have had 8 units of purchasing power in 1970, but only 1 unit of purchasing power in 2022, even though, by construction, CPI and nominal income went up in lockstep, and real purchasing power should be the same.
- phonon 4y agoThe original article was not based on incomes in any age ranges either. If they had wanted to do a more rigorous analysis, they would have compared say, 18-34 year olds in 1970 and today. Anyway, the point is the first half of the article is fundamentally mistaken, There are ways to do more interesting analyses, but this one was mostly incoherent.