3 ms·
And for any N, if p is small enough, other life is very unlikely to exist. Why are you holding p fixed and allowing N to increase? You are implicitly assuming
by pfdietz 4y ago
And for any N, if p is small enough, other life is very unlikely to exist.
Why are you holding p fixed and allowing N to increase? You are implicitly assuming N is in that regime where N > 1/p. That's just assuming p > 1/N, and there's no good reason to make that assumption.
- gcanyon 4y agoI sympathize -- I've argued your side of this many times. I won't jump in today, but I just wanted you to know your words aren't falling on entirely deaf ears.
- pfdietz 4y agoI think observer selection falls into a cognitive blind spot many people have.
- nyokodo 4y agoThis fallacy has always bothered me so thank you for stating it so well!