5 ms·
I think they are. I just also think the problem is a lot harder than people give it credit for. If they just go with a standard username (as in some form of a d
by godelski 4y ago
I think they are. I just also think the problem is a lot harder than people give it credit for. If they just go with a standard username (as in some form of a database lookup) then I'll be upset. But I'll be upset because this effectively doesn't solve any issue, and introduces others that have big privacy impacts and requires Signal to be a trusted source (which is antithetical to Signal's proposed mission).
I do wish Signal would be more transparent though. Given that this is such a difficult problem and they've been struggling with it for years, it reasons that it is time to seek help. This is like when a student just studies for hours and hours on end, spinning their wheels. They aren't learning anything. At some point you need a tutor, help from a friend, or asking the professor for help. (Or analogy in work if that's better)
Signal, it is time to be transparent.
- notpushkin 4y agoSignal is a trusted source already – you trust them telling you which number is which user.
- godelski 4y agoSorry, let me clarify. We should trust Signal as little as possible. That's how the design should work. Zero trust is very hard to create but let's minimize it. Opening up usernames (in the conventional sense) you will end up needing to verify and act as an arbiter. This is due to the fact that certain usernames have real world meaning behind them and you don't want to create an ecosystem where it is really easy to honeypot whistleblowing platforms (how do you ensure that CNN gets {CNN, CNN-News, CNNNews, etc}?). They've suggested that this might be the case given that the "Notes to self" and "Signal" users are verified with a blue checkmark. The issue is that verifying users not only makes Signal a more trusted platform but the act of verification requires obtaining more information about the user. It also creates special users. All things I'm very against. I'd rather hand out my phone number than have Signal collecting this type of information. So yeah, it isn't completely trustless, but I certainly don't want to move in the direction of requiring more trust.
- throwaway290 4y agoSignal does not tell me which number is which user. I know which number is who myself. The most Signal does is presumably warn me when the key associated with the number changed (eg. new phone). And that's where I have to trust Signal, but as a protocol not a "trusted source" of information.
- greyface- 4y agoYou aren't supposed to trust Signal on that; you are supposed to verify it out-of-band using Safety Numbers.
- 3np 4y agoHere's an idea that's been floated many times in the past: Add e-mail as an alternative alongside phone numbers. Support in contacts in both Android and iOS. The only real difference these days is that one requires government ID (by law in an increasing number of countries) and one does not. I fail to see any fundamental difficulty here.
- autoexec 4y ago> I do wish Signal would be more transparent though. You mean like updating their privacy policy to explain that they are keeping sensitive user data in the cloud? They refuse. There are people in this very discussion who are (or were at least) unaware that Signal is collecting and permanently storing user data on their servers. Signal's communication on what they're collecting and how has been a total joke. I cannot consider them trustworthy and at this point I suspect that refusing to update their privacy policy is a giant dead canary intended to warn users away from their product.
- sneak 4y agoPlease stop spreading objectively inaccurate FUD in the thread.
- autoexec 4y agoWhat part of what I said was inaccurate?
- godelski 4y agoWhat user data is being stored in the cloud? Can they decrypt it?
- autoexec 4y agoThe information they collect includes your name, your photo, your phone number, and a list of all the people you've been in contact with using Signal. They encrypt it using a pin which they ask you to set or one they generate for you. They (and anyone else) can decrypt that data by brute forcing what is often just a 4 digit number.
- godelski 4y agoCan you show me this? I'd guess it would have to be in the server code, so where is it? I don't see any real information about this on their site. Their website suggests that this information is stored locally https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007459591-Signal-Profiles-and-Message-Requests https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007459591-Si...