4 ms·
Now justify your implicit assumption that the chance life arises on a suitable planet is at least 1 in 10^22.
by pfdietz 4y ago
Now justify your implicit assumption that the chance life arises on a suitable planet is at least 1 in 10^22.
- layer8 4y agoThe point is we don’t know either way. Earth may or may not be a “Goldilocks” planet. Also, the numbers above are based on the observable universe. We have no idea how big the universe is outside that region. It could be infinitely large.
- colechristensen 4y agoA root fact of my philosophy is the unrefutable claim that I exist, and am alive, so the 1 in 10^22 seems very reasonable.
- pfdietz 4y agoNot 1 in 10^21, or 1 in 10^23? Where exactly is this number coming from? You are implicitly assuming a probability that life can arise. Don't you think that number has to be informed by an actual theory of how life arises, not inferred just from your own existence? And in fact, you can conclude nothing from your own existence. Observer selection bias.
- inanutshellus 4y agoThis thread comes across as bickering, and detracts from OP's original euphoric "wow" message.
- mbostleman 4y agoOrthogonal and bickering, but I find it interesting. I can keep two thoughts going at once. Sort of.
- ziddoap 4y agoWhat an oddly pedantic comment. 10^21, 10^22 and 10^23... Whichever number, the point that the parent poster was making doesn't change at all. >You are implicitly assuming a probability that life can arise. What are you suggesting? We're all actually not alive? Come on.
- pfdietz 4y agoNo, it's not oddly pedantic. It's more an expression of anger, because this sort of argument is common among SETI people. It's a very common error: there's lots of opportunities for life to arise, therefore life must be common in the universe. And this is utter bullshit. Probability does not work that way!
- haswell 4y ago> there's lots of opportunities for life to arise, therefore life must be common in the universe. And this is utter bullshit. Why anger? And will you expand on why this is utter bullshit? In what way does probability not work this way? You are making strong assertions without expanding on why you believe those assertions. Your assertion also goes against some pretty big names in the field; not that big names are automatically trustworthy, but they do seem to carry more weight than a random HN comment (no offense).
- pfdietz 4y agoThe argument that gets my goat is basically this: "if N is large enough, then for any probability p > 0, N p > 1." And that's clearly false. The SETI people making this busted argument are implicitly assuming p, the chance that life arises on a suitable world, is not "too small". And there is no basis for making that assumption.
- johnday 4y agoOn all of the Goldilocks planets we have so far been able to image with the resolution needed to determine the presence of life, we have determined the presence of life. That is not mathematically rigorous, but it is, from the Bayesian perspective, enough to move the needle.
- mrcartmeneses 4y agoIt is at least 1 in 10^22 because we have very strong evidence of one habitable planet Edit: See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth
- Apes 4y agoThe chance of a habitable planet happening could just as easily be 1 in 10^10000000000000000000000000, and it was just a freak occurrence it happened at all. Just because something happened once doesn't tell you much about the odds of it occurring.
- nikanj 4y agoTo be fair, we are working very hard on changing it to uninhabitable
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y ago>uninhabitable *for humans
- scoopertrooper 4y agoThis earth place sounds preposterous! I'm supposed to believe the planet's alpha predators willing make themselves subservient to smaller, but more furry beta predators?
- pfdietz 4y agoWhy 10^22, and not 10^10, or 10^40, or whatever? The number has to come from somewhere. This should be a strong clue your logic is defective.