3 ms·
I agree but not for the reasons you’ve stated. The rules you have complaints about seem to have straightforward interpretations. On reaching the last row it’s
by vlovich123 4y ago
I agree but not for the reasons you’ve stated. The rules you have complaints about seem to have straightforward interpretations.
On reaching the last row it’s the same promotion rules as pawns.
Re castling what they’re saying is that you can keep castling with rooks provided your king has never left the home row (ie the rook would have to leave to let you castle with the other one). A7 implies the king has left the home row and can no longer castle.
I do agree that there is ambiguity to clarify though:
* where is the castled position when the rooks aren’t in their starting position?
* what on earth does en pessant mean for kings?
- xnorswap 4y agoSorry, I meant b8 not a7.
- zuminator 4y agoI thought the castling section meant, not that they could castle multiple times, but that unlike normal chess they could still castle after moving the king as long as it remained in the home row. You might very well be correct though. So I agree with the previous poster that there's too much ambiguity here. One thing I'd like to know is the ELO rating of the variant creator. Is this a game that someone who understands standard chess very well came up with and play-tested, or is it a game that someone with passing familiarity with chess thought of off the cuff? If the latter, the chances that the game is a well-balanced variant are not so high. Also, is "baring" a typo for "barring"? Finally it should be noted that dice chess is already a thing: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dice_chess https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dice_chess