4 ms·
Yale360 seems to cover renewables issues as if the reader already has some very weird ideas about them. Probably a sensible and sadly necessary approach. But i
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
Yale360 seems to cover renewables issues as if the reader already has some very weird ideas about them. Probably a sensible and sadly necessary approach.
But in reality, land use has never been a problem for Solar. It's great that lots of people are working on the issue and improving it. Just as lots of people are working on making them cheaper, or more environmentally friendly or easier to finance or a thousand other metrics.
But none of those were ever fundamental problems with the tech. Their own source of data about the 'problem' puts Ground-based PV at about the same land use as Coal.
They also missed out 'floatovoltaics' (PV on water) and building integrated PV as well as solar PV as a paving solution. Probably all of which are likely to be bigger than ground mount PV, given the trend to bifacial panels.
- mech987 4y agoIs PV at the same land use as coal currently on a per-watt basis or on a total land use basis?
- ncmncm 4y agoSince solar may use up exactly zero acres, its watts per acre may be infinite. Wind, also, coexists easily with other uses. Solar farms are often sited, stupidly, in deserts, not because it is a good idea, but because ignorant investors think it is a good idea.
- QuarterReptile 4y ago>Solar farms are often sited, stupidly, in deserts, not because it is a good idea, but because ignorant investors think it is a good idea. Perhaps indulge our ignorance about deserts for a moment?
- ncmncm 4y agoDeserts are hot and dusty. Efficiency falls quickly as temperature rises, and more as dust accumulates. Panels degrade exponentially faster as peak temperature increases. (Precisely: each fixed increase in temperature doubles rate of degradation.) Siting panels on water and on farmland reduces operating temperature. Mounting vertically, in fence-rows, keeps off dust, collects more during morning and afternoon demand peaks, aids convective cooling, and protects crops from harshest afternoon sun.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThey link to this, which has a table at the top: https://ourworldindata.org/land-use-per-energy-source https://ourworldindata.org/land-use-per-energy-source I'd assume coal uses much more land in absolute terms, since it's what 50% of global electricity vs 3-5% for solar at the moment.
- naasking 4y ago"Same land use as coal" isn't necessarily an equivalent metric. Solar might be taking up land that could otherwise be used for food, for instance. Better energy density will also help locate solar power closer to where it will be used, like on top of buildings in the city rather than in a large plant out in the middle of nowhere, thus saving on transmission costs. Finally, IMO photovoltaic pavement is probably going nowhere.
- kiba 4y agoSolar shading would works, probably.
- abainbridge 4y agoThat seems like an excellent point. Why hasn't this already been done everywhere that gets sunny?
- ncmncm 4y agoSolar may share land that is also used for food, so no: There is no competition between them. In fact, sharing improves efficiency of the panels, cuts water loss, and often increases yield.
- naasking 4y agoMay share for some crops yes, but that hasn't traditionally been the case has it?
- ncmncm 4y agoDid everyone always know that solar/crop dual use was often purely beneficial for both? No. Did somebody know? Yes. Does everyone know today? Evidently not.
- naasking 4y ago> Did everyone always know that solar/crop dual use was often purely beneficial for both? (emphasis added) "Often" != "Always". Therefore you also agree that solar still competes for land use with crops. Furthermore, land that has already been allocated to grid scale solar has already been taken away from possible crop use. Sometimes it's not arable land, but that isn't always the case, therefore solar is still ostensibly taking up land that could be used for crops. Finally, I even disagree that somebody knew that solar and farming could use the same land. Someone had an idea that maybe they could coexist, then ran an experiment that succeeded. They certainly didn't know the outcome beforehand.
- phs318u 4y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted. I think "floatovoltaics" are definitely a growth option with lots of upside - especially if located on man-made bodies of water e.g. dammed lakes (which often will have sufficient infrastructure already in place). https://thesolarlabs.com/ros/floating-solar-farms/ https://thesolarlabs.com/ros/floating-solar-farms/