5 ms·
It’s 2022, and Teslas still aren’t stopping for children
- olodus 4y agoYeah but is anyone asking the real question: how many million of years has children had to learn to avoid Teslas? A design flaw if you ask me. Why I am hesitant to getting one of my own...
- user_named 4y agoIt wasn't part of the requirements
- fredgrott 4y agoconsidering how many children Elon has brought into the world, why not?
- user_named 4y agoThey're not top of mind for him
- jesuscript 4y agoAbortion just became illegal, haven’t you heard?
- krapp 4y ago
- timkam 4y agoThis would then be inconsistent with Musk's stated principle of reproduction as a civic duty (at least _his_ civic duty)...
- smilespray 4y agoWhy am I not surprised he's into eugenics?
- azangru 4y agoDoes Musk talk in terms of civic duties?
- timkam 4y agoNot exactly of course; reasoning backwards from the fact that he has fathered many children, he announced that doing so is good for humanity.
- xedeon 4y agohttps://twitter.com/WholeMarsBlog/status/1558876752062976000 https://twitter.com/WholeMarsBlog/status/1558876752062976000
- Quanttek 4y agoWell, at the very least, it proves the unreliability of Tesla's autopilot
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Kwpolska 4y agoDo you have a source without a hexagon profile picture?
- xedeon 4y agoEURO NCAP Good enough of a source for you? https://youtu.be/x7Hp2zACGmg?t=126 https://youtu.be/x7Hp2zACGmg?t=126
- xedeon 4y agoJason Hughes probably knows more about these cars other than Tesla engineers and have reversed engineers a lot of them. He's been vocal about Tesla's shortcomings before. Here's what he had to say: https://twitter.com/wk057/status/1557059544144044032 https://twitter.com/wk057/status/1557059544144044032
- v413 4y agoWell here it stops lol https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fu4ZEnIwYZI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fu4ZEnIwYZI
- jay_kyburz 4y agoI like how they are doing experiments as to whether the car will stop for children, on a road with actual children running up and down the sidewalk. (a 1:45 - that's as far as I got)
- mlindner 4y agoMaybe watch a bit further when the guy uses his own kids for the test instead and show that it see's kids at the far end of the road, a long way from the car.
- Planktonne 4y agoIdeally, it would always stop. The fact that sometimes it sometimes stops before hitting a child is not completely comforting.
- Etheryte 4y agoI don't think ideally is the right mindset to have here. So long as it does better than a human driver and/or better than the current status quo, it's already a great improvement. Of course things can always be better, but just because it isn't ideal doesn't mean it's bad.
- Planktonne 4y ago> So long as it does better than a human driver and/or better than the current status quo, it's already a great improvement. I've yet to see evidence that this is the case. In this particular situation, it's hard to believe that a human driver would have struggled.
- dotancohen 4y ago
- glanzwulf 4y agoThat's an easy 70 points for Tesla.
- skrebbel 4y agoI love that the crash test kid dummy breaks exactly the way a Roblox character would, that seems fitting somehow. My mind was automatically adding the "oof!" sound.
- martin_a 4y agoThis is a strange advertisement for LiDAR or a strange hit into Teslas' direction. Also it looks like only unknown brands are to integrate LiDAR tech. What about the big brands? Do $bigbrand cars with collision detection/emergency braking assistants stop for children? Which technology do they use if not? I don't get the point.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- timkam 4y agoAFAIK, it is well-known in the industry that Tesla is the only relevant vendor (or at least one of the few) betting on video-only. A couple of years ago, this looked (while risky) more reasonable, given the hype around deep learning-based image recognition (combined with the assumption that humans primarily rely on video). But I suppose most vendors assumed even then that video-only won't be able to handle all edge cases, like bringing a car to a safe stop in case video is non-workable in an extreme situation.
- martin_a 4y agoOk, so we put 15 other cars in a row next to the Tesla and that other car and they will probably (hopefully) all stop and the Tesla will not. That's a serious issue with Tesla then, I see. On the other hand: It proves nothing for LiDAR technology, integrated in some strange non-brand cars, when all the other brands get the same result without LiDAR. As others have pointed out, it seems like the author of the tweet has its own agenda, also the test conditions are obviously not the same and whatnot. This is pure BS at this point.
- Sebb767 4y agoI'm not sure why the Author only listed Volvo, but at least Mercedes and most VAG vehicles use LiDAR, too.
- martin_a 4y agoAh, I didn't even spot Volvo and Cadillac between all those brands that sound like they are trying to sell USB hubs and t-shirts on Amazon.
- Havoc 4y agoMusk should get on that asap in light of his not enough people theory
- bdcp 4y agoThis was filmed by a competitor.
- xedeon 4y ago
- Planktonne 4y agoYou don't need technical experience to watch the video and be concerned.
- xedeon 4y ago
- Planktonne 4y agoDo you have a more reputable source? That Youtube account (and associated website) look like an archetypal example of unbalanced axe-grinding.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Etheryte 4y agoYes and no, it's hard to say if the test setup is fair and/or realistic based on the video alone. If the setup is intentionally made so that the car on the right has an advantage, e.g. the dummy materials are chosen to be more visible to its sensors, then it is highly misleading. If the source is not trustworthy then worrying about hidden agendas like this should come to mind.
- Planktonne 4y agoIt seems somewhat counter-intuitive to declare the source untrustworthy because of a lack of technical expertise while also worrying that the source exploited knowledge of the technology to bias the test. Based on the video, there is cause for concern. I've not seen any evidence presented which would entirely remove that concern, and it would have to be quite significant to do so.
- mlindner 4y agoThere's numerous examples of it stopping for children, including in official testing. It was already stopping for children in 2019. Including in sudden appearance of them from behind an object (see at 2:20). https://youtu.be/x7Hp2zACGmg?t=126 https://youtu.be/x7Hp2zACGmg?t=126 In fact it does it better than most other vehicles in the above test. The more interesting thing here is that I want to know what's going on with the algorithm on how this thing has 213,000 likes and 26,000 retweets despite only having been posted 5 days ago. Twitter bots at work here?
- simion314 4y agoYes, sometimes is stops for train and trucks too, but some other times depending on lighting or who knows what it will drive you into a truck at full speed. And on top of that all old tests are invalid since new updates could change things. As long as the driver does it's job the human saves the FSD and you will never see publish by Elon the number of how many times the human saved the day.
- mlindner 4y ago> And on top of that all old tests are invalid since new updates could change things. Convenient way of discarding any evidence you don't like. > Yes, sometimes is stops for train and trucks too, but some other times depending on lighting or who knows what it will drive you into a truck at full speed. Not sometimes, always. The only times it doesn't of note is what I would call "small overlap into lane" situations. By that I mean the vehicle is almost entirely out of the fixed lane lines on a highway, but a police vehicle is sitting partially into the lane to block the traffic which is something that they do sometimes. Some Teslas have apparently had issue with this which is why they're working to improve that. I haven't heard any recent events of it in the last month or so so it may be fixed by now.
- simion314 4y ago>Convenient way of discarding any evidence you don't like. I am sorry that reality and logic upsets you, after a software update you need to run tests again, the history of old tests does not guarantee anything useful. Blah, blah, it only hits trucks if bullshit reasons, it should not hit giant solid objects ever. Also what is the excuse for this one? https://www.thedrive.com/news/watch-as-teslas-autopilot-almost-steers-model-3-into-oncoming-train https://www.thedrive.com/news/watch-as-teslas-autopilot-almo... Last time the excuse was "that is normal, it is alpha software, it will be fixed in the next update". But if you read tesla subreddit you see people complaining that years old issues are still not fixed, like having issues with specific streets, road borders and similar.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nnoitra 4y agoDon't worry, full self driving will be available by next year!
- eps 4y agoThis is several days old and according to various subs on reddit: There is a (very poorly shot) video from inside of the car, but apparently it's still possible to see that they tried engaging FSD, but it didn't take. Don't have a link for the video, but it's easy to find. The video comes from a guy who's campaigning for a Senate (?) seat and the only campaign issue is that of anti-Tesla.
- xedeon 4y agoHis senate bid was mainly for legal protection since he can't get sued under the guise that they are "political ads".
- mlindner 4y agoSource on that one? That seems like a very strange loophole that wouldn't hold up generally in court. It'd be very easy to show during discovery that his primary incentive is profit and further demonstrate he had no intention of winning by very low vote counts.
- xedeon 4y ago"There is no federal truth-in-advertising law that applies to political ads, and the very few states that have tried such legislation have had little or no success. " https://www.npr.org/2022/03/17/1087047638/the-truth-in-political-advertising-youre-allowed-to-lie https://www.npr.org/2022/03/17/1087047638/the-truth-in-polit...
- mlindner 4y agoI don't think you get an opt-out for political ads when you're not talking about another politician or the government itself.
- Fatnino 4y agoSo like Trump's campaign in 2015? I had the impression in late 2016 that he was like the dog that caught the car.
- ZuLuuuuuu 4y agoI would prefer a more controlled experiment. For example doing the same test 100 times to see the success rate of Tesla. Then doing the same experiment with the other car 100 times as well and then compare the results etc. Just 1 video might be a bit misleading.
- lelag 4y agoIt appears there is a lot of controversy regarding the factualness of this report. Here's an article claiming the results to be completely fabricated. https://www.tesmanian.com/blogs/tesmanian-blog/tesla-model-3-on-fsd-didnt-hit-a-child-sized-dummy-in-the-dawn-project-test-results-are-completely-fabricated https://www.tesmanian.com/blogs/tesmanian-blog/tesla-model-3... If the fraud turns out to be true and provable, I would expect Tesla lawyers to be all over this guy...
- captainmuon 4y agoI'd like to see how the dummy looks like from the perspective of the car. If they painted the back side with a pattern of the road, then of course a car without Lidar can't see it. But neither could a human driver. "Thing on street" detection is probably the most basic function of an autopilot, after lane keeping. I would be surprized if there wasn't a robust "thing on street" detector as a separate module in front of, and separate from the whole self-driving AI. As far as I heard, simple obstacle detection can already be made more robust than human vision, just with stereo cameras. Now what is hard is, stuff moving perpendicular to the road. Child running towards the road behind a chain-link fence is OK, but if there is no fence, stop immediately. Is that rolling thing a tumbleweed, or a ball? And so on...
- mlindner 4y agoI wonder how many retweets and twitter likes were bought for this tweet promoting a technology that's also on the stock market. There's been a recent frenzy in the last few days including stuff by Dan O'Dowd running commercials that fall into the vein of ouright libel in order to gain financial value from seeing the Tesla shares drop doing exactly the same type of fake test as this one where the Tesla runs over a fake child. Then there's this guy who has a vested interest in the company he's promoting in his video he produced here. As he dodges the question here: https://twitter.com/TaylorOgan/status/1556998237432811520 https://twitter.com/TaylorOgan/status/1556998237432811520 Also very likely lying about Tesla for financial gain.