3 ms·
You seem to be mixing and matching acronyms that don't really make sense. "TOTP" means "Time-based one time password". It's where the server and client (like t
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
You seem to be mixing and matching acronyms that don't really make sense.
"TOTP" means "Time-based one time password". It's where the server and client (like the Google Authenticator app) share a secret and then the one-time password changes every 30 seconds. "SMS TOTP" doesn't make sense because SMS codes can be anything random that is sent out to the user attempting to log in.
As I stated above, the Google Authenticator app is a TOTP implementation and is also susceptible to MITM attacks.
U2F refers to physical hardware keys (like yubikeys) that cryptographically validate the requesting server is who they say they are, and is not susceptible to phishing.
- plaguepilled 4y agoYou are completely right, I misspoke (mistyped?) in my previous comment. Apologies for the error. What I referred to as U2F is TOTP as you say, and what I referred to as TOTP is plaintext OTPs. That's an embarrassing mistake. What I had meant to highlight is that SMS based authentication is more vulnerable than an authenticator app because the SMS exposes data that can be intercepted or collected by a third party. A timed algorithm solution does not expose this risk at read time (only when synchronising - unless I've missed something?), which is why I strongly prefer it.
- UncleMeat 4y agoThis is a modest but often overblown risk. SIM swapping is easy but scales badly. SMS interception malware exists but isn’t widely installed and you rely on the malware not being able to root your phone or get accessibility access to your screen. But most importantly, both TOTP and SMS are vulnerable to phishing - by far the most common method of stealing second factors.