3 ms·
There needs to be an equivalent of Choice/Consumer Reports/etc that dismantles products and calls out anything that should've been made from metal instead of pl
by CamperBob2 4y ago
There needs to be an equivalent of Choice/Consumer Reports/etc that dismantles products and calls out anything that should've been made from metal instead of plastic. It's frustrating dealing with unnecessarily broken parts.
I would pay a crazy amount of money to subscribe to a service provided by a professional reverse-engineering outfit that takes the Consumer Reports concept to the next level, with highly technical teardowns and critical analysis of a wide variety of products that covers everything from the BOM to the firmware.
This kind of thing happens sporadically -- e.g., some of the Juicero postmortems offered a lot of engineering insight. And there is no shortage of passionate amateurs like AvE who don't have a consistent methodology and/or don't always have the domain expertise needed to give a given product design a fair assessment.
What's needed is a consistent, professional, and above all objective approach to informing the purchase decisions of technically-literate consumers.
- prawn 4y agoI think beyond tear-downs, it needs to be influential enough to guilt companies into going the right thing. Consumers shouldn't need to browse a detailed tear-down of an object to guess whether something has been made to last or not.
- CamperBob2 4y agoMy thinking is that the people who watch it will do the influencing.