6 ms·
They are also incorruptible. If they give your product good marks, you are not allowed to mention it in your marketing (Not sure how they enforce it; maybe the
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
They are also incorruptible.
If they give your product good marks, you are not allowed to mention it in your marketing (Not sure how they enforce it; maybe they stop reviewing your stuff).
I worked at a company that regularly got top marks from them, and our Marketing folks would have fits, because they couldn't mention it.
- alamortsubite 4y agoSounds great, but Consumer Reports definitely has a checkered past. Read about the Suzuki Samurai debacle, in which they methodically manipulated their tests (strictly for that vehicle, and not any of the others in its class that they were simultaneously evaluating), with the goal of destroying the vehicle's reputation. https://www.aim.org/aim-report/aim-report-a-black-eye-for-consumer-reports/ https://www.aim.org/aim-report/aim-report-a-black-eye-for-co...
- Spooky23 4y agoI think Consumer Reports has an opinionated editorial voice. But I think that’s inevitable in that line of work. SUVs evolved to address the risks pointed out by CR and other entities. They mostly have wider wheelbases and lower centers of gravity.
- crotchrocketeer 4y agoWell, at least this wasn’t in the “pretend it’s better direction” so it’s a at least still reliable in helping pick good quality.
- alamortsubite 4y agoNot if you were trying to decide between the Samurai and the other vehicles CR was "evaluating" (a Wrangler and the Bronco II). Internally, CR's testers praised the Samurai as having the best handling of the bunch, but their editor made sure the public never heard this.
- delusional 4y agoWhat are you talking about? The original review literally mentioned: "Under the touch of our drivers, all four utility vehicles got through the course at 52 mph or better. The Suzuki Samurai was actually more maneuverable than the others, since it's so much smaller and lighter" Tell me again how it was some cover up. They literally published your argument along with the review.
- hn_go_brrrrr 4y agoI hadn't heard about this, thanks for the link. I did a little digging and it doesn't appear be quite as clean cut as that article says. For instance, check out https://www.theautochannel.com/news/press/date/19970422/press001971.html https://www.theautochannel.com/news/press/date/19970422/pres... (a CR press release), where they mention internal Suzuki documents acknowledging the rollover issue.
- alamortsubite 4y agoI've read the text of the lawsuit. As you mention, this is a press release, so I'm highly skeptical of it. Video documentation of CR's manipulation of the tests is on YouTube. It's wild stuff: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2Bv9WL3vpY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2Bv9WL3vpY
- hn_go_brrrrr 4y agoBest guess? CR fabricated their test results because they couldn't figure out how to replicate the real-life problems on their test course. Which is to say, both sides are in the wrong.
- delusional 4y agoEvery review site "fabricates their test reults" thats the whole point. You create a test that documents your assistent. The ruling on an appeal makes the argument better than i could. > [The] først theory is that CU know it was probably lying because its employees tries to make the samurai flip and we're happy when they suceeded. The second is that CU purposely avoided the truth by failing to address a potential source of experimental error. Neither of these theories withstands serious scrutiny The opinion end up concluding that the entire reason for changing the test setup, along with a description of the changes, was present in the article. What a non-story.
- mapt 4y agoI'm not sure what the point is of linking to a reference that also features pieces titled: 'The media lied to you about COVID-19 – TAKE ACTION NOW' 'Critical Race Theory in schools, take action now!' 'Gender activists are politicizing the dictionary: TAKE ACTION NOW' 'Stand up for Rush – TAKE ACTION NOW' 'VOX buries the truth' 'CNN admits Hunter Biden ‘a real problem’ for Joe Biden, not ‘a right-wing media story’' https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Accuracy_in_Media https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Accuracy_in_Media I am less confident about either your contention or about the position you are attacking than about the idea that this particular website is going to lie to me about it.
- switchbak 4y agoI'm still not sure why I'm standing up for Rush, I don't even like the band, but I took action. Immediately!
- midoridensha 4y agoWhy does anyone need to stand up for Rush? It was a great band and not really controversial, plus they disbanded years ago because the drummer died. They don't exist any more, just like Led Zeppelin no longer really exists (also because the drummer died, coincidentally).
- dreamcompiler 4y agoSpock: Captain we need to send down a landing party to investigate the radiation leak. Kirk: Send some red shirts. Spock: They're all in Agile training today. Kirk: Do we have any rock drummers?
- philwelch 4y agoIt was ridiculous how long it took for them to be enshrined in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, but that finally happened a few years back.
- midoridensha 4y agoThe Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is a complete joke, and has nothing to do with real Rock and Roll music. They regularly induct musicians and performers who have absolutely nothing to do with Rock. It's best to just ignore the whole institution.
- nobodyofnote 4y agoThey actually do allow you to mention it in marketing; I've worked with them for a consumer product. What you can't do is use it in "paid" marketing. Emails, social media posts, website landing pages, collateral in-store/retail is all fully acceptable. You can also pay additional fees to them for additional materials to use in communications.
- pandaman 4y agoIt is apparently allowed to put a link to the review, saying "Check out how CR reviewed us" e.g. https://www.lg.com/us/laundry https://www.lg.com/us/laundry
- tomohawk 4y agoI'm a member of CR, but they obviously have their biases and blind spots. Sometimes they start with a premise they want to prove instead of just providing a straight review of the products. They may do this by selecting the criteria (key performance metrics), for example. Sometimes, they just don't competently evaluate the products because they fail to take into account real world consumer needs. The quality of reviews in CR these days doesn't hold a candle to what CR used to provide, but I remain a member because even a weak signal is better than the other random stuff out there like Amazon reviews.
- grepfru_it 4y agoI’ve had great success with them, my vacuum is going strong after 13+ years, washer and dryer great after 9 years. But I’m still harboring negative feelings about their car reviews. They marked the 2013 Ford Edge as a great vehicle with minimal flaws, but when they reviewed the 2014 Ford Edge they found an array of problems and lowered the score. While I was researching and shopping for my Ford Edge I found the 2013 and 2014 were exactly the same cars. I think they enhanced the weld points for ANCHOR points to support 60lbs instead of 45lbs, but that was the extent of changes.. small and incremental. Yet CR faulted them for excess road noise, stiff suspension, and reliability. I test drove both mode years and they both performed and sounded exactly the same. Major parts including suspension were interchangeable as well. We went with the 2013 to save money before the CR reviews for 2014 came out. It made me realize their reviews are not consistent, especially when Tesla Model S went from having top marks to all of a sudden being scored very low. These are not cars that drastically changed between the years, so just buyer beware YMMV FWIW, I do love my Ford Edge and it is still the daily driver for our household
- Tagbert 4y agoYou do need to distinguish between their reviews (which are done by CR internal people and reflect their values and judgement) and the ratings which are done by surveying CR subscribers who are owners of the products.
- TheRealDunkirk 4y agoThey might be ethical, but they don't "live" with appliances to really figure out what they're dealing with, either. I used Consumer Reports' recommendation to buy a full set of appliances for a new house about 18 years ago. I bought "GE Gold" washer, dryer, fridge, stove, microwave, and dishwasher. Within 2 years, every single one had failures. For instance, the oven's convection fan failed in a month. The washer AND dryer completely failed within 3 years. I bought refurbished units from a local guy, and when I told him what I had, he didn't even want them to flip again. I, too, resigned myself to the fact that, unless you pay for commercial-grade appliances, it's all crap, and you may as well just buy the cheapest thing at Lowe's, and replace it when it fails. The industry deserves all the loss of trust they have earned.