5 ms·
>the technology will be good 99.99% of the time This is the kind of technology that's useless if it's not good 100% of the time. Parachutes can be useful even
by coldtea 4y ago
>the technology will be good 99.99% of the time
This is the kind of technology that's useless if it's not good 100% of the time.
Parachutes can be useful even if they open 99.999% of the time.
But this is either 100% cryptograhical proven forgery-proof or it isn't. There's no "good enough" middle ground. You care for forgery-proof when important things are hanging on that being the case.
- lazide 4y agoAnd important things don’t hang from parachutes? Nothing is ever 100%
- SXX 4y agoWhile in cryptography there is never 100% we tend to expect crypto not to have have serious known flaws and require great amounts of compute power, time and energy for brute-force attack. E.g cryptocurrency is "safe" because cost of attack is too high and require too much resources. On other side this Sony Camera-DRM is not just useless, but dangerous especially since Sony have well established track record with backdoors and cryptography: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk... https://www.engadget.com/2010-12-29-hackers-obtain-ps3-private-cryptography-key-due-to-epic-programm.html https://www.engadget.com/2010-12-29-hackers-obtain-ps3-priva... https://www.pcworld.com/article/411221/backdoor-accounts-found-in-80-sony-ip-security-camera-models.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/411221/backdoor-accounts-fou...
- lazide 4y agoNone of what you’re saying appears to be pertinent in this issue, since the primary objections appear to not be related to the crypto but to the end-to-end validation? Which it’s still likely better than the current situation, which is photoshops ahoy everywhere.
- coldtea 4y ago>And important things don’t hang from parachutes? They do. But we're ok with some losses now and then, if it means parachutes still saves tons of lives... The thing is a parachute failing doesn't affect other deployments. Whereas the forgery-proof tech being able to fail means no photo with "forgery proof data" can be trusted.
- lazide 4y agoYour idea of trust here seems at odds with, well, everyone else’s? Digital photos are already used extensively without any digital signing at all in court - for very high profile cases, including murder, high stakes civil suits (Depp vs Heard), insurrection against the US, you name it. How is this going to make it worse exactly? The systems involved already have to deal with uncertainty, doubt, potential fraud, etc. If there is a potential signal to help out with that, which this is, it just makes it easier to discover fraud, not bulletproof or impossible, regardless of the tech.
- coldtea 4y ago>How is this going to make it worse exactly? If it's easily broken? By providing fake assurances. >The systems involved already have to deal with uncertainty, doubt, potential fraud, etc. Yes, and false assurances has already been an issue with all kinds of forensic processes, and led to numerous bad convictions (numerous that we know of, there are obviously more). I'd rather have dgital photos "without any digital signing at all" in court, and the court treating them with uncertainty, doubt, potential fraud, etc, than a easy to beat signing system that gives even 10% extra unwarranted assurances to juries and judges....