3 ms·
I do not consider the St. Lawrence divide to be a "continental" divide, nor do I know of anyone who considers it to be so. It's just a watershed divide, and th
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
I do not consider the St. Lawrence divide to be a "continental" divide, nor do I know of anyone who considers it to be so. It's just a watershed divide, and those are a dime a dozen.
I can see that some people would consider the Eastern divide to be a continental divide, though I do not.
- ghaff 4y agoSo I gave you a reference. But you're smarter. And a "watershed divide" still suggests a higher height of land that still needs to be passed through whether or not it passes your personal definition of a continental divide.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoSure. But I never questioned whether they had to cross a watershed divide. Of course they had to, because Lake Michigan doesn't drain into New York Harbor. The New York Central Railroad followed (more or less) the path of the Erie Canal. They advertised themselves as "The Water Level Route", because they didn't have a major mountain crossing between New York and Chicago (unlike, say, the Pennsylvania Railroad).
- ghaff 4y agoIt's not major--obviously the Erie Canal more or less followed the path of least resistance so it's not surprising the railroad did as well. But it's certainly not flat which would presumably make it difficult to put modern high speed rail along a similar route that was competitive with flying.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoHigh speed rail can take the same grades as regular rail, so far as I know. And on the Water Level Route, there is no grade that gives any kind of problem to regular rail. So, it may not be flat, but it's not non-flat enough to be any kind of an obstacle. Now, if you wanted to say that going up the Hudson clear to Albany before turning west - essentially, taking two sides of a right triangle instead of the hypotenuse - added too much distance for a serious high speed rail line, I could maybe listen to that. If you said that following the Hudson forced you into too many curves, which limited the speed, I could maybe listen to that. But the grades? No way. Not a problem.