5 ms·
There are 20 year olds who demonstrate fine leadership skills and maturity. There are plenty of 40 year olds who do not. Find the best people you can regardless
by vlovich123 4y ago
There are 20 year olds who demonstrate fine leadership skills and maturity. There are plenty of 40 year olds who do not. Find the best people you can regardless of age.
Also, often times the only way to get that experience in the first place is to be put into the positions of leadership to develop your skills.
- znpy 4y agoUhm… I’ve seen the problems with people climbing the corporate ladder too fast. I used to work with this person in his early 30ies and they were in charge of the infrastructure. This person started as a developer and then was tasked with managing infrastructure, while not having never actually worked as a sysadmin and/or having done operations work. Well… after a while it became clear that the limitations of the infrastructure were a reflection of the limitations of this person’s knowledge and understanding of infrastructure. Experience does matter.
- pvorb 4y agoThis is a nice example of the Peter Principle. This person climbed the career ladder until they were no longer good at what they were doing.
- hobobaggins 4y ago"The rise and fall of Ryan Howard" (The Office) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qc35afiM2f4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qc35afiM2f4
- saurik 4y agoOk, but what is the histogram on that? The point wasn't "someone young can't possibly do X" but a combination of "it seems strange that we have an industry built almost entirely of young people" and "somehow this industry believes old people can't do things". Maybe there is a good reason for this, but it is certainly strange: it is like we actively don't want experience that I would have thought should count for a lot (in architecture and planning) while demanding sometimes impossible amounts of experience in things that I'd think wouldn't matter at all (using the new, shiny framework or programming language that those truly experienced people are probably avoiding anyway unless it really really offered something they hadn't seen in their decades of development).
- bombcar 4y agoPart of it was the speed of advancement of tech - at the beginning there wasn't anyone available but the kids and by the time those kids were old enough to get into management/positions of leadership, they were graybeards and some new tech was the important thing and the only people using that were the kids. We're finally getting to the point where there's not much "new" each year or decade, so it's starting to slow down again.
- is_true 4y agoYou can get experience without being in charge of something
- mcculley 4y agoThere are exceptionally talented 20 year olds. There are none with significant leadership experience.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoThe percentage goes up only marginally with age/experience, and that still doesn't keep cultures from hiring older people with zero experience into leadership roles. The culture specifically opts to select older individuals despite there being enough young people with natural leadership skills in contexts where both populations have no experience. Appeal to age runs deep in our species.
- vlovich123 4y agoNone is a bit bold. My college buddies (& lots of people in that peer cohort) founded companies in their 20s and I think they tended more often than not to demonstrate lots of maturity and leadership skills. Certainly more than some stories I’ve heard leaders of bigger tech companies.
- klyrs 4y agoYour parent said "leadership experience," and you responded with "leadership skill." I won't take sides, but I see people talking past each other.
- mcculley 4y agoCorrect. I chose the words “significant” and “experience” deliberately.
- vlovich123 4y agoMy point still stands either way you interpret it. A 26 yold has had 4 years to build leadership skills at college (or even earlier) and another 4 in industry. That’s 8 years of experience which feels substantial. Think about it. There are kids who come out of high school with more coding experience because they got attracted to it at a very early age. There are also kids who do similar kinds of things around leadership.
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoI don't believe that 20 year olds with good leadership skills even exist.
- mattnewton 4y agoLafayette was a major general in the American revolution at 19, he had plenty of leadership skills in his 20’s. Not saying it’s _common_ but historically it seems at least possible.
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoA title is meaningless without context. Knowing he was a major general does not tell me anything about his leadership skills. Often at companies (And I presume in other situations as well), people are thrust into higher level positions purely because they happened to be in the right place at the right time and someone above them left.
- mattnewton 4y agoI’m saying he had the skills because after he was thrust into the position, he lead military operations, then left for France to convince them to contribute more to the American revolution (which they did). Maybe that doesn’t count as true leadership to you but I know it would clear the bar at any company I worked at.
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoRealizing how often people exaggerate their own abilities and working in a "good" company seeing how Senior+ devs operate, I no longer trust any claim of someones skill unless it's by someone who I already trust or there is sufficient context and evidence to support the claim. Too many people/companies claiming to be "world class" or whatever when they are above average at best. I have no knowledge of Lafayette (Not American) and no context or understanding what he did, so my default judgement is that his skill is exaggerated.