3 ms·
That is a remarkably pedantic take on the situation, no? Difficult tasks are difficult. Difficult tasks take time. A credible indicator that they have achieve
by Nevermark 4y ago
That is a remarkably pedantic take on the situation, no?
Difficult tasks are difficult. Difficult tasks take time.
A credible indicator that they have achieved something significant is the widespread acclaim they have received from the global physics and fusion communities.
Repeatability isn’t the only tool in science and nobody is claiming reproducibility isn’t a goal.
If five years from now nobody can reproduce the results, people will take notice. But the evidence is they did what they think they did.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoI'm not sure what you mean by pedantic. But... > A credible indicator that they have achieved something significant is the widespread acclaim they have received from the global physics and fusion communities. How do those people know the result wasn't spurious, if it can't be reproduced? This comment and the one above are questions, do you have an answer?