2 ms·
> Shoplifting is merely a counterexample to the logic "If X is a law that a lot of people break then X is a bad law" Perhaps if 90% of the population shoplifte
by wvenable 15y ago
> Shoplifting is merely a counterexample to the logic "If X is a law that a lot of people break then X is a bad law"
Perhaps if 90% of the population shoplifted, then any law against shoplifting would be bad. What is missing from the question is why the majority of the population would shoplift.
- masterzora 15y agoThat is a very valid line of reasoning and one that I would implore everyone to explore in such a situation. But, as you said, "perhaps". It does not directly follow that it is necessarily a bad law.