If you replaced their entire post with "PG dumb dumb because prideful especially blub" it has the same intellectual content. Even if you agree that the blub the

If you replaced their entire post with "PG dumb dumb because prideful especially blub" it has the same intellectual content. Even if you agree that the blub thesis is wrong that doesn't mean the post itself is well laid out. Their reasoning is belied by the existence of YCombinator itself. Seriously - read it again: it really is that shallow. Try to find a single point within the Blub essay that the essay actually makes which the comment refutes. There isn't one. They don't even try.