3 ms·
Car Talk drove a replica.[1] "You’ve pushed shopping carts with broken casters that handle better. ... No one in his or her right mind would ever venture above
by Animats 4y ago
Car Talk drove a replica.[1] "You’ve pushed shopping carts with broken casters that handle better. ... No one in his or her right mind would ever venture above 45 miles per hour because of the lousy handling."
[1] https://www.cartalk.com/blogs/jamie-lincoln-kitman/test-drives-dymaxion-car https://www.cartalk.com/blogs/jamie-lincoln-kitman/test-driv...
- westurner 4y agoGood old Car Talk. What about with biopolymer superstructure at least, batteries in the surfboard floor, an elegant teardrop airfoil, regenerative braking with natural branching carbon anodes, and an awning?
- sbierwagen 4y agoThose are all solutions to problems the Dymaxion car didn't have? The main complaints of the Car Talk article are the awful handling resulting from rear wheel steering (giving a bad caster angle resulting in no self-centering-- all modern tricycle motor vehicles put the steer tires at the front, even if it complicates the linkages) and the aerodynamic shape that resulted in a large car with surprisingly little usable interior room. (a classic Buckminster problem, as this is still the big downside of geodesic domes) All the big compromises of the Dymaxion car came from the shape, which let it hit a drag coefficient of 0.25. But modern car engineering has simply passed it by: a Prius is 0.24 and a Model S is 0.208. There's no reason to accept the downsides of a Dymaxion car today, which is why nobody ever copied the design.
- westurner 4y agoWhere was the center of gravity - the mass centroid - in terms of handling?
- pcrh 4y ago>Don't drive like my brother!
- evolve2k 4y agoThe CarTalk articles conclusion captures it brilliantly: “So this is the stuff that some automotive legends are made of – a wacky idea, a shameless promoter’s dream and a credulous press, excited to herald the coming of a wonderful new future. “There were a lot of articles about it. But there was never a road test that we could find,” Lane recalled. “People talked about its features and how it was futuristic, but nobody ever said ‘I drove it.’ But do you think they would’ve let someone drive it? It’s terrible. I mean, it’s a ‘30s car, so not so terrible for the time, but I doubt they would’ve gotten glowing reviews.” Thus, the story of the Dymaxion car reminds us, you don’t have to change the world to be famous. You just have to look like you did.”
- emmelaich 4y agoThe idea of rear wheel steering is terrifying just by itself. The turning is very much non-linear wrt to a steering wheel.