3 ms·
They’ve analyzed the data from the experiment to prove that they achieved it (i.e. ruling out all possible other explanations). Assuming there’s been no fraud,
by vlovich123 4y ago
They’ve analyzed the data from the experiment to prove that they achieved it (i.e. ruling out all possible other explanations). Assuming there’s been no fraud, then it’s likely they did achieve it. They’re trying to figure out what the problems are that make reproducibility difficult & I think there’s a new reactor being built that addresses the challenges with reproducing in the current design.
It’s an early signal indicating that we may have line of sight to someone demonstrating working fusion within the next 5 years. Is that not impressive?
- Retric 4y agoWithout reproducing the result it can be extremely difficult to prove something wasn’t a measurement error of some kind.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThat do you mean by "working fusion"? This is a weapons research program wearing a very thin figleaf as a kinda sorta maybe possible power generation option. And fusion weapons have existed for decades - so nothing that nivel here.
- DennisP 4y agoIt's a bit odd how people think nuclear weapons research needs a fig leaf in the US, where overt nuclear weapons funding is about a hundred times more than the government's fusion energy funding. It seems more likely that scientists used the weapons angle to dip into that massive flow of military money for their energy program.
- sudosysgen 4y agoIsn't this at the NIF? The goal was weapons all along.
- DennisP 4y agoSo, you have a source proving the motivations of the people who founded it and run it now? Because I argued above that it makes little sense to simply assume that weapons are the only goal, or even necessarily the primary goal.
- IncRnd 4y ago> I argued above that it makes little sense to simply assume that weapons are the only goal, or even necessarily the primary goal. You can argue all you want. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory is a government-owned, contractor-operated facility managed through a contract between the LLNS Board of Governors and the DOE's National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA). The NNSA in turn works to ensure that the nation's stockpile of nuclear weapons is safe and secure.
- DennisP 4y agoNone of that contradicts what I said, or explains why they bother doing energy research at all.
- sudosysgen 4y agoThis isn't energy research. It's really fundamental research that is directly useful to nuclear weapons. The funding source being mandated solely for nuclear weapons goes against your claim it's not primarily for weapons.
- pxhb 4y agohttps://wci.llnl.gov/ https://wci.llnl.gov/ Note that in the US nuclear weapons are controlled by the DOE, and not the DOD.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThat may be more likely a priori (after all, much "military" funding is in fact a convenient way for the government to fund R&D without huge budget fights in Congress). But, ICF is simply not a viable way to produce fusion power, it is far far far too expensive to operate such a device. So, we can only conclude that they are either deluding themselves, or they are in fact doing fusion weapons research (or, at best, simply fundamental theoretical research into how fusion works) - since the same kinds of conditions or forces are what happens inside a fusion bomb.
- Retric 4y agoNuclear weapons tests have political implications outside and inside the US. It's arguable how much of the NIL is still validating models useful for simulating nuclear weapons vs fundamental research vs energy research. And it’s likely the relative importance of each factor has changed over the programs lifetime.
- D-Coder 4y ago"They’ve analyzed the data from the experiment to prove that they achieved it (i.e. ruling out all possible other explanations)." All possible other explanations that they have thought of.