9 ms·
Are we Blub programmers? (2006)
- test1235 4y agohttps://archive.ph/Ssoqr https://archive.ph/Ssoqr Website is blocked by my ISP as pornography Article's from 2006
- jjice 4y agoIf you don't mind me asking: where are you that your ISP blocks traffic like this outright?
- test1235 4y agoUK, with Sky >Sky Broadband Shield >weblog.raganwald.com has been blocked by Sky Broadband Shield, which lets you choose the websites that can be seen in your home. >The site was blocked because it matched the following categories: > Pornography and Adult
- Blackthorn 4y agoEvery language is capable of blubbing or not blubbing. The lisp wank has really gotten tiring, and I say that as someone who actually likes lisp.
- morelisp 4y agoBlub is an attitude, and people confuse a tool useful for fighting that attitude for absence of the attitude itself. Lisp's power is that you can always use reasonably efficiently it to write the blub you need to solve the problem. But if you already have a suitable enough blub at hand, that's not really helpful.
- Blackthorn 4y agoThat stupid article that originated the word "blub" was nothing but pure lisp wank.
- morelisp 4y agoYes but I've already been banned twice for calling pg a charlatan, so this time I'll leave that for you.
- philosopher1234 4y agoI think I’ve argued with you about go in the past but I’m glad to see we share some common ground
- tryfinally 4y agoThis has been a source of some anxiety for me. C# is such a comfortable place to be in... but I do occasionally feel like I'm missing out by not going out of my comfort zone, towards low-level systems programming. (It is arguable whether the language "more powerful" than Blub is typically lower level or higher level.) These days I worry about it less, primarily because C# let's you "go lower" when needed, and it feels like the concepts translate well enough. (But I still do plan on investing some time in both C and Rust... soon.)
- ReactiveJelly 4y agoI like Rust because it feels like it "spans" well between high-level and low-level use. The highest-level Rust I've written looks kinda like C#, since it has async, mutexes, etc. C is very limited in how high-level it can go.
- tester756 4y agoHah, I'm on the same boat. When I'm checking interesting jobs then only C++ seems like other viable language for me but on the other hand it's C++, painful environment.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kaba0 4y agoA little tongue-in-cheek answer would be that don’t worry, C# will include every new feature in the next release, so you won’t miss anything. But on a more serious note, I really don’t think there is all that much outside C# in terms of features that is not in research phase - perhaps the borrow checker may be regarded as something that is no longer in that phase, but it has limited applicability, and is not needed for automatic memory management. As for C, other than giving you some understanding of the fundamentals, it is a thoroughly unexciting language. I think it is only worth learning to get familiar with pointers, which is important.
- lostmsu 4y agoStill waiting for 64 bit arrays and spans. With spans they wasted such an opportunity to introduce 64 bit memory access - it is very sad.
- sidlls 4y agoPG’s “blub” thesis is particularly terrible, even for him. It’s just a way for him to euphemistically say that programmers who don’t recognize how much better his language is are all dumb. PG’s problem is that he thinks too highly of his own intelligence and can’t seem to understand that his “insights” (especially “blub” style ones) are just not all that deep or useful. So this article is basically deconstructing a garbage thesis that nobody should seriously consider anyway.
- darkerside 4y agoI take it you are a reformed Lisp programmer?
- sidlls 4y agoNo, I just refuse to consider PG to be a walking deity. Personally I have never understood the fascination with his essays. They are generally poorly structured and lacking in any good quality supporting references. If we were submitting his essays in an English or critical thinking class for a grade I suspect the papers would be drenched in red correction ink.
- JoshCole 4y agoYour post would also get a failing grade in an English essay. This says little about your post, because you didn't write it to get a grade in an English class. You are setting up a false evaluation context - it is like watching a competition at the Olympics wherein people fire at a target, but then drawing a circle in your bedroom and saying they missed. Of course they missed: in your post you weren't aiming at an English essay grade so it says nothing about the quality of your post that your comment would fail to get a good grade. In like manner - unless we suppose you are being hypocritical - we can conclude that as Paul was not trying to get a good grade in an English class it matters little whether or not he would receive a good grade within one. The extent to which this false evaluation context is unfair is belied by your need to ignore the actual evaluation context. His essays were written in part to help him think through problems related to starting companies, because he founded and popularized startup incubators. The startup incubator wasn't just successful, it was successful to the point of broad influence. Others have since copied his approach. Now putting aside that the comparison is ridiculous: your guess as to what he would get in grades is probably also wrong: How to Disagree is an example of an essay that would do very well in a Critical Thinking course; actually some people who teach Critical Thinking suggest people ought to read it.
- krallja 4y ago(2006)
- recursivedoubts 4y agodifferent folks like to live at different levels of abstraction, we aren't all level 50 type system mages and, even if we were, that type system wizardry wouldn't help a whole ton in getting strings from browser A into database B and back again. i don't mind blub-tier java code (in fact, I dislike the parts of java where the API designers decided to get fancy, e.g. streams or I/O), it fits my brain pretty well so long as I am not dealing with teutonic AbtractThingDoerFactoryInjectionLookupService type code. i prefer object oriented stuff and I dislike super complicated type systems. I even think java would be a lot cleaner if they had just said "generics are covariant like arrays, don't mess it up" and introduced function types, which captures most of the contravariant situations. this is all blub-tier thinking, no serious computer scientist would advocate for this because it isn't logically sound, but it gives you 80 for 20 and is a lot easier to think about for my level of brain activity. i am grug, hear me "hmmm" https://grugbrain.dev https://grugbrain.dev
- vbezhenar 4y agoLanguages are always designed by big brains so we grugs have to endure that.
- tester756 4y ago>Languages are always designed by big brains What makes you think so? Creating new/any language isn't super-hard
- vbezhenar 4y agoGrugs write business code we dont have time for that nonsense. Big brains like to spend their time writing nonsense which sometimes produces new languages but usually only mess for grugs to deal with after big brain leaves.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zelphirkalt 4y ago
- mikewarot 4y ago[Silly aside] So, the highest level of abstraction is that used by management, since it obviously causes the hiring and firing of programmers, regardless of the languages they use. We've adopted things like Dilbert to point out how silly they are, perhaps it's just because we can't do the 4d chess they do. Or, maybe late stage capitalism is an irrational environment with bad incentives. Backing out a level, it's not possible to look up a level of abstraction, because that view is basically every possible option, and an infinite space. You'd have to violate Gödel's incompleteness theorem to do so.
- draw_down 4y agoI don’t worry about it. Which language you’re using ends up way down the list of Things That Matter in terms of building something useful. I’d think way, way harder about what database I used than which programming language. Most of them are just different stylings of C when you really get down to it. (Ok fine, not Rust.)
- nivertech 4y agoProgramming Language (PL) is such a small part of the Software Engineering / SDLC, let alone running a business. Also no real-life product or business is built using a single PL. When choosing a PL there are lots of other factors to take into account beside its level of abstraction and/or expressiveness.
- wizofaus 4y ago> Also no real-life product or business is built using a single PL I've worked on many "real-life" products where that was exactly the case. And plenty where the only second language was for the script for running the build. I certainly agree choice of PL is only one of many factors that contribute towards success of a software company, but it's still an important one. Choosing a language that makes it impossible to find good devs who want to work for you is almost a guaranteed death sentence.
- activitypea 4y agoThe "blub" thesis assumes that languages can be linearly graded on some, unspecified objective quality, which is a joke.
- goto11 4y agoThe Blub-paradox is that everyone thinks those other languages are blub but their own favorite language is the non-blub pinnacle of creation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- a9h74j 4y agoThat's the blub-paradox. There's also the excuse that one could have completed an assignment if they could have used blub language; this is the fizz-blub excuse.
- pdimitar 4y agoThere are many programmers, myself included, that are under no illusions about the deficiencies of their own favorite languages. Most languages are Blub. Where we the programmers at large fail IMO is that we don't recognize that no language is universal. Some are good at X, others at Y, another group is only good for Z. But we all want to pretend that no no no, language A is perfect and you all are sheep for not seeing it and sticking to languages B, C and D.
- kaba0 4y agoIs there really any language that is all that more productive for a given task? Libraries (somewhat including the standard lib as well) and experience aside, I don’t think one would finish a given task 2x faster in any other general purpose language, let alone more than that. (in agreement with Brook’s famous paper) So by extension, a single language with a huge ecosystem should suffice for any task.
- activitypea 4y agoThe only Blub language is Python, in that it's sort of the arithmetic mean of everything that came before it, and some that came after it. It doesn't have strong opinions on anything, and it's hard to find agreement on what "Pythonic" code is.
- polotics 4y agoNot quite: many higher order and haskell-y things have been implemented on top of python, as well as the usual pedestrian OO stuff, so I don't see python as fitting this one dimensional model of programming language, mostly it demonstrates the limited scope of this "Blub model".
- analog31 4y agoWhat I've noticed about Python is that very few people learn it at a stage when they can make an informed evaluation of programming languages on their merits. And they're not even quite clear on the difference between Python, its libraries, tools, and so forth. They (i.e., we) haven't even learned the entire language. Come for the libraries, the community, jobs, and productivity. Stay for the programming language. It wasn't too long ago that PG said Python programmers were smarter. http://paulgraham.com/pypar.html http://paulgraham.com/pypar.html
- lostmsu 4y agoCame to Python after over 15 years of programming experience for libraries. Would run away as far as I could as fast as I can if not for them.
- gweinberg 4y agoProgramming languages are tools. You can pretty much do anything in any language. Arguing about which language is more "powerful" is like arguing whether a screwdriver or a nail gun is more powerful.
- yccs27 4y agoThe "power" of a good programming language is not about whether you can do something, but whether you can do it easily. It's also about abstraction of interfaces, reusability and similar qualities.
- fluoridation 4y agoYour example seems to contradict your premise, since you can't drive screws with a nail gun and you can't very quickly drive nails into wood with a screwdriver. Actually, your example seems to suggest that although there are actions that any tool can perform, there are tools specifically designed to perform certain actions and so no other tool is better at those actions.
- ok123456 4y agoEmbrace the Blub.
- logdahl 4y agoFeels like I've read this quote somewhere else, maybe some lisp book/manual. Is this the original author? And on the topic of objective quality in PL:s, the article I read had some good points stating that it actually exists.
- pdimitar 4y agoAs others have pointed out, the Blub analogy fails miserably because there's not one universal scale on which to grade programming languages. Wanna do concurrent and parallel programming in a mostly seamless manner, not thinking about deadlocks and being isolated from most dumb mistakes that we all make? Go use Erlang/Elixir, Rust, Golang, OCaml 5.0 and a few others. You can't convince me -- or most practical programmers out there for that matter -- that you can use "most" programming languages "easily" for concurrent and parallel programming. That's bullshit coming from people who are either too idealistic or are stuck deep into their sunk cost fallacy aftermath. Wanna do scientific number-crunching? I hate Python but I know its attached ecosystem excels at this. (Maybe Polars and a few other alternatives as well.) Examples abound. So as far as we can even accept the proposition that "Blub programmers" exist then yes I'd say most of us are kinda sorta "Blub programmers" indeed. It's inevitable; we have limited time and energy and on top of that our brain can burn out. I learned 8 languages and I haven't learned and used a new one ever since I learned Elixir and Rust 5-6 years ago. I am pretty sure I'll learn one or two more and that's going to be it. It's normal. But it still doesn't justify the people who are like "Python everything!". Feels like they didn't even try to find the right tools for the separate jobs. Those people I can't respect.
- kaba0 4y ago> not thinking about deadlocks and being isolated from most dumb mistakes that we all make? Go use Erlang/Elixir, Rust, Golang, OCaml 5.0 and a few others None of them can prevent you from dumb mistakes regarding concurrency (maybe Erlang can do so by runtime checking). At most Rust and Erlang prevents data races (by the borrow checker and by not having shared memory, respectively). I don’t know much about Ocaml, didn’t it have quite a poor concurrency story? But I agree with you in that you can’t do concurrency easily (but I also exclude these languages)
- pdimitar 4y agoWhy do you exclude them though? Golang and Rust do quite amazing and are constantly growing. Even Elixir that many deem niche is used by quite a lot of companies, VERY successfully at that.