5 ms·
> What you're missing is that real humans occasionally need to move a mattress. Or just bring home groceries once a week. People without cars also have to do t
by bawolff 4y ago
> What you're missing is that real humans occasionally need to move a mattress. Or just bring home groceries once a week.
People without cars also have to do that. Groceries can be walked home (i know because i do it) and they also fit on busses. Mattresses are a rare thing and you can rent a taxi.
- radu_floricica 4y agoThen why do people buy cars? You can also manage without running water, people did it for most of human existence, but it doesn't mean it's what we want to do. Money talks - when they afford it, a supermajority of people prefer to own a vehicle. And we're on the cusp of making it non-polluting, cheap and sustainable. Let's not blow it because "trains are marginally more energy efficient".
- dopidopHN 4y agoI bought my first vehicule at 32, when I moved to the US. Prior to that I was relying on public transportation, renting something for vacation, and coordinating with others. In the US that was not sustainable.
- aperson_hello 4y agoThe US is absolutely massive - and in some places, this is absolutely not true and you can use public transport for everything AND it's better than driving. And in other places, the nearest public transport is hours away (by car!!).
- dopidopHN 4y agoYeah, we have cities too. It’s just that there is trains between them. Or buses that are not greyhound. By « we » I mean Europe. It’s small, but large enough. And yeah, density, yadada … It’s fine. Différents place, different organizations. You guys also have a massive army so you will end up being right.
- aperson_hello 4y agoThere are also a whole lot of places places in the US that no one would call a city or even a town. And a whole awful lot of people live in those places! Rural in the US often means living an hour or more drive from the nearest place with a real grocery store.
- tartoran 4y agoThat’s totally doable in a big city such as NYC. Been in here for 20 years and never owned a car. I do drive occasionally and rent a car for a few days to a week. Always works out for me and my non glamorous lifestyle.
- aqme28 4y ago> And we're on the cusp of making it non-polluting, cheap and sustainable Electric cars? They're not really any of these things. They're just not quite as bad as gas vehicles.
- radu_floricica 4y agoI kinda hate this kind of semantics. Paper cups are polluting, using this definition. Literally everything in human civilization is polluting. I practical terms, when using words to actually mean something as opposed to bash opponents over the head with them, EVs take away something which is burning gas exactly in the places with the most population density and replaces them with something which is not burning oil in the places with the most population density. What's left in terms of local pollution? Break pads? Still less than gas vehicles, due to regenerative breaking. Microparticles from tires? Yeah, that's about it. If you also want to count pollution from manufacture and energy generation, then you kinda have to also count pretty much every activity humans engage in, including hiking in the woods because your backpack is manufactured somewhere, using energy. The effects of car pollution for human health are 99% burning fuel. EVs take this away. I think it's fair to call them non-polluting, and not play word games with this.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoLocal air pollution of newish cars is primarily from tyres and brakes, as is the effect of vehicles on waterways. What is from burning is mostly trucks (which are better replaced with trains for about 70% of use cases in a sanely designed area). An EV with decent range will also take until well after it is bricked by a remote software update to break even with keeping a small capacity hatchback running. Producing an EV and building and maintaining car infrastructure uses massive amounts of fossil fuels and entails horrifically destructive mining of large quantities of rare elements such as cobalt and niobium. All for the end result of wasting vast amounts of time, space, and tax money in any urban area to force a suburban lifestyle that is even more destructive, economically unsustainable, and wasteful.
- 4y ago
- petriw 4y agoOwning a car gives you a lot of freedom and flexibility but you either live in a place that requires a car every day, or one where you need it less. If your neighborhood is well planned, with good access to public transportation, groceries, daycare, etc. then renting a car becomes viable for the cases bikes don't cover. Trains, trams, buses and bicycles don't need to cover every case.
- asimpletune 4y agoAlso, there was a recent episode by the YT channel "Not Just Bikes" that really opened my mind to the possibility of 80% of these situations being comfortable accommodated by cargo bikes. They're really amazing and a bike-centric future in cities is actually pretty realistic.
- aqme28 4y agoAs someone who bikes everywhere, I'd say 80% of these situations don't even need a cargo bike. The cargo bike covers maybe another 15%, and the rest you can deal with by renting a van once or twice a year.
- OJFord 4y agoI agree with this - unless you have a single item that almost fills the cargo bucket, panniers are fine. Most cargo bikes I've seen don't have any more carrying capacity than a regular one laden with panniers. It's like truck vs. estate or something - sure there's some added convenience, and it's easier for single big things, but is it worth the specialised vehicle if you have/otherwise need (people capacity, maneuverability, whatever) the other one anyway?
- LunaSea 4y agoCargo bikes are far too expensive for this to work.
- rdtwo 4y agoAnd I could totally do all those things just need to work a couple hours less a day, have more reliable child care and maybe fix the deranged hobo problem so my grocery and body make it home safely after most trips