4 ms·
Roundabouts have a failure mode that 4-way stops don't, akin to starvation in computer science. Consider a roundabout in a right-hand traffic country with conne
by josephcsible 4y ago
Roundabouts have a failure mode that 4-way stops don't, akin to starvation in computer science. Consider a roundabout in a right-hand traffic country with connections in the 4 cardinal directions. If at a given time of day, there's a constant stream of cars from the west that want to go east, and virtually no traffic from the north or east, then a car trying to enter the roundabout from the south will be waiting a very long time.
- jacquesm 4y agoIn practice this rarely happens though.
- throw0101a 4y ago> Roundabouts have a failure mode that 4-way stops don't, akin to starvation in computer science. Putting roundabouts onto streets is not a binary decision: some intersections could be roundabouts, some could be lights, and others could be roundabouts with lights.
- xputer 4y agoIf there's that much traffic, a four way stop will be even worse than a roundabout. You'll need a turbo roundabout, traffic lights or grade separated intersections in that case. Four way stops are one of the dumbest inventions of man kind that are way over used in North America. Everyone has to stop all the time and it leads to scary situations at 2 way stops because people don't expect those anymore. Here is a great video about life without stop signs in the Netherlands: https://youtu.be/42oQN7fy_eM https://youtu.be/42oQN7fy_eM And here are some infinitely better alternatives: Low traffic + low speed: raised intersections where right goes first. Medium traffic + medium speed: priority road with yield signs on side streets and roundabouts High traffic + medium speed: traffic lights High traffic + high speed: grade separated intersections
- josephcsible 4y ago> a four way stop will be even worse than a roundabout. Maybe for people coming from the west, but it'd undeniably be way way better for people coming from the south.
- kitd 4y agoLarge UK roundabouts often have traffic lights that are only operational at peak times, to counter the effect you describe. Small roundabouts don't have this problem.
- alkonaut 4y agoA single “pause” (traffic light, roundabout, stop sign, even just a speed camera or change in speed limit…) in the stretch of the east-west road leading up to the roundabout can usually solve this. You only need occasional breaks in traffic to allow the secondary traffic to join.
- rightbyte 4y agoThere was such a roundabout constructed by my prior job just outside the 4k factory parkinglot entrance. Almost everyone were going from the highway to the parking except me. I had to wait for a bus that was going straight so you could enter or two cars going straight in a row. It got so bad that the workers started to give way to those coming from the starved road so it sorted itself out I guess.