3 ms·
> Nobody thinks judges should police themselves. The question is how to do the policing in a way that respects separation of powers. Maybe you missed it, but t
by woodruffw 4y ago
> Nobody thinks judges should police themselves. The question is how to do the policing in a way that respects separation of powers.
Maybe you missed it, but the claim is directly quoted in the original post[1]. 4 in 5 judges believe that the judiciary should police itself which, by any measure, is not “nobody.”
[1]: https://www.judges.org/news-and-info/judges-prefer-the-judiciary-police-itself-but-there-are-concerns/ https://www.judges.org/news-and-info/judges-prefer-the-judic...
- rayiner 4y agoThe article refers to a statement by Justice Roberts in his end of year address, but Justice Roberts doesn’t use the phrase “police.” I don’t think there’s any dispute that judges are subject to literal “policing.” If they engage in misconduct they can be investigated and prosecuted just like anybody else. And they can be impeached. If by “policing” mean supervising judges the way an employer might supervise an employee—then obviously the judiciary needs to do that itself. Enabling other branches to investigate non-criminal, non-impeachable behavior would be an egregious violation of the separation of powers. The judiciary is a co-equal branch of government. They’re not a department of America Inc. where the President. To use Ken’s example of a judge being an alcoholic, thats obviously not the business of anyone but the judiciary, and Congress if they choose to impeach. It’s the same as a Congressman being an alcoholic.