3 ms·
Whats the purpose of "free-tier" API SaaS. For example, does "free-tier" provide an opportunity for the "API SaaS" operators to collect personal information, o
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
Whats the purpose of "free-tier" API SaaS.
For example, does "free-tier" provide an opportunity for the "API SaaS" operators to collect personal information, or at least email addresses, belonging to users who have no intent of paying the "API SaaS".
The notion of "fraudulent sign-ups" for something allegedly offered for "free" sounds funny. Fraud implies that the alleged perpetrator is obtaining something unlawfully or unfairly. However if that thing is "free" then how could this ever be true. Perhaps the operator of the "free" service actually is expecting to receive (or take) something from the user. When the user fails to provide or allow the operator to take this thing from her, then the operator complains of "fraud".
The problem with this reasoning is that it fails to account for value of the right to privacy.
Consider a telephone analogy, imagine a _toll-free_ number for free information. Imagine the operator referring to callers with unlisted numbers or ones who did not allow caller-ID when calling a toll-free number to obtain free information as comitting "fraud on the service".
As a user, I see no point in "free-tier services" that require "sign-up" because they are really not "free". The user is being asked to give up some of her rights in exchange for the "service".
Consider a public square analogy, imagine someone standing on a street corner handing out _free pamphlets_ but requiring people to "sign-up" to receive one. Then imagine the pamphlet publisher accusing those who did not provide real names and other details when "signing-up" as comitting "fraud".
If the operator ceases the "free-tier" tactics to gather data/information about users and simply sells paid service then this problem "fraud on our service" becomes moot. The question becomes why the operator feels it _must_ provide "free" service.
Consider a www analogy, imagine the "CTO" of HN accusing users who read HN but do not create accounts or provide their real names to HN as committing "fraud on our service".
The www provides an enormous amount of free information. Beyond purchasing service from an ISP, no other "sign-up" is required. Accusing www users of committing "fraud" for retrieving such information without "signing-up" is silly.
The majority of "fraud" occuring via the internet is not being perpetrated by users on "tech" companies. It's being perpetrated by "tech" companies on users.
- derefr 4y agoIn our specific case, we’re providing users query access to datasets supplied to us by channel partners; where these partners pay us to make this data available through our API, because it makes their own ecosystems more valuable for our service to be offered as a part of them. So, technically, our revenue is entirely independent of customers. Which is why free-tier users still benefit us: the more DAU our platform receives, the more our partners value it, and the more they’re willing to pay us to make their data available through it. And before you ask, no, we don’t give our customer data to our partners; all they get to know is DAU and API call count for their network. > Whats the purpose of "free-tier" API SaaS. Mostly? Giving people a taste without the friction of paying, so that they get hooked, and start paying later. Like how you can have one Heroku VM for free. Or how GCP gives you a free month of usage when you sign up. I can’t think of a direct analogy within the API SaaS vertical specifically; but a hypothetical analogy would be if Twilio gave N free credits on each sign-up. > Fraud implies that the alleged perpetrator is obtaining something unlawfully or unfairly. However if that thing is "free" then how could this ever be true. Our free offer is intended to give people a certain amount of credits to spend to try out the service. By registering multiple accounts, you get multiples of that promotional amount. And, in fact, by registering multiple accounts, you escape the rate-limiting we place on every account, to ensure QoS and prevent Denial-of-Service attacks against our service. So we prevent people from registering multiple accounts. Analogy: someone who sees a free sample display in a grocery store, and stuffs the entire display into their bag. And then camps out the display each day, taking the whole thing again the instant it gets restocked. While also going around to N other stores in the chain, camping them out as well. It may not be illegal, but it’s 1. unethical, 2. against the spirit in which the promotion was intended, and 3. screws all the other customers out of their opportunity to get the free thing, because you’re using up their “share.”
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- herbst 4y agoFrom a personal experience charging $9 yearly for a basic tier kept away a lot of bad actors but didn't really drive away users because it's so cheap. My main bad actor problem was fraudulent credit cards but stripe took care of that.
- patmorgan23 4y agoI stopped reading a few paragraphs in. "Free service" does not mean without conditions/limitations. Signing up for multiple accounts when the T&C's say you only get one per person is fraudulent. Especially when they're trying to get around actually paying for the service you are using. Just like if you go to Costco and get free sample of a product, the staff won't let keep taking more and more and more free samples. That's exactly what free usage tiers are, free samples.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago"Signing up for multiple accounts when the T&C's say you only get one per person." As it happens, this particular company does not have such a restriction in their terms. Maybe they should add one, e.g., an explicit prohibition against multiple free API keys assigned to the same user. Using the physical retail analogy, there is no sign stating something like, "One sample per person. Thank you for you cooperation." "Free usage tiers" are nothing like "free samples" in a retail setting. A potential retail customer does not _need_ to provide an IP address in order to take a sample. Costco does not track the behaviour of potential customers who take free samples. Nor is Costco providing "free" samples as bait in order to collect data on behalf of other entities. This particular "API SaaS" crypto/blockchain company collects aggregated data for other entities. Their "legal terms" also permit them to sell this data. According to the HN comment, it wants usage data from IP addresses issued by ISPs not auctions. The "free tier" problem being articulated here with respect to IP addresses is not that there are "too many" potential customers, i.e., too many IP addresses accessing the "free" API, thereby denying some potential customers from obtaining their "free samples". The problem is that the data collector cannot distinguish whether particular IP addresses represent distinct ISP subscribers, and whether such persons may be using automation to avoid mouse clicking, touchscreen tapping or other burdensome interaction. The complaint is that the "tech" company's efforts to _collect data about computer users_ are not working. "Tech" companies require people to "sign-up". The incorporated "tech" website gets something in return for the "free" service. API's can be rate-limited. Potential paying customers, or non-paying users, can easily be blocked from using the API. This can all be done remotely from a keyboard. The retailer offering free samples of physical goods without requiring any information cannot adjust the number of samples available to each potenital customer, and certainly not remotely from a keyboard. As such, the "limited supply" argument falls short. The complaint here is that a "tech" company wants to collect data about computer users and monetise it, and this is difficult because IP addresses do not necessary represent distinct computer users with certain charactersistics, not that a retailer is "running out of free samples".
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoAs it happens, this particular company does not include a restriction in their terms and conditions that explicitly prohibits the same user from receiving multiple free API keys. Using a physical retail store analogy, there is no sign stating something like, "One sample per person. Thank you for you cooperation." "Free usage tiers" are nothing like "free samples" in a retail setting. A potential retail customer does not _need_ to provide an IP address in order to take a sample. The retailer does not track the behaviour of potential customers who take free samples. Nor is it providing "free" samples as bait in order to collect data on behalf of other entities. This particular "API SaaS" crypto/blockchain company collects aggregated data for other entities. Their "legal terms" also permit them to sell this data. According to the HN comment, it wants usage data from IP addresses issued by ISPs not auctions. The "free tier" problem being articulated here with respect to IP addresses is not that there are "too many" potential customers, i.e., too many IP addresses accessing the "free" API, thereby denying some potential customers from obtaining their "free samples". The problem is that the data collector cannot distinguish whether particular IP addresses represent distinct ISP subscribers, and whether such persons may be using automation to avoid mouse clicking, touchscreen tapping or other burdensome interaction. The complaint is that the "tech" company's efforts to _collect data about computer users_ are not working. APIs can be rate-limited. IP addresses can be blocked. All with a few keystrokes. Users are granted _permission_ to use the "free" sample and that permission can be revoked. Retailers of physical goods have no such abilities. They generally cannot control how many samples a person takes, they generally cannot ban selected people from taking samples, and they certainly cannot do this with a few keystrokes. Generally, the physical retailer will have a finite suply of free samples. When one person takes a sample, that is one less sample available for someone else. Whereas when one person accesses data, it does not result in "less data" for another person to access. There is no such depletion. As such, the "limited supply" argument falls short. The complaint here is that a "tech" company wants to collect data about computer users and monetise it, and this is difficult because IP addresses do not necessary represent distinct computer users with certain charactersistics, not that a retailer is "running out of free samples".