4 ms·
Because private cars are incredibly convenient compared to street cars. Faced with significant tax increases for street cars that only go a few places, and car
by rayiner 4y ago
Because private cars are incredibly convenient compared to street cars. Faced with significant tax increases for street cars that only go a few places, and car infrastructure that can allow people to go directly from point to point, it was a no brainer.
I just loaded up my Toyota 4Runner and dumped a bunch of junk at the town dump. I didn’t plan this in advance, I didn’t have to rent a truck (how do I get there anyway?) I just did it on a whim. To compete with the convenience of point to point private transit, public transit would have to be vastly cheaper and it isn’t.
- bobthepanda 4y agoAs far as a truck; most moving companies in my area also offer junk haulage, and the rates are pretty decent for something I do rarely (like less than once a year)
- ipaddr 4y agoWhat is a decent rate for you?
- bobthepanda 4y agoThe city dump charges a minimum fee of $33 and that increases per ton. I junked a sectional for $50, I think?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JamesBarney 4y agoBut will the city dump pick up the sectional for you?
- bobthepanda 4y agoTo be clear: The city dump, even if you bring your own car, will charge a minimum of $33. They don’t offer curbside pickup themselves. The movers/haulers charge $50 for a sectional, and there isn’t a separate line item for the dump fee. I consider this to generally be a decent price, since then I don’t have to pay for a car.
- JamesBarney 4y agoWeird, in Houston its hard to find anyone to move a couch 20 blocks for less than $200.
- bobthepanda 4y agoOh, actual moving costs more. How it works here is that you get charged for labor time and space taken up in a truck, and just plain junking requires very little of the former compared to moving where packing, unpacking, and possibly dismantling and reassembly come into play. The company I used has a rate for using an eighth of a truck, which is what I was charged for a couch.
- NoToP 4y agoThis comment is written from the perspective of cars and transit as they exist today in much of America, and the connotations associated with them. There are places you could be living where public transit is more convenient than a car. You don't have to plan your trips because the train is frequent enough that you just show up whenever you want. And you aren't limited to just one place because there's a network of them and you simply transfer to the line you need. It's not entirely the case that you can go "anywhere" with a car. You can go anywhere where a road has been built and parking is provided. But if the car is limited to built infrastructure, by that measure the train also goes anywhere. Places like Tokyo prove there was an alternative path, and places like New York prove that it's not inherently impossible in America. So that brings us back where we started. Why did people vote / spend one way and not the other?
- rayiner 4y agoI’m not writing from an American perspective. I love Tokyo and go there a couple of times a year for business. Half the people in Tokyo have a car, and outside Tokyo nearly everyone has a car. Nobody takes the Tokyo Metro or Toei subway to haul junk. Your comparison is invalid: building minimal road infrastructure is vastly cheaper than building rail. You need economies of scale to justify the expense of rail construction. It makes no sense to build rail past my wife’s grandma’s house in rural Oregon. At the same time, even when my wife was growing up in the city (Eugene, where the University of Oregon is), they were going to grandma’s house or somewhere similarly low density regularly enough where they needed a car anyway. And once they had incurred the expense of a car, it makes sense to vote for more car infrastructure in the city rather than the capital expense of rail infrastructure.
- travisporter 4y agoHauling junk really isn’t in the purview of a transit system to be fair to parent