5 ms·
More than 10k Canadians received a medically-assisted death in 2021
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hey2022 4y agoThe rise is somewhat predictable and surprising at the same time. Personally I don’t think there is anything more empowering (in this domain) than knowing that you can be in control of the conditions of your own death. The surprising part is perhaps the speed at which this fundamental societal shift is happening. 3.3% of all deaths in Canada were assisted deaths in 2021!
- hluska 4y agoA very close relative suffered for years before she finally passed away. She passed away before medical assistance in death was available. Watching that hardcore spark plug of a human be absolutely destroyed by a disease was awful and changed my view on medical assistance in death. We wouldn’t make a dog go through what she did. Offering her some control over her way out would have been much more humane than what she ended up going through.
- rob_c 4y agoYes but during a time when there is mass psycological depression and other chaos is difficult to believe this change is "just due to people becoming more comfortable with the idea". For reference I'm in favour of MAID as a concept. But a 30% jump in the same year there is other chaos should set alarm bells ringing. The defence of this reached the same levels as a completely different society is somehow also doubly alarming to me...
- swatcoder 4y agoI understand why it might for you and your own values, but why should that sound alarm bells for others who might see things differently? Imagine that you're one of these patients. If you're looking at the last poor years of your life anyway, and it turns out that you see they'll be spent in the shadow of a global pandemic and economic crisis, it's sensible that you might want to just turn out the lights and go to bed already. Making that choice on their own terms isn't something that people do flippantly; instead of assuming we know what the right answer should be for them, isn't it more humble and respectful to assume they made a sound choice and then draw insight from how they were able to do so?
- rob_c 4y ago> why should that sound alarm bells for others who might see things differently? This is not a reversible decision like salted or caramel popcorn. All I'm saying is that numbers like that with a human life be treated seriously. I'm not saying the usual madness of 'halt a thing until we know more'. I'm just saying wouldn't it be prudent to ask the question rather than blindly accepting this as a good thing. I'm not saying anything disingenuous or in bad faith here so please don't assume my argument comes from this position, this just runs the risk of turning any conversation toxic and political which I'm trying to avoid.
- hluska 4y agoHow familiar are you with Canada’s program?? Do you know that mental illness alone is currently not an acceptable reason to seek out medical assistance in death? Do you know that you have to have two fully independent health care practitioners sign off on the request? It would be quite hard to get MAID if you’re not eligible. I completely understand your concern and if it was administered differently I would share them, but I’ve learned a lot about the program and have a lot of trust in how it’s administered.
- rob_c 4y agoI'm familiar enough with the way that these things are structured, why and how policy are implemented from a bureaucratic perspective that I understand when there are un-intentional sytematic bias. I'm not talking about access to reatment. I'm not talking about individual cases here. As I have said. I am in favour of this in concept and I just think that the reasoning away from a very large spike is concerningly poor and the sort of thing that's used as an excuse if '22 numbers shot up another 30-40% that 'well that's just Canada'. Again, please don't read intentionally or not that I'm talking about access or applicability. This again runs the risk of taking a conversation down a political or toxic discussion path and serves nobody. I'm talking about _proper_ large scale understanding of trends here. At best this is bad reporting of a phenomena, at worse there is something there that might be looked back on with concern.
- hluska 4y agoNow you’re arguing in poor faith. I never said that that’s “just Canada”. Rather, I tried to ask how much you know about the Canadian implementation of MAID. You talked around those questions so now it’s time for some facts. 1.) The increase in 2021 numbers can be explained by bill C-7. C-7 changed eligibility for MAID. When C-7 received royal assent it meant that a patient’s death no longer had to be reasonably foreseeable for them to be eligible for MAID. 2.) Numbers in 2022 will rise as more physicians are being trained in MAID and getting more comfortable with the idea. 3.) Numbers in 2023 will rise even more as in March, mental illness as a sole condition will become eligible for MAID. Again, all of this is guided by policy that would make it very hard to receive MAID if you’re not actually eligible. Those are facts and at this point, it seems like you’re trying to use some personal moral queasiness as a way to overlook the evolution of policy.
- walterbell 4y agohttps://apnews.com/article/covid-science-health-toronto-7c631558a457188d2bd2b5cfd360a867 https://apnews.com/article/covid-science-health-toronto-7c63... > His application for euthanasia listed only one health condition as the reason for his request to die: hearing loss. Nichols’ family reported the case to police and health authorities, arguing that he lacked the capacity to understand the process and was not suffering unbearably — among the requirements for euthanasia. They say he was not taking needed medication, wasn’t using the cochlear implant that helped him hear, and that hospital staffers improperly helped him request euthanasia. “Alan was basically put to death,” his brother Gary Nichols said. > Disability experts say the story is not unique in Canada, which arguably has the world’s most permissive euthanasia rules — allowing people with serious disabilities to choose to be killed in the absence of any other medical issue.
- julianlam 4y agoThere will always be people who misuse systems to achieve their own ends (in this case, quite literally.) What's important to also realize is that the solution isn't to make the system harder to use, because a side effect of that will be that people who NEED said system will find it inaccessible. e.g. disability insurance is rife with fraud. Insurers combat this by auditing nearly all applications for fraud, and this has the effect of denying recompense for those who are truly disabled, for they do not, will not, or cannot jump through all the arbitrary hoops introduced by the insurer to combat fraud. I don't have a solution for fraud and abuse of systems, however.
- ramraj07 4y agoGiven that euthanasia isn’t even allowed in other places, and given whats at stake (a literal human life), it seems perfectly acceptable to make it harder to get killed by the government. The article linked in the parent comment is very well written, please read it. It recommends exactly what Canada should do to mitigate the situation. They have no review boards, and actively recommend NURSE PRACTITIONERS to suggest euthanasia to patients as a treatment alternative. That sounds evil.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pedalpete 4y agoI have a relative who chose MAID last year, rather than suffer a fairly quick and painful death. As a Canadian, I am happy we have this humane option. I believe it is imperative that we accept death as part of life, and each get to a point where we are accepting of death, but not seeking it without reason. What surprised me most about the process was how quickly it occured. Once my relative made the decision, informed the appropriate parties, went through psychological tests, it was only a matter of days before they were gone. It was shocking to me how quickly it came, but it was what THEY wanted, and they were ready. It isn't up to me, which is the right approach.
- throwntoday 4y agoMy only concern is it becoming normalized to the point those suffering from long-term depression are encouraged to seek a medically assisted suicide rather than play the hand they were dealt. I can't think of many crimes greater than a government encouraging people to kill themselves instead of helping them overcome their tribulations.
- lwansbrough 4y agoWhile I agree, it's just as easy for a nihilist to argue that it doesn't matter at all. It purely comes from your perspective on the value of life, which in the case of Canada, the government leaves to the holder of that life.
- pedalpete 4y agoI think "encouraging" is very much not the correct word. Even "option" wouldn't be right. It's "allowing".
- rob_c 4y agoHow is this not a major international scandal?
- seized 4y agoWhy should it be? Theres a strict process in place to request it, it requires phycological evaluation, you can't request it in an unsound state of mind (too far gone into dementia for example). If someone has a terminal disease then what's the concern? Your religion? (Canadian who supports this being available).
- rob_c 4y agoplease don't assume religious biggotry here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32453364#32455056 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32453364#32455056 This is a major jump with a flippant response, this is not an individul case, but a social change which should be closely monitored not just 'well it works for europeans'...
- moaf 4y agoI support medically assisted death, but there are legitimate issues that should be discussed and it really doesn't get much attention in Canada. For example, beginning in 2023, those suffering from mental illness alone will be eligible for medically assisted death. I think this raises serious issues of equity in Canada for the physically and mentally disabled. Making no meaningful changes to the health care system to better support these people, but instead offering medically assisted death, does not seem very compassionate at all.
- refurb 4y agohttps://www.researchgate.net/publication/313384992_Cost_analysis_of_medical_assistance_in_dying_in_Canada https://www.researchgate.net/publication/313384992_Cost_anal... "Medical assistance in dying could reduce annual health care spending across Canada by between $34.7 million and $138.8 million, exceeding the $1.5-$14.8 million in direct costs associated with its implementation."