3 ms·
The last 409A price, when it's fresh (for the current tax year) and there has been no funding activities or other definitive material effects (such as a pending
by toast0 4y ago
The last 409A price, when it's fresh (for the current tax year) and there has been no funding activities or other definitive material effects (such as a pending merger) is de jure the FMV.
Asking for options granted at a strike price other than FMV is bad for everyone. Negotiating on strike price is kind of silly anyway. In a succesful exit, the strike price is going to be pennies on the dollar (I had a cost basis of like 9 cents per share on shares I sold for $33-60 dollars), if you halve that, it's still nothing. If it's a mediocre exit, then it makes a meaningful difference, but still pretty small. For an unsuccesful exit, it makes little difference unless you exercised.
You could ask them to do a new 409A valuation, but they're time consuming and expensive, so it's likely not worth the trouble. If you want to negotiate for something, negotiate for your options to be canceled and reissued in February if the Jan 2023 comes back lower.