3 ms·
The solution to climate change and all these crises is a vastly reduced human population living in small agrarian communities with preindustrial lifestyles. We
by bitwize 4y ago
The solution to climate change and all these crises is a vastly reduced human population living in small agrarian communities with preindustrial lifestyles. We keep having these environmental crises because technological civilization was a mistake.
- feanaro 4y agoIt was only a "mistake" if the word is stripped of its normal meaning since it was inevitable. It may lead to our downfall, but it was then an inevitable downfall. That said, it's not at all obvious that this is the case yet.
- zzo38computer 4y agoI do think that the human population is too much, but so is dangerous chemicals in the environment. But, additionally to that is harmfulness to nonhuman environment (animals/plants) as well as human, and also harmfulness earning money at the expense of everything else in this world.
- zmgsabst 4y ago
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoI didn't hear a call for killing people. People die without any extra help. We should just stop having so many babies.
- zmgsabst 4y ago
- switchbak 4y agoI have yet to hear an approach to this that isn't terribly inhumane. Agreed that the end result sounds like a positive one (on just environmental terms), but there's a tremendous amount of complexity and unintended consequences involved. My country alone is already below the rate of replacement. Questions quickly arise around who gets to decide who the people are that are allowed to breed. I can't think of a more contentious subject. It's also such an invasion of personal freedom. I don't have answers here, but this is an incredibly hard thing to do at all (outside of China), and it's not clear it can be done ethically at all.
- xbar 4y agoEnvironmentalism never turns into death cults. Fanaticism did not drive 3M to create PFAS nor DuPont to create DDT, nor did fanaticism drive them to continue its use. Your strawmen need work.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> Your strawmen need work. Your reply is a strawman and factually untrue, as I was responding specifically to someone who called for the massive reduction in human population — justifying that with environmentalism. Ironically, you’re the one engaged in fallacies while gaslighting.
- 4y ago
- worldshit 4y agoagree agree agree. but it's completely unrealistic to hope that humans will do what must be done on their own...
- justbored123 4y agoWhat the hell are you talking about??? Technological civilization arouse because our ancestors living in "small agrarian communities" were tired of living in a nightmare in which their children died like flies and the starved to death periodically every time the climate farted. I'm tired on hearing entitled little sh1ts like you that have lived incredibly pampered lives and don't have a clue of what is like to have to live without a refrigerator, hvac or modern medicine.
- bitwize 4y ago> Technological civilization arouse because our ancestors living in "small agrarian communities" were tired of living in a nightmare in which their children died like flies and the starved to death periodically every time the climate farted. This is what Daniel Quinn calls "living in the hands of the gods". We are not really fit to do anything else. Humans have survived for hundreds of thousands of years living off what the land provides them in its natural course. Civilization will probably not make it much past ten thousand years, if that. So tell me again which is the bigger nightmare: living and dying according to the whims of nature, being one small part in a society that adapts and harmonizes to nature; or the death of billions, and the extermination of considerable amounts of other life, all because we wanted to rule in place of the gods and never learned not to shit where we eat.
- mathlover2 4y ago> We are not really fit to do anything else. If you go by that logic we are only fit to live in tropical savannahs in Africa where modern humans originated. What I find supremely arrogant, though, is any Westerner who, while living in comfort and safety amidst high technology, proposes that everyone in the world should just be content with not having the comforts they are currently using (including some, like vaccines and modern medicine, which arguably have vastly less negative effects than PFAS and burning fossil fuels). Anyone actually serious about this philosophy should try as much as possible to make their lifestyles like what they want for everyone. It probably wouldn't convince everyone, but it would certainly earn them a lot more respect.