6 ms·
The world could reach 100% renewable energy by next year if every citizen took a massive cut to their quality of life. And it isn't going to happen at all if a
by londons_explore 4y ago
The world could reach 100% renewable energy by next year if every citizen took a massive cut to their quality of life.
And it isn't going to happen at all if at least some citizens don't take a cut to their quality of life (compared to what they could have had with no action)
So it's a trade-off....
- goodpoint 4y agoThis is plain false. Quality of life is in no way strictly correlated with energy usage and pollution. It's product of thousands more variables and the most important ones are urban planning and social issues.
- perrygeo 4y agoQuality of Life is too fuzzy to make such a strong statement. But if we take economic output as a proxy, it's your view that is demonstrably false. You're roughly claiming that "Decoupling" (economic growth without resource consumption) is not only possible but has already occurred? Seriously? Global GDP is very highly correlated with energy use, fossil fuel use specifically. You probably heard that some countries (the US, EU) are in the process of decoupling. Bullshit. Looking at this on a per-country basis is a deeply flawed analysis at best, a deceptive account trick. We have a global trade network and you can't outsource your fuel consumption to China, import their products, and call yourself green. If you extend the analysis globally, you will not find decoupling at all - energy is the economy. I encourage you to read this paper by the European Environmental Bureau: https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/ https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/
- goodpoint 4y ago> Quality of Life is too fuzzy to make such a strong statement. So it is GDP. Also environmental impact, happiness an much more. Yet you can find plenty of lists of countries by per capita income, QoL and so on and make comparisons. > But if we take economic output as a proxy, it's your view that is demonstrably false. Wrong. > You're roughly claiming that ... is not only possible but has already occurred? It's clearly shown if you compare QoL vs environmental impact across nothern european countries, japan and US for example. US being pretty terrible at that, to no surprise. > Bullshit. You can do better. > I encourage you to read this paper by the European Environmental Bureau: https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/ https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/ From the landing page: "Is it possible to enjoy both economic growth and environmental sustainability?" ...which is nowhere close to my initial point. And for the record I'm actually going to finish reading the pdf instead of just calling things "Bullshit"
- perrygeo 4y ago> Bullshit Sorry for the language but the argument that you can have economic growth without energy/resource consumption is just plain false. I'm deeply frustrated that people continue parroting that view without any credible evidence. To be fair to you, your initial point only hinted at Decoupling and didn't claim it directly. My bad. > "Is it possible to enjoy both economic growth and environmental sustainability?" ...which is nowhere close to my initial point So in your view, quality of life and happiness are separate concerns from "the economy"? I truly hope you're right! We may never be able to decouple resource extraction from economic production - but we might have a shot at decoupling economic production from QoL if we can learn to collectively reduce our consumption and find more fulfilling ways to live on less. There's no historical precedent for a civilization ever willingly de-growing themselves and surviving (see the work of Joseph Tainter) let alone thriving, but one can hope.
- curiousgal 4y agoSee I hate this kind of statements. Even if every citizen "did their part" simple actions by corporations can undo all of their effort.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoNo! Implying that this has to do with lifestyle is the same trite that BP came up with when they pushed the PR spin of "carbon footprint" to deflect attention onto consumers. What you suggest would push many Energy companies and the entire Oil&Gas complex into insolvency. So I can guarantee that politically there will be no "trade-off". Of course emissions per capita matter but this constant spin that consumers drive demand and depiction of industry as a passive agent victim of consumer desire is naive at best and malicious at worse.