3 ms·
What would be the downside of Hyundai just making all the info in this blog post public info? They could start fostering an app ecosystem for their cars. And
by londons_explore 4y ago
What would be the downside of Hyundai just making all the info in this blog post public info?
They could start fostering an app ecosystem for their cars.
And it would be an extra selling point for their cars (especially if there are apps that won't run in other cars).
And it might even turn into a new revenue stream by building an app store.
- meibo 4y agoThere are some things you don't want to run apps on, even if they're sandboxed, which isn't the case here - I would count "computer in my car that can talk to the stuff that makes it go" as one of these things.
- EMIRELADERO 4y agoAnd yet most cars run apps. Are you arguing that those not coming from/authorized by the manufacturer are less legitimate, or should not deserve the same treatment?
- lozenge 4y agoThat seems... incredibly obvious? If there's a software bug that is a safety risk, the regulatory agencies force the manufacturer to implement a recall at their own expense. That wouldn't be the case for third party software.
- teamonkey 4y agoThe garage can charge ridiculous amounts of money for trivial features and upgrades. Although the manufacturer may benefit from an App Store, the garage gets nothing. Toyota, for example, charges something like $150 for a single satnav maps update, although now CarPlay/Android Auto is a standard feature and has tanked that market.
- rasz 4y agoGM charges for access to key cloning and module programming/pairing. Its not overly expensive (~$40 per module), but super annoying and bug infested (software crashing/failing/constantly updating). https://www.acdelcotds.com https://www.acdelcotds.com Afaik Ford has similar program where you pay one time fee for ability to reprogram modules remotely. Imo a good deal for consumers.
- Nextgrid 4y ago> GM charges for access to key cloning and module programming/pairing A lot of this is done entirely in security by obscurity so there might not even be any actual cryptography/authentication involved. It's purely a rent-seeking operation.
- Nextgrid 4y ago> downside of Hyundai just making all the info in this blog post public info? All the CAN protocol data being public means there's no need for expensive documentation, proprietary scan tools or trips to the dealership for key/module programming if it's all been reverse-engineered (a lot of programming and security-related things in cars are more down to obscurity than actual public-key-cryptographic authentication). Hell, it may even remove the need for expensive modules (over 1k bucks for what is essentially a slow microcontroller on a conformal-coated board running shitty firmware) if the docs allow third-parties to reimplement module functionality on the cheap. It would also blow up any future attempts at subscription-based heated seats or A/C if the published docs make bypassing it trivial.