7 ms·
On a road to Prizren with a Free Software Phone
- throwaway81523 4y agoPhone is a Librem 5 in case that was what you wanted to know.
- shepherdjerred 4y agoHow much harder is it to own one of these phones vs an iPhone? I loved hacking on my smartphone when I was in high school, but now I'd like something that just works (or at least requires only a small amount of effort). I'd really like a barebones phone that has only the bare essentials, ideally not even a web browser.
- flipnotic 4y agoI'm building a barebones phone like you describe, and am looking for feedback from people. Mind if I get in contact?
- shepherdjerred 4y agoSure thing! My email is in my profile.
- em-bee 4y agoit really depends on how you use it. i had non-android phones before. (even openmoko). calling, sms, taking notes. those phones had less apps, but they worked. so the question of "how much harder" is really a question of "what apps to you need". today i am on android (/e/) because there are a few android apps that are absolutely essential for me now. but if i didn't need those specific apps, then any other system would be just fine.
- chrisseaton 4y agoPeople used to say they wanted a phone that just did the basics - calling, SMS. The thing is... are those the basics now? I almost never make phone calls and I think I've literally never sent an SMS on my current phone. The basics now are the apps - Signal, WhatsApp, Twitter and Instagram DMs, etc. I think that's typical for most people?
- sethhochberg 4y agoThey're probably not defined as basics based on how frequently people use them compared to apps, but, phone and SMS are still the lowest common denominator. I've been dealing with the police recently after a minor burglary. That involved both making and receiving phone calls. My dentist has an automated system that texts to confirm appointments. Despite its downsides, SMS-based 2FA is ubiquitous and you don't always have ability to opt into something more secure. I'd expect most people elect to use apps for communication when they've got an option, but there are tons of scenarios in modern life where you really don't have the option.
- at-fates-hands 4y agoI think it could be a generational thing. My nephew who's 26, runs a pool company. He said he barely makes any phone calls and most of his appointments and interactions with clients and friends are all mainly done through texting. The only social media he uses is Instagram. My daughter is 15. She still uses the phone extensively for conferencing her friends when playing online games. She's uses the iphone Facetime extensively as well if she's not playing online games. Most of her friends do little texting and actually do call each other much more frequently and for much longer periods of time. Not unusual for her to be on the phone with one of her online buddies living in Florida for a few hours. Their conversations frequently revolve around videos they share or shows they're watching. They all have Apple devices and I've been surprised at the multiple different ways they're utilizing the phone feature on their devices in ways I never imagined. Now me? I'm in my early 40's, my parents are their 70's and they're using the texting feature a lot more nowadays. My Mom and Dad both still prefer to use the phone, but my Dad's hearing is starting to become an issue, so texting allows him to have really good conversations without fear of losing out on anything. Myself, I still use the phone quite a bit, texting seems to to be tapering off in favor of email and phone calls with my friends and freelance clients which I never thought would happen. I really thought the same thing, that the phone part of your device was quickly becoming obsolete. I've been surprised with my daughter's generation who are finding new ways to utilize the feature and combine with the other things her and friends love most - online gaming, sharing videos, sharing and discussing their favorite topics of conversation.
- woodrowbarlow 4y agoif free software is not your motivator, consider the light phone 2. it's a b&w e-ink phone that does 4g LTE calls/sms/hotspot, with apps for gps navigation and podcasts.
- gonehome 4y agoThe Punkt also has Signal: https://www.punkt.ch/en/products/mp02-4g-mobile-phone/ https://www.punkt.ch/en/products/mp02-4g-mobile-phone/ I think these are neat, but have an iPhone 13 Mini because it’s hard to beat Apple’s quality and privacy work.
- shepherdjerred 4y agoI've seen those and have been tempted. I think I'd need two phones to pull that off. There are some things that require an iOS or Android compatible phone, e.g. most smart home stuff cannot be setup without a smartphone.
- woodrowbarlow 4y agoin the states, verizon has a number share program (two sim cards, one phone number). they consider the light phone a "wearable" and the monthly rate is similar to stand-alone data hotspots -- far cheaper than adding a "real" second phone to the plan.
- user764743 4y agoIf only people could get the phone they pre-ordered. The /r/purism subreddit is so much filled with horror stories and dishonest marketing practices by the company that I decided against ordering one.
- monopoliessuck 4y agoI was a super early pre-order and then waited years for SOMETHING. I eventually asked for a refund which they said they'd honor. I've now been in the refund "queue" for over a year or two. I've lost count of the exact number of years, promises and emails at this point. I understand growing pains, but purism is neither a transparent nor a trustworthy company. Buy a PinePhone Pro and call it a day. It's still not ready for prime time as a daily driver, IMO, but the company is a breath of fresh air in comparison.
- piethesailorman 4y agoThis is a bummer. Did you order the USA model or the Chinese model?
- monopoliessuck 4y agoThe US model didn't exist even as a concept at the time I pre-ordered. I ordered before the first lot, but picked Evergreen because I wanted it to work and I didn't mind funding and waiting, but this is crazy. I realize there's a valid difference between place of origin, but for me sitting here empty handed, the US model just seemed like a way to upcharge for a product that hardly existed in any form. Chinese? American? Whatever, for me vapor is vapor no matter where it's supposed to be coming from "eventually".
- caboteria 4y agoWhen I asked for a refund I was told that they had changed their mind and they were no longer honoring their original policies. I have the phone now and it's pretty much a paperweight. Someday I might want to play around with it but at the moment it's more of a toy and less of a phone.
- emptyparadise 4y agoVery nice, looks like these open phones are moving forward. Would love to have a new Nokia N900.
- HidyBush 4y agoWe still don't have a free software feature phone that has the same polish as bottom of the barrel flip phones from 20 years ago. I have a PinePhone and I'm seriously asking myself how much time it will take to get an experience remotely comparable with even the first iPhone, both in terms of ease of use and features. I believe people are rushing down this road with no real vision of what such a device needs to feel useable. I am planning to start developing something for the PinePhone in foreseeable the future, but just the difficulty in retrieving resources about understanding how the Linux kernel is patched to run on that ARM board, the necessary drivers and how all the various sensors and interfaces communicate really lets me down
- wiz21c 4y ago>>> just the difficulty in retrieving resources about understanding how the Linux kernel is patched to run on that ARM board, the necessary drivers and how all the various sensors and interfaces communicate really lets me down maybe you could give it a try and document your trip ? As someone who'd love to help the cause, but who doesn't have much time, a good documentation would help.
- megous 4y agoIt all mostly uses standard Linux interfaces. IIO for most sensors, V4L2 for camera, AT interface for modem, ALSA for codec audio controls, I2C to talk with accessories, USB configfs to configure USB gadgets,... I struggle to recall something that's purely Pinephone specific from the userspace perspective. I tried almost all the lowest level Linux HW interfaces usable on Pinephone.
- longrod 4y agoIt took Linux desktop some 20 years to reach the point where you could just use it i.e., no tinkering needed, everything works by default, you install the software you need and that's it. It's not perfect even now but it's much better. I rarely have to pop into the terminal to tinker with a system config file now. We don't have 20 years to wait when it comes to free software phones. The problem is that phones are not meant to be hacked upon. They are meant to be used. Sure, it may feel nice to tinker and stuff but everything should just work before you can even consider it a daily driver. I haven't personally used Librem or Pinephone so I don't know how far along they are in terms of user experience (not developer experience).
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI have not used Librem, but I own a Pinephone. Anecdotally, while the initial impression of community edition was not great ( I personally blame ubuntu as default OS ), I eventually tried PostmarketOS ( on HN recommendation actually ) and I am now going through side by side testing with my work phone as a backup. For basic stuff ( phone, text, light net use ) it works. It is not polished. It is very much underpowered.. but there is something to be said for having that level of control over a machine. I think I agree with you; it will take take time the same way it did with desktop linux. Still, I am more optimistic now.. we are starting to have real options outside of the duopoly forced down humanity's throats. And.. even if you are not ready to jump onto new hardware, you can install Kali linux in Android now[1]. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxOGyuGq0Ts https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxOGyuGq0Ts
- squarefoot 4y ago> you can install Kali linux in Android now This solves some problems (running Linux UI and apps) but leaves some very important others unaddressed (security). The point isn't just installing Linux but also removing from devices every piece of non free -as in not open, therefore non auditable and by extension not trustworthy- piece of firmware/OS/software. The hardest part is achieving that goal and many initiatives are struggling to get as close as possible to that point. As a Linux guy, I would love being able to turn a spyware ridden phone into a 100% open Linux platform, but if someone said like that it can be done, but they're using *BSD, or Haiku, or whatewer 100% open OS out there, that would be great anyway.
- stuaxo 4y agoNaming is always funny, not sure I would have chosen a project name so close to "Prison"
- tildef 4y agoI don't think Prizren is part of any project name--it just happened to be where DebConf was hosted this year. Unless you're referring to Purism.
- ardit33 4y agoAnybody reading this, Prizren is a very beautiful historical town/city. It has some really nice old architecture, plus a castle, and there is plenty to explore around the area. It has a lot of old school Albanian gold and silver shops, that do some really interesting/old style jewelry, as back in the Ottoman era used to be an important stop for merchants.
- goodpoint 4y agoThis comment section has a bunch of people whining that Free Software phones developed by mostly *unpaid volunteers* are not good enough. Also, nobody gifted me a pony today.
- monopoliessuck 4y agoThis is not the reality on the ground here, though I agree with you with FOSS whining in general. Purism marketed their phone as the eventual iPhone/Android killer. "Get the hardware, and the software will ripen with every update in your hand", was their claim. Purism created the hardware very slowly and worked on the software in-house themselves in a very "cathedral-esque" paradigm. Without hardware, you don't have passionate *unpaid volunteers* so stuff was slow and incomplete. Developers were also just pleading for something to hack on. Yes, they did some good things that are upstreamed in the kernel and elsewhere, credit where it's due, but it's beyond merciful to call this anything but a botched product. Pine64 put their phone out relatively quickly for the devs. A weak, early and raw device with big warnings letting people know that this was a DEV DEVICE and it was not for general consumption. Pine created the hardware themselves, but not the software and just cultivated an ecosystem where they'd support and work with third-party software distributions. They even did cycle runs where they'd ship different logos and operating system on the device to support the community. This is the way. I think people have good reason to call Purism out for their $1200-2000 Librem phones that have overheating issues and alpha-grade software, if they get delivered at all. There's no free pony here sure, but my $600 vapor pony wasn't free either.
- goodpoint 4y ago> people have good reason to call Purism out for their $1200-2000 Librem phones I fully agree. Yet I was referring exclusively to the complains around the whole FOSS ecosystem.
- monopoliessuck 4y agoAh okay, gotcha. Sorry for the rant then :+1:
- whateveracct 4y agoFree software phones are very important. But judging by this thread, we need more people with guts. So many doubters in here who aren't being useful in any way :) So - I think I'm going to run NixOS Mobile on a 2nd device (alongside my iPhone) in the next year-ish and provide some guts and elbow grease (PRs incoming!) Prepare to wish you did the hard thing for the fun of it :D