7 ms·
How to get a PhD in mathematics in a timely fashion (2020) [pdf]
- lemursage 4y ago« You will like any subject once you get to know enough about it. » this is a really important observation — good attitude will do wonders to your motivation for research.
- t_mann 4y ago> « You will like any subject once you get to know enough about it. » this is a really important observation And unfortunately false, as I've witnessed on multiple occasions. Don't underestimate mental health problems in academia, telling people that everything will fall into place if they just keep pushing can lead to bad outcomes.
- admissionsguy 4y ago> Don't underestimate mental health problems in academia Having dropped out of my PhD due to - mostly - mental health reasons, I don't fully understand the preoccupation with the mental health situation in academia. Not that it is not bad, but is it worse than in most other occupations? Or is it just that academia is mostly populated by people of at minimum middle class upbringing who are not supposed to experience hardship of any kind?
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoThe poor do not have a monopoly on suffering. The middle class constitutes a large/majority portion of a lot of western countries, it's odd to believe they are living perfect lives free of pain and hardship. Academia is the worst environment I've ever worked in, worse than any industry job I've ever had whether blue collar or white collar.
- atq2119 4y agoI suspect it is in part the combination of academia being a somewhat "normatively standard" path for people to take but, unlike most other such paths, inherently requires a lot of self-discipline and self-motivation. The result is that mental health issues may cause worse extreme outcomes, for the sort of person who can go into a PhD. The "standard" alternative path for somebody like that is some office job where you can just sort of muddle through: you may be deeply unhappy, but the money still comes in and it's easier to find satisfaction in other aspects of your life. There are other paths where self-discipline and self-motivation are important, like being an independent consultant, but those are generally not considered "normatively standard" paths for people to take. (My personal experience with academia was great. I was genuinely interested in the topics, had great colleagues and a great advisor. It probably helped that it was in maths, where there is money for decent pay but no lab work with which PhD students are routinely burdened.)
- t_mann 4y agoI wasn't actually saying anything about outside academia. Makes me wonder, is there a name for that sort of reasoning where one person asserts 'A is associated with B', and the response tries to turn it into an argument about !A? I guess it's not a strawman, but I'm sure the philosophers have come up with a name for it.
- watwut 4y agoMental health issues are not more likely to happen to middle class. Middle class do have them, of course, but lower classes have them more.
- sudosysgen 4y agoIt's statistically overrepresented in PhD students. Something like 40% fit the criteria for severe depression or severe anxiety.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Something like 40% fit the criteria for severe depression or severe anxiety. Psychological (indeed, medical) criteria are not necessarily all they're cracked up to be. https://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=3303 https://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=3303
- sudosysgen 4y agoThat's still higher than the general population.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThat would indicate either a problem in the population under discussion, or a problem with the diagnostic criteria.
- wbl 4y agoAcademia has a uniquely personal importance: your work is a reflection of your personal effort and interests for years. It's also very isolated: the only people who did what I did were hundreds of miles away at other institutions.
- badpun 4y agoDoing a PhD is a bit like doing a startup, in the way that you can work on something for years and produce nothing of value. This is way more stressful than regular job where your effort is validated every month with a paycheck. Many people are not built for this level of stress and uncertainty, but they're too young when they join the PhD program to know that about themselves yet.
- imgabe 4y agoI haven't done a Phd, but I always think of Paul Graham saying "If you think something's supposed to hurt, you won't notice if you're doing it wrong"
- lemursage 4y agoIt's not a statement about your general motivation for a PhD -- I don't think you can easily find a subject for which you will find a non-stop motivation 24h/7days for 3-4 years (or so, eqv. period required to get a PhD). If you encounter a dip in interest, which most likely will happen, you need to understand that changing a PhD is not always a best option -- just because it sounds good now, it doesn't mean it will in 2 years time. You supervisor should be there to guide you into interesting areas of research and may play a substantial role in rekindling your motivation. Naturally, mental health issues are another problem -- but I think they have often different origins than "just boredom" with subject. I may be completely wrong though.
- blippage 4y agoBrit here. It seems a little different than US. I didn't take any exams (except viva at the end). I was given some reports by PhD students/researchers working in a similar field in the same department as background reading. I thought that I'd never understand the stuff, but after awhile, it seemed fairly straightforward. My supervisor chose me rather than the other way around. It seemed an interesting subject, so I went for it. He set the subject and had a general idea of the direction it should be going. An alternative approach is to look at the PhD opportunities at various universities, and pick one that looks interesting. I don't think it's rocket science. The overwhelming number of theses will be a bunch of results that are "quite interesting" and extend the field incrementally. Don't expect to redefine the way people look at physics, mathematics, or whatever. My number one tip for getting a PhD in a timely fashion: work hard and don't arse around on the internet all day. You don't need the intellect of Gauss to get a PhD; although the brainier the better, obviously.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- groffee 4y ago> and don't arse around on the internet all day I feel personally attacked!
- Test0129 4y agoComprehensive entry exams are being done away with a lot of schools. At the university I went to (before I dropped from the program for financial reasons) I simply had to have gotten A's in my last 4 semesters of CS classes. The last 4 semesters are graduate courses, and undergrads simply do marginally less work. Comprehensive exams in my opinion are extremely dumb. You take some classes and to take more classes you need to take sometimes up to a year to cram 4 years of various CS trivia, most likely unrelated to your core interest, to sit a 4-5 hour long exam to prove you can regurgitate things. It really is trivia too. My advisor issued these exams and showed me one of the old ones. I am not sure how regurgitating the finer details of computer architecture will ever help me produce research in computational mathematics but apparently it was required. It's just yet another shibboleth of academia. It provides the illusion of exclusivity for a group that is so smart, they're too dumb to see comprehensives prove nothing.
- sumanthvepa 4y agoThat bit about researchers being the CEOs of their own little companies really resonated with me. I'm myself not a PhD, but I worked at IBM Research for a while in a business development role, and I amazed at how incredibly good the researchers in the lab were at sales (when they took the time off from their research to find a customer for their idea). I came to the conclusion that it was their training as PhDs and their need to constantly be pitching for grants. The process forces you to sell your ideas, even when there is no concrete 'product' yet. And that is not so different from how a startup CEO works. Not surprisingly, many of them have gone on to start their own companies very successfully, desipite never having managed anything bigger their lab printer before.
- meltyness 4y agoI feel like writing this in LaTeX is a way of saying, "someone should study this." My takeaways are the 20 hours a week. That's a hard wall to break through, beyond which you can't really consolidate, I'm running into that, and I don't have any BS to put up with. On finding an advisor -- why would a graduate even apply to a school without having selected a research interest / target? Undergrads are all research-exposed, so I don't know why you'd subject yourself to more if that wasn't your purpose! Yikes! What happened to the 3-4 LetRecs to even get in the door?!
- woopwoop 4y agoUndergrads are mostly not exposed to research in mathematics.
- klyrs 4y agoMathematician here. For me, writing in latex is the lowest possible barrier to making a document, because I write all my documents in latex. Professors get free and easy static webspace, fancier web services are a headache. It's not a statement. It's the familiar and accessible technology.
- sleepyams 4y agoI think this is good advice but also not the only possible path towards completing a PhD in math. I get a lot of fruitful research done while binge-watching television, for instance. The key is that you have to find something that works for you. For some that may be logging hours but I know a lot of people for whom logging hours is a hindrance. There are mathematicians who have to actively hold back from just doing research all the time, and for these types there's no point in logging hours. My point is that if you don't think the work ethic described in this article is agreeable, don't let that dissuade you from pursuing a PhD in math.
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis is a useful nuts-and-bolts discussion of the academic routine, but I'd disagree with this conclusion: > "It’s your company. Mathematicians each run a small business. We work in malls called math departments. Your company sells theorems. Your advisor is a free consultant for your company, not your boss, not your employee. Ultimately YOU are responsible for the success of your company..." The adoption of corporate entrepreneur model of academic research is one of the worst, if not the worst, things about the current American academic system. Why? First of all, who is funding this 'company'? Not you, in all likelihood - it's the tax-paying public who finances the majority of the funding train that keeps academic institutions afloat. What does the public expect in return, ideally? Well, how about producing highly skilled teachers, that seems important in a technological society, where mathematical skills are in general critically important. Hence, a critical part of the PhD student's job (and the professor's) is the instruction of the undergraduate population. This article doesn't even mention the importance of that role. Secondly, corporate research is highly secretive and non-collaborative in nature, as the goal is creation of intellectual property that can be sold on for a profit. This attitude is entirely at odds with the most successful acadamic model for making scientific progress, i.e. collaboration and rapid sharing of results. If you spend your time in academia worrying about people stealing your work and not trusting anyone, it's going to be a fairly miserable experience. My advice is to toss the corporate enterpreneur model in the garbage bin.
- huitzitziltzin 4y agoThe highlighted sentence is a metaphor and it’s the right one. You are selling in your academic career. You are selling results, papers, conference presentations, whatever counts among your peers in your field. You will not have a career as an academic in your field unless you can sell your work to your peers in the field. No one cares about your teaching, certainly not of undergrads (exceptions exist at some liberal arts colleges). Your department and your dean care about your research. That’s it. You have to sell it both to get it published and to get it cited. Do that and you’ll be fine. Don’t and you won’t have a career in a university.
- photochemsyn 4y ago
- j7ake 4y agoAuthor says 20 hours / week of research, but computer work counts as half was because they are not deep thoughts. So for computational heavy research, this would mean 40 hours per week. Taking the statement further, experimental research maybe counts as a quarter because debugging machinery is even less deep? This would be eye opening and maybe explains why experimental phds are so much more brutal in terms of working hours than theory.
- goethes_kind 4y agoNot every Ph.d requires the same amount of deep thought. Experimenting and hypothesizing and writing code is just not the same as logically deriving a new proof, but not any less worthy of a Ph.d.
- orbifold 4y agoOf course if you do theory you barely have to work more than 4 hours a day can be counterproductive unless you are embarking on a Lurie or Grothendieck style project and work 12 hour a day.
- bannedbybros 4y ago
- runeblaze 4y agoThis article seems great. I can't help but think that given the job market, the "best choice" for somebody in the program can often be to get a masters and go into industry, which honestly seems quite a bit easier than finishing a math PhD. The academia jobs are hard to get and they pay relatively terribly.
- _of 4y agomandatory phd comics: https://bashify.io/images/JAgsAM https://bashify.io/images/JAgsAM No but seriously, it was one of the best periods of my life. A lot of creativity, freedom and long nights working on things that are far away from the corporate world.
- graycat 4y agoStill easier: (1) Pick a practical problem in physical science, engineering, medicine, some other field, e.g., ecology, or business, a problem not yet solved. (2) Get a good solution to this practical problem, mostly using math, hopefully at least a little new math. For publication, the math is supposed to be "new, correct, and significant" -- get the "significant" part from how much the math does for the practical problem. In medicine, your work might save thousands of lives. In business, your work might make/save millions of dollars. In ecology, you might help clean up a river. (3) Surprising blunt academic fact of life: Academics is very short on money and understands clearly that very little of their new theoretical work has any near term practical value. So, academics understands that they are short on money mostly because their work is short on valuable, current applications. Indeed, the words and applications are commonly in the titles of journals. So, publish in such a journal. Some high end universities say that the requirement for a Ph.D. dissertation is "an original contribution to knowledge worthy of publication" -- so, remove all doubt and publish your work. Advisor? Show them the letter that your paper was accepted. Done, fully, de facto, essentially, or nearly so. Where to get the practical problem? Typically outside of a math department and maybe off campus. For a job? Long the main source of good jobs for a Ph.D. in math was US national security, heavily near DC. That may still be the case. If you have any hope of a career that lets you be financially responsible, e.g., support a family and provide for retirement, stay away from academic careers. Academics just quietly assumes that any recent Ph.D. is just obsessed with research, even apparently useless research, and will pursue it neglecting nearly everything else in life including being financially responsible. Instead, go into business, e.g., start a business, own 100% of it, and make it successful. The business is likely a sole proprietorship and LLC (limited liability company). In that business, maybe some math, new, or new to the field of the business, will be an advantage. In particular, currently take advantage of the not fully exploited amazing technology of current computing and the Internet.
- Test0129 4y ago> Academics just quietly assumes that any recent Ph.D. is just obsessed with research, even apparently useless research, and will pursue it neglecting nearly everything else in life including being financially responsible. This isn't even an assumption. It's borderline enforced. I dropped from the program after paying my own way because my lack of interest in being financially irresponsible put me at the bottom of the bin for good research opportunities. Academics force you to take 9-10/hr. and work 60 hours a week (of course on a contract for only 30 hours), because if they don't have the constant meat-mill of H1Bs and young financially irresponsible people the entire industry would collapse into itself. It's not unlike tech itself which relies on exploiting the revolving door of new grads to get cheap labor. The only difference is the new grad working for BigCo for sub-par dollars can usually afford to eat. Where I went to school the MAJORITY (not an exaggeration) were on some kind of assistance. Either food or housing. Post-docs were barely able to afford rent.
- peterhalburt33 4y agoAs a mathematician who works with many engineers and computer scientists, I wanted to expand on one of the points under the “Getting a Job” section. While it is certainly true that a mathematics education provides a great background for understanding other STEM fields, I would caution math Ph.D students who expect these jobs to be open to them because of their STEM connection: the onus is completely on you to bridge the gap between what you do and the field you want to work in. While it may be true that someone will hire you for your critical thinking skills (though I will personally say that I have never seen this happen), it is more likely that your deep specialization in a tangentially connected field (coupled with not being involved in the culture/conferences of the community you wish to enter) will be an impediment to entering a new field: you expect to be paid like a Ph.D., but will potentially require years of training to get up to speed. As an example, I remember the advice of “just go into data science” being handed out like candy to students interested in industry around the time I was in grad school (10 years ago). To be sure, there was a period where a STEM background + interest could get you in the door, but that time is over. These days you are competing with many equally brilliant students who have taken multiple courses and done research in this area, and it is highly unlikely that an employer will take a chance retraining an e.g. algebraic geometer with no precious data science experience to suit their needs. All this to say, if you have an interest in another area, you must know the players and their work in that area while simultaneously knowing your area in math. It is not easy by any means, you are essentially signing up for twice as much work learning your field and theirs, but the rewards are great - as a connector between two fields, you have precious expertise that is very employable across a broad range of industries (my first job out of grad school was essentially providing advice on research programs helping connect different STEM communities to government funding agencies, but I was able to use my connections from that job to get back into research).
- BossingAround 4y ago> the onus is completely on you to bridge the gap between what you do and the field you want to work in. Yes, like for everyone else. Sounds like when I was getting into the field with no formal comp sci education, only I was expecting this to be true :).
- 4y ago
- supernova87a 4y agoThere really is one question that people should grapple with early in their academic path, and think about hard (because it is rarely deliberately posed as a question to students): Unless you are extremely talented and have some gift for a very specific topic or subfield, I would argue that finding a good environment (e.g. lots of adjacent collaborative research opportunities, and other productive students) and a good advisor is far more important than any particular thesis topic. What I have observed is that few people at the end of their academic careers (esp. those who decide to do something else later) would say that the topic of their thesis was really all that important. They might have equally chosen some other related topic out of sheer luck or accident. Far more important were the experiences of: -- developing critical thinking -- how to organize your life and work methods while trying to get a research project done -- how to collaborate with others and use self-initiative to seek out opportunities -- learning how to pick yourself up after ideas fail, or how to power through adversity and difficulty phases in your work Almost all academic programs (or just tradition) make it seem like the thesis question you answer is the entire goal of your career. I doubt it. As I said maybe for the rare few with a calling to be expert in <xyz tensor manifold number theory> etc. etc. it matters. But given that so few people reach the pinnacle of academia, for many, many others, these things are far more important outcomes that you keep with you in life. Maybe it's a similar logic to "it doesn't actually matter that much what particular app you're building, it's that you launch something and have the experience of doing that, in prep for your next thing".
- kkwteh 4y agoWhat would have really helped me during my PhD, would have been to learn some project management skills. Just basic stuff like tracking where you’ve spent your time and using documents to track various projects. I wasn’t exposed to any of these things until I entered industry and by that time it was too late.
- why5s 4y ago> Computer programming work only counts at half the normal rate because debugging isn’t quite the same as deep thought. This mentality is the reason why most software originating from academia is awful. Productivity is measured by research output (i.e. conference/journal papers) rather than the artifacts (i.e. code/software) built to support said research.