3 ms·
> 'Seizing' is a legal term, where your property is taken and held by the government Doesn't that perfectly describe civil asset forfeiture? (What the parent
by kelnos 4y ago
> 'Seizing' is a legal term, where your property is taken and held by the government
Doesn't that perfectly describe civil asset forfeiture? (What the parent was talking about when referring to "seizure", not the wiretap stuff in this case.)
> So there's precedent for 'metadata' about people to be open to government without a warrant (especially if they are open to members of the public anyways)
Phone/messaging records are not open to members of the public, though.
> * And frankly it wouldn't be until 1967 that any substantive restriction was finally put on government use of electronic communications.*
Is that even necessary, though? I mean, we don't need to have a law on the books that says the US President must be 35 years or older; that's in the Constitution. Just like "no unreasonable searches or seizures". Certainly law can help codify and clarify specifically what a search consists of. But I think it's pretty uncontroversial to argue that much of what the US government does vacuuming up electronic data should constitute a "search".