5 ms·
Just for anybody caual browsing here; we can't just blame the radiation and isotopic waste: > During its years of operation, highly toxic chemical additives we
by defrost 4y ago
Just for anybody caual browsing here; we can't just blame the radiation and isotopic waste:
> During its years of operation, highly toxic chemical additives were widely used in order to power over 30,000 rocket engine tests and to clean the rocket test-stands afterwards.
> In addition, considerable nuclear research and at least four nuclear accidents occurred, which resulted in the SSFL becoming a seriously contaminated site and an offsite pollution source, requiring a sophisticated multi-agency Cleanup Project
- bb88 4y ago
- defrost 4y agoNo. Think of my comment as emphasing the range of the "Choose your toxic pollutant" offered up by lab activities over the decades.
- icehawk 4y agoGiven that the GP quotes "nuclear research and at least four nuclear accidents occurred" that's a pretty ungenerous assumption to make. That's not blame shifting, that's blame expansion; all of these causes are activities from the same organization, and the blame should be attributed to them.
- Spooky23 4y agoYou have to accept that HN has alot of technical/engineering folks who are trained to solve scoped problems. Some are very vocal proponents of nuclear energy, for valid reasons. Because nuclear technology and military requirements go hand in hand, you’re always going to have the dissembling, the misinformation and the propaganda elements tightly aligned with anything nuclear. Nobody ever knows the full story, and advocates can always latch on to some bizarre statistic, like “More people have been killed by cordless drills installing solar panels per gigawatt hour than have ever died from electric generation with nuclear power.”
- acidburnNSA 4y agoYeah I mean what are the dose rates? You need 100 mSv acute or 300 mSv over a year to get the first small increase of cancer risk from a baseline risk of 40%. Is anyone getting even remotely close to 300 mSv from this in a year? I highly doubt it. At that level every kid with a $50 Geiger counter from Amazon would see it everywhere. You can detect even a single atom decaying. The difference between the threshold of detection and the threshold of damage is astoundingly large in radiation. I'm pretty sure people are overblowing the radiological risks here without being quantitative. Let's talk dose rates in mSv/yr or not talk.
- defrost 4y ago> I'm pretty sure people are overblowing the radiological risks here without being quantitative. > Let's talk dose rates in mSv or not talk. You're only seeing the direct radiation risk here .. chances of being struck by a decaying particle from a hot pile of short half life material breaking down. There is a significant ongoing risk from toxic isotopes that aren't especially radioactive but nonetheless pose a toxic health risk (akin to straight up rare heavy metal poisoning). There is a related risk from 'biological isotopes' that are taken up within the food chain and concentrate in plants, animals and perhaps ultimately human bodies where slow damage is caused by slow breakdown (again, not highly radioactive).
- acidburnNSA 4y agoI don't think that's a serious concern from a radioactive meltdown of a small core. The major hazard is, was, and will remain measurable radioactive dose. Nuclear engineer here so I'm happy to look into whatever you're referring to. Got any publications describing this concern in more detail?
- defrost 4y ago> I don't think that's a serious concern from a radioactive meltdown of a small core. Was that the only issue over the years at this site though? Others have cited four 'incidents' reported (I have no idea what these were), various experiments and tests, and I imagine there's the implication of a legacy of less than rigorous material handling and storage being possible. From the wikipedia page: > At least four of the ten nuclear reactors had accidents during their operation. > The reactors located on the grounds of SSFL were considered experimental, and therefore had no containment structures. Given all that I'd say the possibilities are wide open. > Got any publications describing this concern in more detail? Your best bet might be to drop Alex Wellerstein a line and ask if he knows of (or knows anyone who knows of) what documents the DOE | NASA have released into the public domain and whether there are whispers of further releases in the wind. I tend to track things of this nature not in central north america. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Susana_Field_Laboratory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Susana_Field_Laboratory [2] https://alexwellerstein.com/writing/books/restricted-data/ https://alexwellerstein.com/writing/books/restricted-data/