4 ms·
> Mandarin also does not have direct equivalents of ‘yes’ and ‘no’. This is going a little too far; 是的 is a direct equivalent of "yes".
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> Mandarin also does not have direct equivalents of ‘yes’ and ‘no’.
This is going a little too far; 是的 is a direct equivalent of "yes".
- eloisius 4y agoIt’s the equivalent to ‘yes’ in a subset of contexts where ‘yes’ would make sense, for example ‘Is he the guy you were talking about?’ 「是的」 would make sense to say yes. But it wouldn’t work as an answer like ‘yes, I like hiking’.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Apocryphon 4y agoI suppose 對 would be able to cover the rest of the contexts.
- yibg 4y agoThat’s still not complete. You wouldn’t answer 對 to the question “do you like hiking?”. The standard answer would be “like”. Or the versatile 嗯
- Apocryphon 4y ago- 你喜歡爬山嗎? - 對,我喜歡 Sounds fine to me. Though I suppose that's more like saying "That's correct/right, I like hiking."
- yibg 4y agoYea exactly. In that phrasing you're putting an affirmation to the original question. Just "對" doesn't work.
- Apocryphon 4y agoI still think you can reply that way in conversation, because "That's correct" is a valid way to answer that question, imo. But sure, I guess 對 doesn't actually mean "yes" in the same way the word "yes" does.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Just "對" doesn't work. As with 是的, that isn't true. I knew one Chinese person who was very definite that 它 could not be used to refer to an inanimate object such as a folder or notebook. Instead, the object must be referred to with 这个. But I know other Chinese people who routinely refer to inanimate objects with 它.
- yibg 4y agoThe overall point is there isn't a single "yes". The equivalent of "yes" takes various forms depending on the context. "是的", "对" etc can all work depending on the question.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoBy that argument, English also has no direct equivalent of "yes". Sometimes you say "right". (Compare 对.) Sometimes you say "sure". But don't you think it's strange to claim that there is no English equivalent of an English word?
- thaumasiotes 4y agohttps://zhidao.baidu.com/question/1947367332200522468.html https://zhidao.baidu.com/question/1947367332200522468.html Where you can say 是的,我最喜欢爬山, you can obviously also just say 是的.
- yibg 4y agoThe full answer is ok, but just 是的 sounds weird even though people would understand your intent.
- mazlix 4y agoI wouldn’t say that. Maybe someone would understand what you mean but it’s definitely not as versatile as yes. I’d say the closest to yes is 嗯
- derekzhouzhen 4y agoIt is different. "是的" means "That's correct"; So if someone ask me "you don't smoke?" and I answer "是的" that means I don't smoke, which is actually what "no" means in standard English.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> So if someone ask me "you don't smoke?" and I answer "是的" that means I don't smoke, which is actually what "no" means in standard English. I don't think there's much to be learned by trying to examine this situation in English. Affirmative answers to negative questions are a source of frequent confusion among native speakers, suggesting that the rules of English are not clear on this point. If you said to me 你不是犹太人吧?, and I responded 是的, what would you think?
- derekzhouzhen 4y agoThere are clear rules in English and Chinese. English is absolute so "yes" means I am. Chinese is an echo language so "是的" means you are correct that I am not. However, I do see Chinese making mistakes in English and English speakers making mistakes in Chinese and I am not 100% free of the guilt. In the question "你不是犹太人吧?" there is already a "是“ in it, so a native speaker would use "对“ or "没错“ instead of "是的". They all means "correct" but by avoiding using "是" again, the chance of misunderstanding is minimized.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoI guess I have to draw your attention to these two sentences: > There are clear rules in English and Chinese. > They all mean "correct" but by avoiding using "是" again, the chance of misunderstanding is minimized. If the rules were clear, there would be no misunderstanding.
- derekzhouzhen 4y agoI mean there are clear rules in both English and Chinese `officially`. However, Chinese is such a lax language and can convey very different meanings with just tone differences, you don't want to take the chance if there is a better way.