7 ms·
One more clue to the Moon’s origin
- missedthecue 4y agoScientists believe the moon was formed by a collision into planet earth by another celestial body. Why didn't: 1. The other celestial body leave a very obvious elemental makeup in the collision point on earth? We can detect other asteroids, but this one was 100% identical to Earth's crust? 2. Why didn't the debris left by the collision form a ring around earth like Saturn? Instead it all coalesced into one compact body and left zero debris in a ring around earth. I am not an astrophysicist but these seem like obvious questions with no clear answers online after my quick Google search.
- towaway15463 4y agoIf the body was big enough it would have completely erased the earth’s crust, after cooling again our current crust would be a mixture of both bodies. Having an outsized moon might also degrade the orbit of any material that would have been left over after coalescing into the earth and moon.
- causi 4y ago1. The other celestial body leave a very obvious elemental makeup in the collision point on earth? We can detect other asteroids, but this one was 100% identical to Earth's crust? Earth's crust was rubble and magma. Sort of like how you couldn't find an impact point if you threw a water balloon into a can of paint. Why didn't the debris left by the collision form a ring around earth like Saturn? It did. Earth had very impressive rings for thousands of years after the impact.
- missedthecue 4y agoAh ok first point makes perfect sense. How do we know we had rings around earth for so long? And where did they go?
- vvilliamperez 4y agoRings of space debris coalesce into small celestial bodies over time. That's one theory of how moons form.
- Nux 4y agoGravity had them I guess. Saturn's going to lose the rings as well, and "soon" (hundreds or thousands of years).
- balfirevic 4y agoDid you mean hundreds or thounsands of millions of years?
- moffkalast 4y agoAbout 100-300 million years, and they only formed sometime in the last 100 million. A blink of an eye from a cosmic standpoint. For comparison, the dinosaurs existed before than the rings did.
- petrocrat 4y agodid a large collision during the era of the dinosaurs also form Saturn's rings then? If so what residual evidence of that collision do we know about?
- Nux 4y agoYes, my bad
- causi 4y agoThe short answer is "math". The material either coalesced into the moon or eventually fell back to earth. It's actually a pretty short lifetime for the rings, compared to ring systems like Saturn. Earth has several disadvantages when it comes to maintaining a set of rings. It doesn't have gravity strong enough for tidal forces to tear orbiting bodies apart at far remove from the planet and it doesn't have "shepherd moons" to keep ring material in a stable orbit.
- ajross 4y ago> but this one was 100% identical to Earth's crust? Given the size of this impact, the crust[1] didn't really survive. Most of the mantle material ended up vaporized and either falling back down or coalescing onto a single fragment, becoming the moon. It was a collision "of" the planet, not "on" the planet. [1] Which in any case wouldn't have survived this long anyway. The differentiation process that produces the crust we're standing on takes billions of years. There aren't any surface rocks that old, and wouldn't be even if the collision hadn't happened.
- changoplatanero 4y agoSome scientists believe that we can detect the place the moon hit the earth at. https://www.science.org/content/article/remains-impact-created-moon-may-lie-deep-within-earth https://www.science.org/content/article/remains-impact-creat...
- sokoloff 4y agoIt would be the place the earth was hit by an extraterrestrial body, which resulted in the creation of the moon, not the earth being hit by the moon.
- cossatot 4y agoThis isn't 'the place the moon hit', it's material from the colliding object (Theia) that has been added to the Earth's mantle. The mantle convects, and this material is a little more dense, and has pooled up at the bottom of the mantle, but because the mantle convects (the material circulates) there is no real reason to believe that these bodies are at the location of collision, especially considering that much of the mantle (and the parts of Theia that stayed behind) would have been reduced to flying bits of lava in orbit around the core, before coalescing.
- g6762736 4y agoOne of the hypotheses to explain the Large low-shear-velocity provinces at the Earth Mantle-Core boundary is that they are remnants of the impactor that lead to the formation of the Moon: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_low-shear-velocity_provinces#Possible_origin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_low-shear-velocity_provi...
- sfink 4y agoMy personal opinion, but informed by arguments from a number of "real" scientists: because that explanation is bogus. It never made much sense. A collision of a magnitude to break off a moon-sized chunk of mass would be enormous. And why wouldn't the chunk either escape or fall back down, rejoining the main mass? Do we have any evidence that such collisions ever result in significantly-sized orbiting bodies? Or maybe I'm just not understanding that "theory" well enough, because my current preferred hypothesis could be described in much the same way. Let's say there was a large collision, but it was when the Earth was hotter and more molten, and it added enough heat and instability (and perhaps angular momentum) that large globs were thrown off. Some escaped, some fell back down, and some were swept up by the largest glob, now the Moon. But either way, I think the answers to your objections are: (1) it was molten enough to meld together, OR it wasn't, in which case plate tectonics regularly replace the entirety of the crust (and underneath the magma layer is molten); and (2) the Moon cleared its orbit and the Earth is small enough to not support a large area to hold crud that makes up a ring? (All of this is guesswork.)
- hither_shores 4y agoAt these scales, there are no rigid bodies, and so no single "chunk". If the giant-impact account is correct, the moon coalesced out of ejecta in orbit. > And why wouldn't the chunk either escape or fall back down, rejoining the main mass? Some material likely did escape, but that takes much more energy than getting into orbit. You need to leave the surface of the Earth at about 11km/s to escape, but only 6km/s to reach lunar orbit.
- GolfPopper 4y agoIt wouldn't necessarily "break off" anything. If the angular momentum of the post-impact planetary mass reaches or exceeds orbital velocity, and its temperature is high enough, you get a novel type of celestial body - a synestia [1], a planet-sized hurricane of boiling rock. As the rock cools, magma rains inward re-fornming the Earth (Earth V2?) over decades, while everything far enough out (beyond the Roche limit [2]) would coalesce to form the Moon. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synestia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synestia 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roche_limit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roche_limit
- sixbrx 4y agoRe #1, one really cool thing is that the remains of Theia (the other body that collided with Earth) may be visible in a big way in Earth's mantle still, if recent study is correct. See https://skyandtelescope.org/astronomy-news/bits-of-theia-might-be-in-earths-mantle/ https://skyandtelescope.org/astronomy-news/bits-of-theia-mig...
- cscurmudgeon 4y ago> It was not until Galileo’s time, however, that scientists really began study it It is 2022 and yet we see mildly racist falsehoods like this. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surya_Siddhanta https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surya_Siddhanta the diameter of the moon as 2,400 miles (actual ~2,160)[6] and the distance between the moon and the earth to be 258,000 miles[6] (now known to vary: 221,500–252,700 miles (356,500–406,700 kilometres).[11] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aryabhata https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aryabhata Aryabhata also noted that the luminosity of the Moon and other planets is due to reflected sunlight.
- nickelcitymario 4y agoI'm not sure why this is getting downvoted... seems to be an accurate statement. The Surya Siddhanta predates Galileo by more than a millenia.
- sokoloff 4y agoI did not downvote, but my racism detector’s gain is not high enough to detect the racism here, which might be leading to downvotes. The earlier learnings are interesting; the accusation that racism has something to do with the omission is not.
- macintux 4y agoAgreed. If someone argued that geology began in the 1800s and neglected to mention Eratosthenes’ calculation of Earth’s size 2000 years earlier, I’d hardly say they’re showing an anti-Greek bias. In this case it’s more likely either ignorance or a different definition of “study”.
- nickelcitymario 4y agoThe article doesn't state that "astronomy" as a whole was invented by Galileo, but rather that the moon itself was never studied scientifically until his time. That's a patently false statement that requires dismissing the millennia of Indian observations and research on the moon. I'm pretty sure we could make similar arguments for the Middle East or Asia. It's like when they teach that everyone thought the world was flat back then. They didn't. That's a fairy tale. Some people thought that, but the idea that the Earth was in fact round was not a shocking finding to contemporary people. Likewise, geology as a field may have begun in the 1800s, but you wouldn't claim that no one tried to study any aspect of the earth before then. And if you did, I would describe that as being at least ignorant of Eratosthenes. (Actually, no I wouldn't, because I almost certainly wouldn't have thought of that precise example. But I digress.) Is the issue that "racist" just seems too harsh of a label for what may be a simple error? One can definitely argue there is a western bias in claiming Galileo as the starting point for studying the moon. Maybe conflating "western bias" with "racism" is a step too far.
- mvcalder 4y agoI always thought of Tom Dooley as a Kingston Trio song. The article cites The Greatful Dead.
- JackFr 4y agoIt’s a traditional folk song recorded by dozens of artists. The Kingston Trio are the only ones who charted with it.
- sammalloy 4y agoLink for those who want to read about the fascinating history of the tune: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Dooley_(song) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Dooley_(song)
- jbaber 4y agoThe hypothetical planet has a name (Theia). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theia_(planet) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theia_(planet)