5 ms·
There are legitimate criticism to blockchain technologies and arguments that could be made against its usefulness in the future. However, one of the things tha
by leolara 4y ago
There are legitimate criticism to blockchain technologies and arguments that could be made against its usefulness in the future.
However, one of the things that fuel my believe on blockchain is how many the arguments against it are falacies and/or full of ignorance like this one.
"Someone made the wrong assertion that git is blockchain IMPLIES THAT blockchain is going down and their adepts are desperate" a very simple fallacy to realize to be honest, not worthy of hacker news.
Also ignorant things like: "stumping up in a complicated, exclusionary, and non-existent proof-of-stake system its advocates claim is just around the corner every six months"
1. It is not complicated, I understand it
2. It is less exclusionary than proof of work
3. It exists
4. It launches next month (aprox 15th September) on Ethereum
- ddrdrck_ 4y agoAlso apart from Ethereum switch to PoS planned soon (hopefully), there is a lot of PoS blockchains in production today. Cosmos (ATOM) [0], for instance, is live since march 2019 and going very well, spawning a whole ecosystem of PoS blockcains using Cosmos SDK [1] [0] https://cosmos.network/ https://cosmos.network/ [1] https://www.coingecko.com/en/categories/cosmos-ecosystem https://www.coingecko.com/en/categories/cosmos-ecosystem
- remram 4y agoAt some fundamental level, blockchains do not generate money, it just moves it around. The idea that a content creator might be rewarded every time her site is shown, or every time her in-game items are used, or every time her painting is re-sold sounds attractive. But the idea that the rest of us might have to pay a micro-transaction every time we visit a site, or every time we use an in-game item, or every time we re-sell our property is repugnant. This is the fundamental problem with blockchain/web3 and you will notice that everyone shilling for it is very careful to focus on one side of the coin. The fact that some of those systems start to approach usability is also a very weak reason to switch from the existing usable systems. The non-buzzword web3 exists, works, and is called "micro-transactions".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ChadNauseam 4y agoBlockchains, like everything in existence besides central banks, can’t create money. (Cryptocurrencies are not money or currencies.) However, they can create value. I don’t find the idea of a microtransaction every time someone visits a site to be repugnant at all. It costs me money to send my site to people requesting it. Why shouldn’t I be able to say that my sending it to them is conditional on them compensating me for that cost? This doesn’t take a cryptocurrency to implement, I believe amazon used to have a similar service to facilitate sub-penny transactions. But it does take a cryptocurrency to implement it in a decentralized way, a way that’s credibly impartial, and can’t ban you because you irritated amazon, and can’t try to raise its take once network effects have set in. (Cryptocurrencies have their own problems, like the persistent issues with scaling, but let’s say those are solved within our lifetimes and the cost of doing something on Ethereum is within an OOM of doing it on AWS.) If something like this “pay me a tenth of a penny to view my site” became commonplace, that could enable new trades that otherwise couldn’t exist. For example, I’m not willing to put ads on my site and not enough people are going to donate to me to make updating my site not something I do out of the goodness of my heart. But if I could have this arrangement, maybe things would look different. It would be one more way of being compensated for making things that other people want to use, and it would have much better incentives than advertising. That’s an example of how cryptocurrencies can create value by moving money around.
- arinlen 4y ago> Blockchains, like everything in existence besides central banks, can’t create money. (Cryptocurrencies are not money or currencies.) However, they can create value. That's the type of facetious claim that leads everyone to tune off Blockchain/web3 snake oil salespersons. If your notion of value depends on your ability to generate artificial scarsity then it's not worth even debating. > I don’t find the idea of a microtransaction every time someone visits a site to be repugnant at all. It costs me money (...) Completely irrelevant. Like everything else in the whole world, if you're considering providing a service to the public but you think it would cost you too much to justify the trouble, then don't, and go do something fruitful with your life. Just because you can come up with an idea to provide something, that does not mean you are automatically owed profit or even revenue, nor does it mean you are free to force everyone to hand over their hard-earned money to you just because you want to install your parking meter on their mouse button.
- tromp 4y ago> It is less exclusionary than proof of work It is not as permissionless as PoW. Anybody can mine a GPU mineable coin, but to stake you need to find existing owners willing to sell you enough coins to stake with. This reflects the fact that PoW is also a distribution method in addition to a consensus method, while PoS is only the latter.
- Jasper_ 4y agoDo you have any explanations of proof of stake? I've tried to read https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/consensus-mechanisms/pos/ https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/consensus-mechanisms... and https://arxiv.org/pdf/2003.03052.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2003.03052.pdf but I feel they're intentionally obfuscated. I understand proof of work very well. I tried reading the Tezos proof-of-stake scheme [0], but it seems like it has some very obvious holes that leave security gaps wide open (namely, once you get to somewhere around 50%, probably less, you can completely predict and control the PRNG outputs, giving you full capture of the network), which makes me feel like I still don't quite understand it. I won't go into whether it's exclusionary or not. That depends on your economic viewpoint. Personally, I think they're about the same -- those with the wealth control the network. And they've consistently been pushing back The Merge's launch date less than a month than the go-to date. I remember when they wanted to launch it in April 2022. And then May. And then June [1]. [0] https://tezos.gitlab.io/active/proof_of_stake.html https://tezos.gitlab.io/active/proof_of_stake.html [1] https://eips.ethereum.org/EIPS/eip-4345 https://eips.ethereum.org/EIPS/eip-4345
- ChadNauseam 4y agoFormer protocol developer for Tezos here. Once you get to 33% of the stake you can stop the chain, so the idea that you could control the RNG at 50% isn’t that scary by comparison. You can only influence the RNG if you go last. That is to say, you could not completely predict or control the RNG unless you control 100% of the stake. At 50% of the stake, you go last 50% of the time, and even when you go last you don't have the ability to fully control the RNG (although you could do a pretty good job at 50%, at substantial expense to yourself). The only means anyone has of influencing the RNG is by not revealing their random contribution, which they're punished for by losing their staking rewards. (The original tezos whitepaper had a higher penalty, I believe you forfeit an additional "safety bond", but I don't know if that made it into the implementation.) The hope is that incentives like these are enough to discourage that behavior. All cryptocurrencies depend on incentives for security, in part for cases like these. But this is a particularly bad case where someone with a sub-33% stake could attack the chain. Fortunately, at <33% control of the stake, the damage you could cause from that attack is small and the attack would be very expensive, so it’s not considered a major problem. I think the worst you could do is censor some transactions for a time, and deprive some others of their staking rewards. (Although I was a protocol developer, I never worked on anything related to this, so don't take my word as gospel.)
- balefrost 4y agoAre you not doing the same thing that the author is doing? The author has a bias against blockchain, sees blockchain proponents making a poor argument, and that reinforces their bias against blockchains. You have a bias seemingly in favor of blockchains, you see a blockchain critic making a poor argument, and that reinforces your belief in blockchains. I think the linked post makes good points (e.g. git and blockchains are related but not broadly comparable) wrapped up in a lot of unnecessary opinion. Surely the rational approach is to just discount bad arguments, not to treat them as evidence to reinforce the opposite position.
- yunohn 4y ago> one of the things that fuel my believe on blockchain is how many the arguments against it are falacies and/or full of ignorance like this one. I’m not sure this is an argument really.
- robin_reala 4y ago“Less exclusionary than proof of work” doesn’t mean “is not exclusionary”.
- snarf21 4y agoSerious question: What problems do you feel blockchains solves? Just non-governmental currency? I've found another use case that isn't blockchain for blockchain's sake. Also, I don't follow Eth but are proof-of-stake pools prohibited? Can one address stake more than X (1?) Eth?
- DennisP 4y agoThere are working pools on Ethereum's proof-of-stake. Each validator node is 32 ETH but the pool can run multiple validators, and give people a way to deposit smaller amounts.
- Ajedi32 4y agoWhat problem does Mastodon solve? Just non-Twitter shortform social networking? What about Diaspora, PeerTube, etc? Not being beholden to a central authority (whether that authority be Twitter, PayPal, or the US government) is intrinsically valuable to a lot of people. Blockchains are just a convenient and proven way of enabling that sort of independence. Granted, decentralization is a bit of a niche, and the cryptocurrency gold rush has made it way more mainstream than it has any right to be at this point in time given its drawbacks. But that doesn't mean it's not valuable. As for blockchain specifically: yes, decentralized payments seems to be the primary use case. But once you have a decentralized payments system, that enables the creation of a whole bunch of other decentralized applications that would not have otherwise been possible. That's why most "blockchain" projects start with a currency and then build from there: it's hard to build decentralized cloud storage[1] or decentralized DNS[2][3] without first having a decentralized way to pay for those services. [1]: https://sia.tech/ https://sia.tech/ [2]: https://www.namecoin.org/ https://www.namecoin.org/ [3]: https://handshake.org/ https://handshake.org/
- namose 4y agoThe problem is that most use-cases for blockchain require being beholden to a central authority anyway, because a chain is only as strong as it’s weakest link, and it’s either impossible or prohibitively inefficient to also run distributed applications that interact with the blockchain. I think anyone who’s trying to achieve trustlessness by introducing more complexity into software is running a fools’ errand. Make simple, auditable systems.
- packetlost 4y agoI have a friend from college who works for a legitimate company that has a legitimate use for blockchain technology where it does actually seem to work pretty well. It's not a currency, there's no zero-trust model (instead, it's used for verifying very large datasets that are used by multiple companies/entities). I think there is some legitimate use for this type of tech, but currency is probably not one of them, and they're far more limited in practicality than what would be suggested by all the SV money being thrown into them.
- XorNot 4y agoIf it's not zero trust then why isn't it just a database? As soon as you have a trust model, "blockchain" goes out the window as a good answer.
- packetlost 4y agoWell, it technically meets the zero-trust definition, but it's not a core concern because it's entirely privately controlled by cooperative entities. It seems to be functioning more or less as a distributed verification database (the datasets are massive genetic sequences or something)